The concept of patriarchy gives a necessary causal basis to the study of gender divisions and gender inequality. However, it has often been employed in a deterministic way, where variation is unexplained and agency is underplayed. This paper reviews Walby's reconceptualisation of six dimensions of patriarchy, based on a realist view of causation, which attempts to reintroduce empirical complexity and institutional variation into the concept.
The author suggests that this reconceptualisation does not go far enough. Similarly, models of gendered welfare states, though descriptively quite detailed, are analytically weak. It is suggested that an integration of Walby's theory of patriarchy with Scandinavian ideas of the gender contract provides the best means of conceptualising difference in gender divisions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AckerJ, 1989, “The problem with patriarchy”Sociology23235–240
2.
AlcoffL, 1988, “Cultural feminism versus post-structuralism: The identity crisis in feminist theory”Signs13(3) 405–436
3.
BorchorstA, 1990The Scandinavian Welfare States: Patriarchal, Gender Neutral or Women-friendly?Institute for Political Science, University of Aarhus
4.
BrownC, 1981, “Mothers, fathers and children: From private to public patriarchy”, in Women and Revolution: The Unhappy Marriage of Marxism and Feminism Ed. SargentL (Pluto, London) pp 239–268
5.
BrownmillerS, 1976Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
6.
CharlesN, 1993Gender Divisions and Social Change (Harvester Press, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
7.
ChodorowN, 1978The Reproduction of Mothering (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
8.
CoontzSHendersonP, 1986Women's Work, Men's Property: The Origins of Gender and Class (Verso, London)
9.
DickensPDuncanS SGoodwinMGrayF, 1985Housing, States and Localities (Methuen, London)
10.
DuncanS S, 1989, “Uneven development and the difference that space makes”Geoforum20(2)131–140
11.
DuncanS S, 1994, “The diverse worlds of European patriarchy”, in South and North: Women's Work and Daily Lives in the EC Eds Garcis-RamenDMomsonS (Routledge, London) forthcoming
12.
DuncanS SEdwardsE, 1994, “Lone mothers and paid work: Welfare regimes, social discourses and neighbourhood processes”Gender, Place and Culture forthcoming
13.
DworkinA, 1981Pornography: Men Possessing Women (Women's Press, London)
14.
EdwardsR, 1993Mature Women Students: Separating or Connecting Family and Education (Taylor and Francis, London)
15.
EisensteinZ, 1981The Radical Future of Liberal Feminism (Longman, New York)
16.
Esping-AndersonG, 1990The Three Words of Welfare Capitalism (Polity Press, Cambridge)
17.
FraserNNicholsonL, 1988, “Social criticism without philosophy: An encounter between feminism and post-modernism”Theory, Culture and Society5373–394
18.
FribergT, 1990Kvinnors vardag: Om kvinnors arbete och liv. Anpassningsstrategier i tid och rumLunds Geografiska Institutionen, avhandling 109 (Lund University Press, Lund)
19.
GoldbergS, 1979Male Dominance: The Inevitability of Patriarchy (Abacus, London)
20.
HartmannH, 1981, “The unhappy marriage of marxism and feminism: Towards a more progressive union”, in Women and Revolution Ed. SargentL (Pluto, London) pp 1–41
21.
HemesH, 1984, “Women and the welfare state: The transition from private to public dependence”, in Patriarchy in a Welfare Society Ed. HolterH (Universitetsforlaget, Oslo) pp 26–45
22.
HernesH, 1988, “The welfare state citizenship of Scandinavian women”, in The Political Interests of Gender Eds JonesKJónasdottirA (Sage, London) pp 187–213
23.
HirdmannY, 1988, “Genussystemet—reflexioner kring kvinnors sociala underordning”Kvinnovetenskaplig Tidskrift349–63
24.
HirdmannY, 1990, “Genussystemet”, in Demokrati och Makt i Sverige, Statens Offentliga Utredningar1990: 44, Stockholm
25.
JónasdottirA, 1991, “Love power and political interests”, Örebro Studies number 7, Örebro University, Sweden
26.
LanganMOstnerI, 1991, “Gender and welfare: Towards a comparative framework”, in Towards a European Welfare State? Ed. RoomG, School of Advanced Urban Studies, University of Bristol, pp 127–150
27.
LeacockE, 1981, “History, development and the division of labour by sex: Implications for organisation”Signs7(2) 474–491
28.
LeibfriedS, 1993, “Towards a European welfare state?”, in New Perspectives on the Welfare State in Europe Ed. JonesC (Routledge, London) pp 133–156
29.
LewisJ, 1992, “Gender and the development of welfare regimes”Journal of European Social Policy2(3) 159–173
30.
McDowellLMasseyD, 1984, “A woman's place”, in Geography Matters Eds MasseyDAllenJ (Open University Press, Milton Keynes) pp 128–147
31.
MannM, 1986, “A crisis in stratification theory”, in Gender and Stratification Eds CromptonRMannM (Polity Press, Cambridge) pp 40–50
32.
Mark-LawsonJ, 1988, “Occupational segregation and women's politics”, in Gender Segregation at Work Ed. WalbyS (Open University Press, Milton Keynes) pp 157–173
33.
Mark-LawsonJSavageMWardeA, 1985, “Gender and local politics: Struggles over welfare policies, 1918–1939”, in Localities, Class and Gender Eds Lancaster Regionalism Group (Pion, London) pp 195–215
34.
MasseyD, 1984Spatial Divisions of Labour (Macmillan, London)
35.
OrtnerS, 1974, “Is female to male as nature is to culture?”, in Women, Culture and Society Eds RosaldoMLamphereL (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 67–88
36.
PrattA C, 1991, “Discourses of locality”Environment and Planning A23257–266
37.
QuackSMaierF, 1994, “From state socialism to market economy: Women's employment in East Germany”Environment and Planning A261257–1276
38.
RosaldoM, 1974, “Women, culture and society: A theoretical overview”, in Women, Culture and Society Eds RosaldoMLamphereL (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 17–42
39.
SavageM, 1985, “Capitalist and patriarchal relations at work: Preston cotton weaving, 1890–1940”, in Localities, Class and Gender Eds Lancaster Regionalism Group (Pion, London) pp 177–194
40.
SavageM, 1993, “Career mobility and class formation: British banking workers and the lower middle classes”, in Building European Society: Occupational Change and Social Mobility in Europe Eds MilesAVincentD (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 196–216
41.
SayerA, 1984Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach (Hutchinson, London)
42.
StaceyM, 1986, “Gender and stratification: One central issue or two?”, in Gender and Stratification Eds CromptonRMannM (Polity Press, Cambridge) pp 214–223
43.
WalbyS, 1985, “Spatial and historical variations in women's unemployment”, in Localities, Class and Gender Eds Lancaster Regionalism Group (Pion, London) pp 161–176
44.
WalbyS, 1986Patriarchy at Work: Patriarchal and Capitalist Relations in Employment (Polity Press, Cambridge)
WalbyS, 1994, “Methodological and theoretical issues in the comparative analysis of gender relations in Western Europe”Environment and Planning A26 forthcoming
47.
WalbySBagguleyP, 1990, “Sex segregation in local labour markets”Work, Employment and Society4(1) 59–81
48.
WatersM, 1989, “Patriarchy and viriarchy: An exploration and reconstruction of concepts of masculine domination”Sociology23(2) 193–211
