Throughout the mid-1990s, considerable misgivings have emerged about the value of regulation theory for concrete research. Whilst acknowledging much of this critique, I seek to operationalize some recent interpretations of the ‘geography of regulation’ and regulation-theoretic state theory towards an analysis of the governance of economic development in Lowland Scotland. I argue that, when suitably contextualized, these approaches help to foreground some complex issues of scale, particularly the interactions between national, regional, and local levels, as well as to highlight the integral politics which surround the governance of urban and regional spaces. In substantive terms, this paper focuses on the decision to replace the Scottish Development Agency with the Scottish Enterprise Network. The latter was heralded by the Conservative government as a new private-sector-led hegemon within Lowland Scotland's emerging form of ‘entrepreneurial’ governance. However, the discussion below demonstrates two key factors. First, that the formation of such ‘local enterprise’ was a highly politicized endeavour; one which needs to be understood within the context of the broader dynamics of a (then) centralizing British state. And, second, a key net effect of the new structure is that the informal networks and partnerships which characterized the mode of governance in the 1980s under the hegemony of the Scottish Development Agency have been jeopardized in and through the ‘turf wars’ which have accompanied the post-1991 institutional milieu. This political shaping of privatism within one of the United Kingdom's more institutionally endowed and relatively autonomous spaces thereby provides some lessons for a New Labour government committed towards reconfiguring the contours of regional economic development in the regions and nations of the United Kingdom.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adam Smith Institute, 1983The Omega ReportAdam Smith Institute (Research) Ltd, PO Box 316, London SW1P 3DJ
2.
AgliettaM, 1979A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US Experience (Verso, London)
3.
AminAThriftN, 1994a, “Living in the global”, in Globalization, Institutions, and Regional Development in Europe Eds AminAThriftN (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 1–19
4.
AminAThriftN (Eds), 1994bGlobalization, Institutions and Regional Development in Europe (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
5.
BainS, 1995, “Lack of trust”Scotland on Sunday 3 December, page 1
6.
BarnekovTBoyleRRichD, 1989Privatism and Urban Policy in Britain and the United States (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
7.
BennettRWicksPMcCoshanA, 1994Local Empowerment and Business Services: Britain's Experiment with Training and Enterprise Councils (UCL Press, London)
8.
BertramsenR, 1991, “From the capitalist state to the political economy”, in State, Economy and Society Eds BertramsenRThomsenJTorfingJ (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 1–34
9.
BonefeldWHollowayJ (Eds), 1991Post-Fordism and Social Form (Macmillan, London)
10.
BoyerR, 1990The Regulation School: A Critical Introduction (Columbia University Press, New York)
11.
BoyleMHughesG, 1995, “The politics of urban entrepreneurialism in Glasgow”Geoforum25453–470
12.
BurrowsRLoaderB (Eds), 1994Towards a Post-Fordist Welfare State? (Routledge, London)
13.
BuxtonJ, 1988, “A leap for enterprise”Financial Times 16 December, page 18
14.
CBI, 1993Making Labour Markets Work: CBI Policy Review of the Role of TECs and LECsConfederation of British Industry, Centre Point, New Oxford Street, London WC1
15.
CBI, 1994Manufacturing MattersScottish Manufacturing Group, Scottish Confederation of British Industry, Beresford House, 5 Claremont Terrace, Glasgow G3 7XT
16.
ClarkeJ, 1995, “Towards a post-Fordist welfare state? Review article”Local Government Studies11637–644
17.
CochraneA, 1993Whatever Happened to Local Government? (Open University Press, Milton Keynes)
18.
CookeP, 1995, “Keeping to the high road: Learning, reflexivity and associative governance in regional economic development”, in The Rise of the Rustbelt Ed. CookeP (UCL Press, London) pp 231–245
19.
CookePMorganK, 1993, “The network paradigm”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space11543–564
20.
COSLA, 1994The Operation of the Enterprise Agencies and the LECsScottish Affairs Select Committee Enquiry, memorandum by the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, Rosebery House, Edinburgh
21.
DansonMLloydGNewlandsD, 1989, “‘Scottish Enterprise’: Towards a model agency or a flawed initiative?”Regional Studies23557–563
22.
DansonMLloydGNewlandsD, 1993, “The role of regional development agencies in regional economic regeneration”, in Spatial Policy in a Divided Nation Eds HartMHarrisonR (Jessica Kingsley, London)
23.
DeakinNEdwardsJ, 1993The Enterprise Culture and the Inner City (Routledge, London)
24.
DoE, 1988, “Employment for the 1990s” command paper 540 (The Stationery Office, London)
25.
DoETR, 1997, “Regions invited to have their say”, press release from R Caborn MP, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
26.
DunfordMBenkoG (Eds), 1991Industrial Change and Regional Development: The Transformation of New Industrial Spaces (Pinter, London)
27.
EcclesA, 1994, “Urban political change in Scotland: The impact of Scottish Enterprise”, mimeograph, Department of Applied Social Studies, University of Paisley, Paisley PA1 2BE
28.
FairleyJ, 1989, “The Scotship Enterprise: Will it fly?”Radical Scotland volume 37, February/March issue, pp 24–26
29.
ForgacsD (Ed.), 1988A Gramsci Reader (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
30.
GambleA, 1994The Free Economy and the Strong State: The Politics of Thatcherism (Macmillan, London)
31.
GarmiseSMorganKReesG, 1995, “Networks and local economic development: Evidence from the Southeast, Wales and the West of England”, paper submitted at ESRC Conference on Local Governance, Exeter; copy available from S Garmise, Department of City and Regional Planning, University of Wales, Cardiff CF1 3NS
32.
GoodwinMPainterJ, 1997, “Concrete research, urban regimes, and regulation theory”, in Reconstructing Regime Theory: Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy Ed. LauriaM (Sage, London) pp 13–29
33.
GoodwinMClokePMilbourneP, 1995, “Regulation theory and rural research: Theorising contemporary rural change”Environment and Planning A271245–1260
34.
GoodwinMDuncanSHalfordS, 1993, “Regulation theory, the local state and the transition of urban politics”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1167–88
35.
GramsciA, 1971Selections from the Prison Notebooks (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
36.
GulliverS, 1984, “The area projects of the Scottish Development Agency”Town Planning Review55322–334
37.
HalkierH, 1992, “Development agencies and regional policy: The case of the Scottish Development Agency”Regional Politics and Policy21–26
38.
HallS, 1988The Hard Road to Renewal (Verso, London)
39.
HardingA, 1996, “The private side of public-private partnership: Contrasts and comparisons in European cities”, paper to the Department of Environment Seminar series on Local Governance, number 3: Public—Private Partnership, London; copy available from A Harding, European Institute of Urban Affairs, Liverpool Moores University, Liverpool L3 2ET
40.
HarveyD, 1985The Urbanization of Capital (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
41.
HarveyD, 1989, “From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation of urban governance in Late Capitalism”Geografiska Annaler71B3–17
42.
HarvieC, 1994Scotland and Nationalism (Routledge, London)
43.
HaughtonGPeckJStrangeI, 1997, “Turf wars: The battle for control over English local economic development”Local Government Studies2388–106
44.
HayCJessopB, 1995, “The governance of economic development and the development of local economic governance: A strategic relational approach”, paper to the American Political Science Association, Chicago; copy available from B Jessop, Department of Sociology, University of Lancaster, Lancaster LA1 4YW
45.
HealeyPCameronSDavoudiSGrahamSMadani-PourA (Eds), 1995Managing Cities: The New Urban Context (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
46.
HoodN, 1990, “Scottish Enterprise: The basis of a Scottish solution to Scottish problems?”Fraser of Allander Quarterly Economic Commentary16(2) 65–75
47.
HuttonW, 1995The State We're In (Jonathan Cape, London)
48.
IDS, 1986Summary of Treasury—Scottish Office Review of the SDAIndustry Department for Scotland, Edinburgh
49.
IDS, 1988, “Scottish Enterprise: A new approach to training and enterprise creation”, command paper 237, Industry Department for Scotland (The Stationery Office, London)
50.
JensonJ, 1990, “Representations in crisis: The roots of Canada's permeable Fordism”Canadian Journal of Political Science23653–683
51.
JensonJ, 1993, “Naming nations: Making nationalist claims in Canadian public discourse”Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology30337–358
52.
JessopB, 1985Nicos Poulantzas: Marxist Theory and Political Strategy (Macmillan, London)
53.
JessopB, 1990aState Theory: Putting Capitalist States in Their Place (Polity Press, Cambridge)
54.
JessopB, 1990b, “Regulation theories in retrospect and prospect”Economy and Society19153–216
55.
JessopB, 1991, “On the originality, legacy, and actuality of Nicos Poulantzas”Studies in Political Economy3475–106
56.
JessopB, 1992, “Regulation and politics: The integral economy and the integral state”, mimeograph, Department of Sociology, University of Lancaster, Lancaster LA1 4YW, pp 1–30
57.
JessopB, 1994, “Post-Fordism and the state”, in Post-Fordism: A Reader Ed. AminA (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 251–279
58.
JessopB, 1995a, “The future of the nation state: Erosion or reorganisation?”, Lancaster Regionalism Group, WP-50 (governance series) University of Lancaster, Lancaster LA1 4YW
59.
JessopB, 1995b, “The regulation approach, governance and post-Fordism: Alternative perspectives on economic and political change?”Economy and Society24307–333
60.
JessopB, 1995c, “Towards a Schumpeterian workfare regime in Britain? Reflections on regulation, governance, and the welfare state”Environment and Planning A271613–1626
61.
JessopB, 1997, “A neo-Gramscian approach to the regulation of urban regimes: Accumulation strategies, hegemonic projects, and governance”, in Reconstructing Urban Regime Theory Ed. LauriaM (Sage, London) pp 51–74
62.
JessopBBonnettKBromleySLingT, 1988Thatcherism: A Tale of Two Nations (Polity Press, Cambridge)
63.
JonesMR, 1996, “Full steam ahead to a workfare state? Analysing the UK Employment Department's abolition”Policy and Politics24137–157
64.
JonesMR, 1997, “Spatial selectivity of the state? The regulationist enigma and local struggles over economic governance”Environment and Planning A29831–864
65.
JonesMR, 1998, “Restructuring the local state: Economic governance or social regulation?”Political Geography17(7) forthcoming
66.
JonesMRWardK, 1997, “Crisis and disorder in British local economic development: Business Link and the Single Regeneration Budget”Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management5154–165
67.
KearnsGPhiloC (Eds), 1993Selling Places: The City as Cultural Capital, Past and Present (Pergamon Press, Oxford)
KeatingMBoyleR, 1986Re-Making Urban Scotland (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
70.
KooimanJvan VlietM, 1993, “Governance and public management”, in Managing Public Organizations: Lessons from Contemporary European Experience Eds EliassenKKooimanJ (Sage, London) pp 58–72
71.
LauriaM (Ed.), 1997Reconstructing Regime Theory: Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy (Sage, London)
Le GrandJ, 1990, “Quasi-markets and social policy”, research briefing number 9, Economic and Social Research Council, Polaris House, North Star Avenue, Swindon SN2 1US
74.
LeyshonATickellA, 1994, “Money order? The discursive construction of Bretton Woods and the making and breaking of regulatory space”Environment and Planning A261861–1890
75.
LipietzA, 1986, “New tendencies in the international division of labour: Regimes of accumulation and modes of regulation”, in Production, Work and Territory: The Geography of Industrial Capitalism Eds ScottAStorperM (Allen and Unwin, Winchester, MA) pp 16–40
76.
LipietzA, 1994a, “The national and the regional: Their autonomy vis-à-vis the capitalist world crisis”, in Transcending the State-Global Divide: A Neo-Structuralist Agenda in International Relations Eds PalanRGillsB (Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO) pp 23–43
77.
LipietzA, 1994b, “Post-Fordism and democracy”, in Post-Fordism: A Reader Ed. AminA (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 338–357
78.
LoveringJ, 1995, “Creating discourses rather than jobs: The crisis in the cities and the transition fantasies of intellectuals and policy makers”, in Managing Cities: The New Urban Context Eds HealeyPCameronSDavoudiSGrahamSMadani-PourA (John Wiley, London) pp 109–126
79.
MacLeodG, 1997, “Globalizing Parisian thought-waves: Recent advances in the study of social regulation, discourse, politics and space”Progress in Human Geography21530–554
80.
MacLeodGJonesMR, 1999, “Re-regulating a regional rustbelt: Institutional fixes, entrepreneurial discourse, and the ‘politics of representation’”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space forthcoming
81.
MarrA, 1995The Battle for Scotland (Penguin, London)
82.
MasseyD, 1977, “Regionalism: Some current issues”Capital and Class6106–125
83.
MooreCBoothS, 1989Managing Competition: Meso-Corporatism, Pluralism, and the Negotiated Order in Scotland (Oxford University Press)
84.
MorganK, 1997, “The learning region: Institutions, innovation and regional renewal”Regional Studies31491–503
85.
MorganKRobertsE, 1993, “The democratic deficit: A guide to quangoland”; copy available from the Department of City and Regional Planning, University of Wales, Cardiff CF1 3NS
86.
MoulaertFSwyngedouwF, 1989, “A regulation approach to the geography of flexible production systems”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space7327–345
87.
MurphyPCabornR, 1996, “Regional government—an economic imperative”, in The State and the Nations: The Politics of Devolution Ed. TindaleS, Institute for Public Policy Research, 30 Southampton Street, London
88.
Nolan Committee, 1995Local Public Spending Bodies: Issues and Questions (The Stationery Office, London)
89.
OffeC, 1974, “Structural problems of the capitalist state”German Political Studies131–57
90.
OsborneDGaeblerT, 1992Reinventing Government (Addison-Wesley, Wokingham, Berks)
91.
PaasiA, 1991, “Deconstructing regions: Notes on the scales of spatial life”Environment and Planning A23239–256
92.
PainterJ, 1997, “Regulation, regime and practice in urban politics”, in Reconstructing Regime Theory: Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy Ed. LauriaM (Sage, London) pp 122–143
93.
PainterJGoodwinM, 1995, “Local governance and concrete research: Investigating the uneven development of regulation”Economy and Society24334–356
94.
PatersonL, 1994The Autonomy of Modern Scotland (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
95.
PeckJ, 1995a, “Moving and shaking: Business elites, state localism and urban privatism”Progress in Human Geography1916–46
96.
PeckJ, 1995bLocal Empowerment and Business Services: Britain's Experiment with Training and Enterprise Councils by R J Bennett, P Wicks, A McCoshan Environment and Planning A27669–670
97.
PeckJJonesM, 1995, “Training and Enterprise Councils: Schumpeterian workfare state or what?”Environment and Planning A271361–1396
98.
PeckJTickellA, 1992, “Local modes of social regulation? Regulation theory, Thatcherism and uneven development”Geoforum23347–363
99.
PeckJTickellA, 1995a, “The social regulation of uneven development: ‘regulatory deficit’, England's South East, and the collapse of Thatcherism”Environment and Planning A2715–40
100.
PeckJTickellA, 1995b, “Business goes local: Dissecting the business agenda in Manchester”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research1955–78
101.
PoulantzasN, 1978State, Power, Socialism (New Left Books, London)
102.
PutnamR, 1993, “What makes democracy work?”Civic Infrastructure Spring issue, pp 101–107
103.
RhodesR, 1995, “The new governance: Governing without government”, seminar 2 of The State of Britain seminar series, Economic and Social Research Council, Polaris House, North Star Avenue, Swindon SN2 1US
104.
RobertsonG, 1996, “Economic Development Strategies for the Twenty First Century”, speech by the shadow Scottish secretary, Cameron House Hotel, Loch Lomond, 11 October; transcript available from the Scottish Labour Party, Keir Hardie House, 1 Lynedoch Place, Glasgow G3 6AB
105.
RoseNMillerP, 1992, “Political power beyond the state: Problematics of government”British Journal of Sociology43175–205
106.
SabelC, 1993, “Studied trust: Building new forms of cooperation in a volatile economy”Human Relations461133–1170
107.
SadlerD, 1992The Global Region (Pergamon Press, Oxford)
108.
SadlerD, 1993, “Place-marketing, competitive places and the construction of hegemony in Britain in the 1980s”, in Selling Places: The City as Cultural Capital, Past and Present Eds KearnsGPhiloC (Pergamon Press, Oxford) pp 175–192
109.
SaundersP, 1984, “Rethinking local politics”, in Local Socialism Eds BoddyMFudgeC (Macmillan, London) pp 22–48
110.
SCC, 1995Evidence for the Nolan Committee on Local Public Spending Bodies and Enterprise Companies Scottish Chambers of Commerce, Conference House, The Exchange, 152 Morrison Street, Edinburgh EH3 8EB
111.
ScottAStorperM (Eds), 1992Pathways to Industrialization and Regional Development (Routledge, London)
112.
ScottR, 1991, “The SDA ain' broke but it is being fixed”The Independent 22 January, page 13
113.
Scottish Affairs Committee, 1995The Operation of the Enterprise Agencies and the LECs volume 1 (The Stationery Office, London)
114.
Scottish Enterprise, 1992Strategies for the 1990sScottish Enterprise, 120 Bothwell Street, Glasgow G2 7JP
StoneC, 1989Regime Politics: Governing Atlanta 1946–88 (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence)
126.
STUC, 1994The Operation of the Enterprise Agencies and the LECs. Scottish Affairs Select Committee Enquiry memorandum by the Scottish Trades Union Congress, 16 Woodlands Terrace, Glasgow G3 6DF
127.
The Economist1988, “What the Scots can teach the English about creating jobs” 17 September, pp 33–34
128.
The Scotsman1987, 24 November
129.
The Scotsman1995, “The fishy side of networking—editorial”, 24 January, page 10
TickellAPeckJ, 1992, “Accumulation, regulation, and the geographies of post-Fordism: Missing links in regulationist research”Progress in Human Geography16190–218
132.
TindaleS (Ed.), 1996The State and the Nations: The Politics of DevolutionInstitute for Public Policy Research, 30 Southampton Street, London
133.
WilsonI, 1995, “Enterprise told it must open up”The Herald 4 April, page 6
134.
YoungA, 1997, “A cleansing in quangoland”The Herald 16 May, page 15
