Scholarly study of the European Community (EC) has concentrated on the macrolevel process of regional integration to the neglect of its ‘internal’ policy processes. A newly emerging literature on EC public policy is beginning to address this imbalance, but it is largely focused on the development of policy outputs culminating in the adoption of policies by the Council of Ministers, rather than the long-term outcomes of policy at the national and subnational levels. This paper develops a multitheoretical framework and applies it to a case study of the implementation of the Directive on bathing water in the United Kingdom and France to reveal the sort of intriguing questions and puzzles which emerge in the ‘postdecisional’ phase of the EC policy process. The study draws comparisons between implementation in the two countries, showing that policy ‘making’ and retuning continued long after the formal point of adoption. As in national systems, policy implementation and the interpretation and evaluation of policy outcomes in the EC are just as much part of the political process as agenda setting and policy framing.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersenSElliassenK, (Eds), 1993Making Policy in Europe (Sage, London)
2.
BarrettSFudgeC, (Eds), 1981Policy and Action: Essays on the Implementation of Public Policy (Methuen, London)
3.
BarrowG, 1981, “Microbial pollution of coasts”Water Pollution Control10221–230
4.
Bodiguel M and others, 1996La Qualité des Eaux dans l'Union Européenne: Pratiques d'une Réglementation Commune (L'Harmattan, Paris)
5.
BondR, 1994, “Lucky dip: Bathing in British water”The Surveyor 4 August, pages 20–22
6.
BullerH, 1996, “Privatisation and Europeanisation: The changing context of water supply in Britain and France”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management39461–482
7.
BungartensH, 1978Umweltpolitik in Westeuropa (Europa Union Verlag, Bonn)
8.
CEC, 1976, “Council Directive of 8 December 1975 (76/160/EEC) concerning the quality of bathing water”Official Journal of the European Communities Number L 31/1-7 (Commission of the European Communities, Brussels)
9.
CEC, 1995, “Quality of bathing water—1994 bathing season” EUR 15976 (Commission of the European Communities, Brussels)
10.
CEC, 1996, “Quality of bathing water—1995 bathing season” EUR 16755 (Commission of the European Communities, Brussels)
11.
CollinsKEarnshawD, 1992, “The implementation and enforcement of EC environmental policy”Environmental Politics1213–249
12.
DoE, 1989, “£1.1 billion improvements to bathing water”DoE News Release number 547, 20 October
13.
ENDS, 1997, “Water companies increase moves to sewage disinfection”Environmental Data Services (ENDS) Reportnumber 264, 14–15
14.
ErnstJ, 1994Whose Utility? The Social Impact of Public Utility Privatisation and Regulation in Britain (Open University Press, Milton Keynes)
15.
HaighN, 1984EEC Environmental Policy and BritainEnvironmental Data Services Ltd, Unit 24, 40 Bowling Green Lane, London EC1
16.
HaighN, 1986, “Devolved responsibility and centralisation: Effects of EEC environmental policy”Public Administration64197–207
17.
HaighNLaniganC, 1995, “Impact of the European union on UK environmental policy making”, in UK Environmental Policy in the 1990s Ed. GrayT, (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 18–37
18.
HajerM, 1993, “Discourse coalitions and the institutionalisation of practice”, in The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning Eds FischerFForesterF, (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 43–76
19.
HallP, 1993, “Policy paradigms, social learning and the state”Comparative Politics25275–296
20.
HamCHillM, 1993The Policy Process in the Modern Capitalist State (Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead)
21.
HanfK, 1982, “Regulatory structures: Enforcement as implementation”European Journal of Political Research10159–172
22.
HecloH, 1974Modern Social Politics in Britain and Sweden (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
23.
HermineF, 1994, “Sous la plage, le pavé de la pollution”Décision Environnement2860–61
24.
HOCSCE, 1990Pollution of Beaches Volume 1, Report, HC paper 12-I, House of Commons Select Committee on the Environment (Stationery Office, London)
25.
HOCSCWA, 1985Coastal Sewage Pollution in Wales, Volume I House of Commons Select Committee on Welsh Affairs (Stationery Office, London)
26.
HOLSCEC, 1995Bathing Water Revisited House of Lords Select Committee on the European Communities (Stationery Office, London)
27.
JohnP, 1996, “Centralisation, decentralisation and the European Union: The dynamics of triadic relationships”Public Administration74293–313
28.
JordanA, 1995, “From Brussels to Blackpool and Southport: ‘post-decisional’ politics in the EC”, in Contemporary Political Studies — 1996, Volume Three Eds Hampsher-MonkIStanyerG, (Political Studies Association, Belfast) pp 1897–1906
29.
JordanAJ, 1997, “‘Bridging the divide’ between comparative politics and international relations approaches to the EC: What role for ‘post-decisional’ politics?”, West European Politics20(4) 43–70
30.
JordanAGreenawayJ, 1997, “Paradigm shift or muddling through: British coastal water policy 1955–1995”, WP GEC 97-01, Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment, University of East Anglia, Norwich, Norfolk
31.
KrämerL, 1989, “Environment and industry: Towards a common agenda”RSA Journal137243–248
32.
KramerL, 1995EC Treaty and Environmental Law2nd edition (Sweet and Maxwell, London)
33.
LevittR, 1980Implementing Public Policy (Croom Helm, London)
34.
MajoneGWildavskyA, 1978, “Implementation as evolution”, in Policy Studies Annual Review Ed. FreemanH, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 103–117
35.
MaloneyWRichardsonJ, 1994, “Water policy making in England and Wales: Policy communities under pressure?”Environmental Politics3110–138
36.
MarshDRhodesR, 1992Policy Networks in British Government (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
37.
MazeySRichardsonJ, 1993Lobbying in the EC (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
38.
Medical Research Council, 1959, “Sewage contamination of coastal bathing waters in England and Wales”Journal of Hygiene57435–472
39.
Ministère de l'Environnement, 1995aQualité des eaux de baignade, résultats 1994 (Ministère de l'Environnement and Ministère de la Santé, Paris)
40.
Ministère de l'Environnement, 1995bCauses de pollution des baignades et actions engagées, résultats, 1994 (Ministère de l'Environnement and Ministère de la Santé, Paris)
41.
MooreB, 1954, “Sewage contamination of coastal bathing waters”Bulletin of Hygiene29689–704
42.
MooreB, 1970, “Public health aspects”, paper presented at an Institute of Water Pollution Control Symposium, “Water Pollution Control in Coastal Areas”, May, Bournemouth; copy available from the authors
43.
MooreB, 1977, “The EEC bathing water directive”Marine Pollution Bulletin8269–272
44.
National Consumer Council, 1994Water Price Controls: Key Consumer ConcernsNational Consumer Council, 20 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1
45.
NRA, 1989, “Memorandum submitted by the NRA”, in Pollution of Beaches: Volume II, Minutes of Evidence HOCSCE National Rivers Authority (Stationery Office, London) pp 29–56
46.
PetersG, 1992, “Politics and the institutions of the EC”, in Euro-Politics: Institutions and Policy Making in the ‘New’ EC Ed. SbragiaA, (The Brookings Institute, Washington, DC) pp 75–122
47.
PetersG, 1994, “Agenda-setting in the EC”Journal of European Public Policy19–26
48.
PetersonJ, 1995, “Decision making in the European Union”European Journal of Public Policy269–94
49.
PuchalaD, 1975, “Domestic politics and regional harmonisation in the European Communities”World Politics27496–520
50.
QuetinB, 1987, “Sea outfalls for industrial and sea effluent—French practice”, in Marine Treatment of Sewage and Sludge Institute of Civil Engineers (Thomas Telford, London) pp 69–77
51.
RehbinderEStewartR, 1985Environmental Protection Policy (de Gruyter, Berlin)
52.
RhodesR, 1981Control and Power in Central—Local Government Relations (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
53.
RhodesR, 1986European Policy Making, Implementation and Sub-central Governments: A Survey (European Institute of Public Administration, Maastricht)
54.
SabatierP, 1986a, “What can we learn from implementation research?”, in Guidance, Control and Performance Evaluation Eds KaufmannFOstromEMajoneG, (De Gruyter, Berlin) pp 313–325
55.
SabatierP, 1986b, “Top-down and bottom up approaches to implementation research: A critical analysis and suggested synthesis”Journal of Public Policy621–48
56.
SabatierPJenkins-SmithH, (Eds), 1993Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
57.
SbragiaA, (Ed.), 1992Euro-politics: Institutions and Policy Making in the ‘New’ EC (The Brookings Institute, Washington, DC)
58.
TarrowS, 1995, “The Europeanisation of conflict: Reflections from a social movement perspective”West European Politics18223–251
59.
Van HornC, 1979Implementation in the Federal System (Lexington Books, Lexington, MA)
60.
WallaceH, 1995, “Britain out on a limb?”The Political Quarterly6646–58
61.
WardNBullerHLoweP, 1996, “The Europeanisation of local environmental politics: Bathing water pollution in South West England”Local Environment121–32
62.
WardNLowePBullerH, 1995Implementing European Environmental Policy at the Local Level: The UK Experience with Water Quality Directives volumes 1 and 2, Centre for Rural Economy, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne
63.
WealeA, 1992a, “Implementation: A suitable case for review?”, in Achieving Environmental Goals Ed. LykkeE, (Belhaven, London) pp 43–66
64.
WealeA, 1992bThe New Politics of Pollution Control (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
65.
WildavskyA, 1979Speaking Truth to Power (Macmillan, London)
66.
WRC, 1994Health Effects of Sea Bathing Phase III final report, Water Research Centre plc, Henley Road, Medmenham, Marlow SL7 2HD
