In this paper we consider the extent to which manufacturing activity in London in the 1980s has been influenced by a ‘crowding-out’ effect as a result of the expansion of ‘global-city’ functions within the capital. First, a brief outline is provided of the concept of the global city and the related interpretations of urban manufacturing change. We then examine the relevance of global-city hypotheses, focusing on three different empirical aspects of London's manufacturing in the 1980s—employment change, floorspace and land-use issues, and change in firm stock, output, and productivity. The conclusion is that the ‘crowding-out’ hypothesis of manufacturing change expressed in the literature on global cities is not demonstrated by the existing evidence, and that such an hypothesis is an oversimplified way of examining the complexities of manufacturing change across London over this period.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BrothertonI, 1984, “A response to McNamara and Healey”Town Planning Review5597–101
2.
BuckNGordonIYoungK, 1986The London Employment Problem (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
3.
BuckNDrennanMNewtonK, 1991, “Dynamics of the metropolitan economy”, in Divided Cities: New York and London in the Contemporary World Eds FainsteinSGordonIHarloeM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 68–104
4.
CSO, 1979–1994Regional Trends Central Statistical Office (HMSO, London)
5.
CSO, 1981Indexes to the Standard Industrial Classification Revised 1980 Central Statistical Office (HMSO, London)
6.
CloutHWoodP (Eds), 1986London: Problems of Change (Longman, Harlow, Essex)
7.
CohenR, 1981, “The new international division of labour: multinational corporations and the urban hierarchy”, in Urbanisation and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society Eds DearMAllenS (Methuen, New York)
8.
CowanSGordonI, 1993, “Industrial land demand in London”Planning Advisory Group, Romford, Essex
9.
DE, 1984–91New Earnings Survey Department of Employment (HMSO, London)
10.
DoE, 1986Commercial and Industrial Floorspace Statistics Department of the Environment (HMSO, London)
11.
FothergillSGudginG, 1982Unequal Growth: Urban and Regional Employment Change in the UK (Heinemann, London)
12.
FothergillSKitsonMMonkS, 1985Urban Industrial Change: The Causes of the Urban Rural Contrast in Manufacturing Employment Trends (HMSO, London)
13.
FriedmanJWoolfG, 1982, “World city formation: an agenda for research and action”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research6309–344
14.
FrostM E, 1991, “Change in economic structure and opportunity”, in London: A New Metropolitan Geography Eds HoggartKGreenD R (Edward Arnold, London) pp 34–50
15.
FrostMSpenceN, 1991a, “British employment in the eighties: the spatial, structural and compositional change of the workforce”Progress in Planning32(2) 75–168
16.
FrostMSpenceN, 1991b, “Employment change in Central London in the 1980s. 1 The record of the 1980s”Geographical Journal1571–12
17.
FrostMSpenceN, 1991c, “Employment change in Central London in the 1980s. 2 Understanding recent forces for change and future development constraints”Geographical Journal157125–135
18.
FrostMSpenceN, 1993, “Global city characteristics and Central London's employment”Urban Studies30547–558
19.
GordonIHarlowM, 1991, “A dual to New York? London in the 1980s”, in Dual City: Restructuring New York Eds MollenkopfJ HCastellsM (Russell Sage Foundation, New York) pp 377–396
20.
GrahamDSpenceN, 1995, “Contemporary deindustrialisation and tertiarisation in the London economy”Urban Studies32885–911
21.
HallP, 1962The Industries of London Since 1861 (Hutchinson, London)
22.
HallP, 1964, “Industrial London: a general view”, in Greater London Eds CoppockJPriceH (Faber and Faber, London) pp 225–245
23.
HallP, 1989London 2001 (Unwin Hyman, London)
24.
HamiltonF E, 1991, “A new geography of London's manufacturing”, in London: A New Metropolitan Geography Eds HoggartKGreenD R (Edward Arnold, London) pp 51–78
25.
HarloeMFainsteinF, 1991, “Conclusion: the divided cities”, in Divided Cities: New York and London in the Contemporary World Eds FainsteinSGordonIHarloeM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 236–268
26.
HebbertM, 1989, “Research uses of development control data”, in Development Control Data: A Research Guide Ed. HebbertM (ESRC, Swindon) pp 1–13
27.
HomeR, 1989Planning Use Classes: A Guide to the Use Classes Order (BSP Professional, Oxford)
28.
KeebleD, 1976Industrial Location and Planning in the United Kingdom (Methuen, London)
29.
McNamaraPHealeyP, 1984, “The limitations of development control data in planning research”Town Planning Review5591–97
30.
McNamaraPMcNamaraGMathraniS, 1989, “District council storage and use of development control data”, in Development Control Data: A Research Guide Ed. HebbertM (ESRC, Swindon) pp 25–34
31.
RowthornB, 1986, “Deindustrialisation of Britain”, in The Geography of Deindustrialisation Eds MartinRRowthornB (Macmillan, London) pp 1–27
32.
RydinY, 1989, “A beginner's guide to development control”, in Development Control Data: A Research Guide Ed. HebbertM (ESRC, Swindon) pp 15–24
33.
SassenS, 1991The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
34.
SassenS, 1994Cities in a World Economy (Pine Forge Press, London)
