Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 1995-3
The Employment Structure of the Sunday Labour Market in Retailing: A Comparative Analysis of DIY and Grocery Superstores in Scotland and in England and Wales
Sunday trading in Scotland is an established feature integral to the retail operations of many companies. This requires that a considerable number of people take up paid employment on Sunday. Illegal Sunday trading in England and Wales, particularly since Christmas 1991, has made similar demands on retail staff. In this paper Sunday employment in superstores in Scotland with its more established and legal Sunday working, is compared with England and Wales, with their more recent and illegal opening pattern. It is concluded that a number of differences do exist, particularly in grocery superstores. Key findings include the high number of Sunday-only workers and a lower proportion of workers on premium rates in Scotland. When Sunday trading is legalised and established in England and Wales it would be expected that the employment pattern would come to mirror more closely the Scottish situation. These findings are discussed in the context of employment change and spatial-legal debates.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Area1984, “Geographical evidence to the Committee of Inquiry on the Shops Acts”Area16233–243
AtkinsonJMeagerN, 1985Changing Working Patterns (National Economic Development Office, London)
4.
AuldCommittee, 1984The Shops Act Late Night and Sunday Opening: Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Proposals to Amend the Shops Acts Cmnd 9376 (HMSO, London)
5.
BlomleyN K, 1985, “The Shops Act (1950): The politics and the policing”Area1725–33
6.
BlomleyN K, 1986, “Regulatory legislation and the legitimation crisis of the state: The enforcement of the Shops Act (1950)”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space4183–200
7.
BlomleyN K, 1987a, “Retail regulation in England and Wales: The results of a survey”Environment and Planning A191399–1406
8.
BlomleyN K, 1987b, “Legal interpretation: The geography of law”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie78265–275
9.
BlomleyN K, 1988, “Law and the local state: Enforcement in action”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: New Series13199–210
10.
BlomleyN K, 1989, “Text and context: Rethinking the law-space nexus”Progress in Human Geography13512–534
11.
BlomleyN KClarkG L, 1990, “Law, theory and geography”Urban Geography11433–446
BroadbridgeA, 1991, “Image and goods: Women in retailing”, in Working Women Eds RedcliftNSinclairM T (Routledge, Chapman and Hall, Andover, Hants) pp 42–55
14.
BroadbridgeA, 1995, “Female and male earnings differentials in retailing”Service Industries Journal15 forthcoming
15.
BroadbridgeADaviesK, 1993, “Management education at a distance and its effects on career progression”Distance Education14(1) 6–26
16.
BurkeT, 1988, “Sunday trading in Scotland”, WP-32, Faculty of Social Sciences and Business Studies, Polytechnic of Central London, London
17.
BurkeTShackletonJ R, 1986, “The likely impact of the deregulation of Sunday trading on consumption and employment”, WP-27, Faculty of Social Sciences and Business Studies, Polytechnic of Central London, London
18.
BurkeTShackletonJ R, 1989, “Sunday, Sunday: The issues in Sunday trading”, The Adam Smith Institute, 23 Great Smith Street, London SW1P 3DJ
19.
BurtonJ, 1993, “Whither Sunday trading? The case for deregulation”, Institute of Economic Affairs, 2 Lord North Street, London SW1P 3LA
20.
Burton-JonesS, 1989, “New Facts for Auld”, Jubilee Centre, 3 Hopper Street, Cambridge CB1 2N2
21.
CairncrossF, 1992, “Shopping hours: The options for reform”, mimeograph of lecture, 18 June, copy available from The Shopping Hours Reform Council, 36 Broadway, London SW1H OBH
22.
CarterN JCarterS B, 1985, “Internal labour markets in retailing: The early years”Industrial and Labour Relations Review38586–598
23.
ChristophersonS, 1993, “Market rules and territorial outcomes: The case of the United States”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research17274–288
24.
ClarkG L, 1992, “Real regulation: The administrative state”Environment and Planning A24615–627
25.
CouchD, 1992, “Retailing organisational structure and personnel management”, in Retailing Management Ed. HoweW S (Macmillan Education, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 212–233
26.
CraigCWilkinsonF, 1985, “Pay and employment in four retail trades”, RP51, Department of Employment (HMSO, London)
27.
DawsonJ A, 1985, “Costs and returns of Sunday trading”, WP-8502, Institute for Retail Studies, University of Stirling, Stirling
28.
DawsonJ AFindlayA MSparksL, 1986, “The importance of store operators on superstore employment levels”Service Industries Journal6349–361
29.
DiamondP, 1989, “The Shops Act and the EEC Treaty”Justice of the Peace 28 January, pp 51–55
30.
DiamondP, 1991, “Dishonourable defences: The use of injunctions and the EEC Treaty—case study of the Shops Act 1950”Modern Law Review5472–87
31.
DooganK, 1992, “Flexible labour? Employment and training in new service industries: The case of retailing”, WP-105, School of Advanced Urban Studies, University of Bristol, Bristol
32.
ElliottDLevinS, 1987, “Estimating the economic impact of repealing laws prohibiting Sunday sales”International Journal of Retailing2(1) 31–43
33.
FreathyJ P, 1991, “Distance learning and the distributive trades”Journal of European Industrial Training15(4) 21–24
34.
FreathyJ P, 1993, “Developments in the superstore labour market”Service Industries Journal1365–79
35.
FreathyJ PSparksL, 1993a, “Sunday working in the retail trades”, Institute for Retail Studies, University of Stirling, Stirling
36.
FreathyJ PSparksL, 1993b, “Sunday working in the retail trade”International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management21(7) 3–9
37.
FreathyJ PSparksL, 1994a, “Understanding retail employment relations”, in Retailing, Consumption and Capital Eds WrigleyNLoweM (Longman, Harlow, Essex) forthcoming
38.
FreathyJ PSparksL, 1994b, “Flexibility, labour segmentation and retail superstore managers: The effects of Sunday trading”, paper submitted to journal; copy available from authors
39.
GilbertNBurrowsRPollertA (Eds), 1992Fordism and Flexibility (Macmillan, London)
40.
GowersCommittee, 1947Closing Hours of Shops Cmnd 7105 (HMSO, London)
41.
GregoryA, 1991, “Patterns of working hours in large scale grocery retailing in Britain and France: Convergence after 1992?”Work, Employment and Society5497–514
42.
HarrisRSeldonA, 1984Shoppers' Choice (Institute of Economic Affairs, London)
43.
HogarthTBarthM, 1991, “Age works: A case study of B&Qs use of old workers”, Institute of Employment Research, University of Warwick, Coventry
44.
HomeOffice, 1993Reforming the Law on Sunday Trading: A Guide to the Options for Reform Cm 2300 (HMSO, London)
45.
IMS, 1993a, “Employment, work and training in the UK retail sector”, report 238, Institute of Manpower Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, Sussex
46.
IMS, 1993b, “Occupation and skill change in the European retail sector”, report 247, Institute of Manpower Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, Sussex
47.
JacksonMLeopoldJTuckK, 1993The Decentralization of Collective Bargaining (Macmillan, London)
48.
JafferS MMorrisC N, 1985, “Sunday trading and unemployment”, Institute for Fiscal Studies, 7 Ridgmount Street, London WC1E 7AB
49.
JarvisVPraisS J, 1988, “Two nations of shopkeepers: Training for retailing in France and Britain”, DP-140, National Institute of Economic and Social Research, 2 Dean Trench Street, London SW1P 3HE
50.
KirbyD A, 1992, “Employment in retailing: Unsociable hours and Sunday trading”International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management20(2) 19–28
51.
KirbyD A, 1993, “Working conditions and the trading week”, in Retail Change: Contemporary issues Eds BromleyRThomasC (UCL Press, London) pp 192–207
52.
KirbyD ALivettPRotherhamD, 1991Women and Work During Unsociable Hourstwo volumes (Department of Business Studies, University of Durham, Durham)
53.
LabandD NHeinbuchD H, 1987Blue Laws: The History, Economics, and Politics of Sunday-closing Laws” (Lexington Books, Lexington, MA)
54.
LangR, 1989, “Scotland's Sunday under pressure”, Jubilee Centre, 3 Hopper Street, Cambridge CB1 2NZ
55.
LemanS, 1992, “Gender, technology and flexibility in the UK mail order industry”, in Fordism and Flexibility Eds GilbertNBurrowsRPollertA (Macmillan, London) pp 118–133
56.
LewisJ C, 1985, “Technical change in retailing—its impact on employment and access”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design12165–191
57.
LondonEconomics, 1993, “The economic impact of alternative Sunday trading regimes”, London Economics, 91 New Cavendish Street, London W1M 7FR
58.
LoweMCreweL, 1991, “Lollipop jobs for pin money? Retail employment explored”Area23344–347
59.
McNeilD WYuS S, 1989, “Blue laws: Impact on regional retail activity”Population Research and Policy Review8267–278
60.
MarchingtonMHarrisonE, 1991, “Customers competition and choice: Employee relations in food retailing”Industrial Relations Journal22(4) 286–299
61.
MarchingtonMParkerP, 1990, “Multistores: Co-operating with customer care”, in Changing Patterns of Employee Relations Eds MarchingtonMParkerP (Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead, Herts) pp 152–176
62.
MoirC, 1987, “Research difficulties in the analysis of Sunday trading”International Journal of Retailing2(1) 3–21
63.
NattiJ, 1990, “Flexibility, segmentation and the use of labour in Finnish retail trade”Acta Sociologica33373–382
64.
NEDO, 1988Part-Time Working in the Distributive Tradestwo volumes (National Economic Development Office, London)
65.
OgbonnaEWilkinsonB, 1990, “Corporate strategy and corporate culture”Personnel Review19(4) 9–15
66.
PennRWorthR, 1993, “Employment patterns in contemporary retailing: Gender and work in five supermarket service industries”Service Industries Journal13252–266
67.
PollertA (Ed.), 1991Farewell to Flexibility? (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
68.
PriceJYandleB, 1987, “Labor markets and Sunday closing laws”Journal of Labor Research8407–414
69.
RamsdalePCapaldiA, 1993, “Sunday trading: A study of the impact on local authorities”, Institute of Public Finance Ltd, 3 Robert Street, London WC2
70.
ReganP, 1988, “The 1986 Shops Bill”Parliamentary Affairs41281–335
71.
ReynoldsJBrueN, 1990, “Recruitment and retention in retailing”, Oxford Institute for Retail Management, Templeton College, University of Oxford, Oxford
72.
RobinsonO, 1990, “Employment policies in the service sector: Training in retail distribution”Service Industries Journal10284–305
73.
RobinsonOWallaceJ, 1976Pay and Employment in Retailing (Saxon House, Farnborough, Hants)
74.
RuberyJ, 1989, “Employers and the labour market”, in Employment in Britain Ed. GallieD (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 251–280
75.
ShopsAct, 1950Public General Acts—George VI14 chapter 28 (HMSO, London)
76.
SHRC, 1992, “Voters opinions and Sunday shopping”, Shopping Hours Reform Council, 36 Broadway, London SW1H OBH
77.
SmithD, 1988, “How much change at store? The impact of new technologies and labour processes on managers and staff in retail distribution”, in New Technologies and the Labour Process Eds KnightsDWilmottH (Macmillan Education, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 143–162
78.
SparksL, 1983, “Employment characteristics of superstore retailing”Service Industries Journal363–78
79.
SparksL, 1986Employment Characteristics of Superstore Retailing unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, St David's University College, Lampeter
80.
SparksL, 1987, “Employment in retailing: Trends and issues”, in Business Strategy and Retailing Ed. JohnsonG (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 239–256
81.
SparksL, 1991, “Employment in DIY superstores”Service Industries Journal11304–323
82.
SparksL, 1992, “Restructuring retail employment”International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management20(3) 12–19
83.
ThomasA B, 1991, “Leadership and change in British retailing 1955–84”Service Industries Journal11381–392
84.
TownsendCSchluterM, 1985, “Why keep Sunday special?”, paper 5, Jubilee Center, 3 Hopper Street, Cambridge CB1 2NZ
85.
USDAW, 1983, “The choice must be hours”, Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers, 188 Wilmslow Road, Manchester M14 6LJ
86.
WalshT, 1991, “‘Flexible’ employment in the retail and hotel trades”, in Farewell to Flexibility? Ed. PollertA (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 104–115
