In this paper I examine the ways in which economic and political restructuring is impacting environmental rights as conceptualized and practised by environmental justice activists in California and the Southwestern USA. Using Iris Young's framework, I argue that the recent gains of the environmental justice movement have been based largely on procedural justice, which is insufficient to ensure universal environmental quality, a stated goal of the movement. The limits of procedural justice have become apparent through the processes of restructuring, internationalization, and immigration, all of which are creating a new landscape for activists. Activists in California find that their rights are being contracted, because of deregulation and capital flight, and at the same time are expanding to include residents of Mexico. Given these global realities, procedural justice must also be accompanied by efforts to address both uneven development and a lack of democracy over private production decisions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
• Reference of particular interest to this paper which is not cited in the text
2.
AlstonD (Ed.), 1990We Speak for Ourselves: Social Justice, Race, and Environment (Panos Institute, Washington, DC)
3.
AschPSenecaJ, 1978, “Some evidence on the distribution of air quality”Land Economics54278–297
4.
BaileyEMorainD, 1993, “Anti-immigration bills flood legislature”Los Angeles Times 3 May, pp A3, A22, A23
5.
BarkinD, 1990Distorted Development: Mexico in the World Economy (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
6.
BathR, 1982, “Health and environmental problems: The role of the border in El-Paso Ciudad Juarez Coordination”Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs24375–392
7.
BerkovitzD, 1992, “Pariahs and prophets: Nuclear energy, global warming, and intergenerational justice”Columbia Journal of Environmental Law17245–325
8.
BerryBCarisLGaskillDKaplanCPiccininiJPlanertNRendallJIIIde Sainte PhalleA (Eds), 1977The Social Burdens of Environmental Pollution: A Comparative Metropolitan Data Source (Ballinger, Cambridge, MA)
9.
BlochRKeilR, 1991, “Planning for a fragrant future: Air pollution control, restructuring, and popular alternatives in Los Angeles”Capitalism, Nature and Socialism244–65
10.
BlumbergLGottliebR, 1989, “Saying no to mass burn”Environmental Action (January/February) 28–30
11.
BorrelliP, 1988, “Environmentalism at a crossroads”, in Crossroads: Environmental Priorities for the Future Ed. BorrelliP (Island Press, Washington, DC) pp 3–25
12.
BryantBMohaiP, 1992, “Introduction”, in Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards Eds BryantBMohaiP (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 1–9
13.
BullardR, 1990Dumping in Dixie (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
14.
BullardR, 1992, “Unequal environmental protection: Incorporating environmental justice in decision-making”, paper presented at the Resources for the Future Conference on Setting National Environmental Priorities: The EPA Risk-based Paradigm and Its Alternatives, Annapolis, MD, November; copy available from R Bullard, Sociology Department, University of California-Riverside, Riverside, CA 92521
15.
BullardR, 1993, “Anatomy of environmental racism and the Environmental Justice Movement”, in Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots Ed. BullardR (South End Press, Boston, MA) pp 15–39
16.
BurkeL, 1993, “Environmental equity in Los Angeles”, MA thesis, Department of Geography, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA
17.
CallicottB (Ed.), 1989In Defense of the Land Ethic (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY)
18.
CapekS, 1993, “The ‘Environment Justice’ frame: A conceptual discussion and an application”Social Problems405–24
19.
CarsonR, 1962Silent Spring (Riverside Press, Cambridge, MA)
20.
CBE, 1989, “Richmond at risk: Community demographics and toxic hazards from industrial polluters”, Citizens for a Better Environment, 122 Lincoln Boulevard, Suite 201, Venice, CA 90291
21.
CCC, 1992California's Jobs and FutureCouncil on California Competitiveness; copy available from California State Senator Leonard, 1020 N Street, Suite 534, Sacramento, CA 95814
22.
ColeL, 1992, “Empowerment as the key to environmental protection: The need for environmental poverty law”Ecology Law Quarterly19619–683
23.
ColquetteKRobertsonE H, 1991, “Environmental racism: The causes, consequences, and commendations”Tulane Environmental Law Journal5153–207
24.
DavisM, 1992City of Quartz: Excavating the Future of Los Angeles (Verso, London)
25.
DietzM, 1987, “Context is all: Feminism and theories of citizenship”Daedalus41–24
26.
EPA, 19911991 Toxic Release Inventory, Public Data Release (US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Pollution, Prevention and Toxics, Washington, DC)
27.
EPA, 1993Environmental Equity: Reducing Risk for All Communities (US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Policy, Planning and Education, Washington, DC)
28.
EPA Journal1992, “Environmental protection—has it been fair?”, special issue, Ed. HeritageJ181–64
29.
•FitzSimmonsMGottliebR, 1988, “A new environmental politics”, in Reshaping the U.S. Left: Popoular Struggles in the 1980s Eds DavisMSprinklerM (Verso, London) pp 114–130
30.
FoxS, 1981John Muir and His Legacy: The American Conservation Movement (Little, Brown, Boston, MA)
31.
FreedD, 1993a, “The dangers of life on the line”Los Angeles Times 5 September, pp A1, A26–A28
32.
FreedD, 1993b, “Few safeguards protect workers from poisons”Los Angeles Times 6 September, pp A1, A24, A26
33.
FreedD, 1993c, “Revived Cal fails to inspect most factories”Los Angeles Times 7 September, pp A1, A14, A15
34.
FreemanA, 1972, “Distribution of environmental quality”, in Environmental Quality Analysis Eds KneeseABowerB (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 243–278
35.
FreudenbergN, 1984NOT In Our Backyards! (Monthly Review Press, New York)
36.
GaylordC, 1993, “Statement of Dr. Clarice Gaylord before the Subcommittee on Civil Rights and Constitutional Rights Committee on the Judiciary, US House of Representatives. 3 March” (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
37.
GelobterM, 1992, “Toward a model of environmental discrimination”, in Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards Eds BryantBMohaiP (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 64–81
38.
GianessiLPeskinHWolffE, 1979, “The distributional effects of uniform air pollution policy in the United States”The Quarterly Journal of EconomicsXCII281–301
39.
GibbsL, 1982Love Canal: My Story (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY)
40.
GodsilR, 1991, “Remedying environmental racism”Michigan Law Review90394–427
41.
GottliebRIngramH, 1988, “The new environmentalists”The Progressive5214–16
42.
GouldC, 1988Rethinking Democracy (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
43.
GreenbergMAndersonR, 1984Hazardous Waste Sites: The Credibility Gap (Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ)
GuptaAFergusonJ, 1992, “Beyond ‘culture’: Space, identity, and the politics of difference”Cultural Anthropology76–23
46.
HaysS, 1987Beauty, Health and Permanence (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
47.
HeimanM, 1990, “From ‘Not in My Backyard!’ to ‘Not in Anybody's Backyard!’ Grassroots challenge to hazardous waste facility siting”Journal of the American Planning Association56359–362
48.
HerzogL, 1991, “Cross-national urban structure in the era of global cities: The US-Mexico transfrontier metropolis”Urban Studies28519–533
49.
HeymanJ, 1991Life and Labor on the Border (University of Arizona Press, Tucson, AZ)
50.
HiseL, 1992, “The role of environmental regulations in industrial location: Furniture manufacturing in Southern California”, client project, Graduate School of Architecture and Urban Planning, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA
51.
HurelyA, 1988, “The social biases of environmental change in Gary Indiana, 1945–1980”Environmental Review121–19
52.
IHERC, 1993BorderLines3Inter-Hemispheric Education Resource Center, PO Box 4506, Albuquerque, NM 87102
53.
KazisRGrossmanR, 1982Fear at Work (Pilgrim Press, New York)
54.
KearneyM, 1991, “Borders and boundaries of state and self at the end of empire”Journal of Historical Sociology452–74
55.
KratkeSSchmollF, 1991, “The local state and social restructuring”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research15542–552
56.
LavelleM, 1992, “The minorities question”National Law Journal 21 September, page S2
57.
LazarusR, 1993, “Pursuing ‘Environmental Justice’: The distributional effects of environmental protection”Northwestern University Law Review87787–857
58.
LCSC, 1989, “Labor/community watchdog: A three year organizing strategy to impact the Los Angeles Clean Air Plan”, Labor/Community Strategy Center, 3780 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 1200, Los Angeles, CA 90010
59.
LealT, 1993, Presentation at the Gathering of the Southwest Network for Economic and Environmental Justice, Tijuana, Mexico, 20 August; copy available from Southwest Organizing Project, 211 10th Street SW, Albuquerque, NM 87102
60.
LeeC, 1992, “Toxic waste and race in the United States”, in Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards Eds BryantBMohaiP (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 10–27
61.
LeopoldA, 1988A Sand County Almanac 25th printing (Ballantine Books, New York)
62.
LevySArnoldR, 1992The Outlook for the California EconomyCenter for Continuing Study of the California Economy, 610 University Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301
63.
LoganJSwanstromT (Eds), 1990Beyond the City Limits (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
64.
LowenthalABurgessK (Eds), 1993The California—Mexico Connection (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
65.
McCaullJ, 1976, “Discriminatory air pollution”Environment1826–31
66.
MannE, 1991, “L.A.'s Lethal Air”, Labor/Community Strategy Center, 3780 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 1200, Los Angeles, CA 90010
67.
MarstonS A, 1990, “Who are ‘the people’?: Gender, citizenship, and the making of the American nation”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space8449–458
68.
MartinezE, 1991, “When people of color are an endangered species”Z-magazine461–65
69.
MFASC, 1989, “Memorandum on City Council proposed ordinance requiring relocation of metal finishing facilities, council file 88–0983”, Metal Finishing Association of Southern California, 20 January; copy available from author
70.
MooreR, 1993, Presentation at the Gathering of the Southwest Network for Economic and Environmental Justice, San Diego, CA, 21 August; copy available from Southwest Organizing Project, 211 10th Street SW, Albuquerque, NM 87102
71.
MoralesROngP, 1993, “The illusion of progress: Latinos in Los Angeles”, in Latinos in a Changing U.S. Economy Eds MoralesRBonillaF (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 55–84
72.
MoralesRTamayo-SanchezJ, 1992, “Urbanization and development of the United States—Mexico border”, in Changing Boundaries in the Americas Ed. HerzogL (Center for US—Mexico Studies, University of California, San Diego, San Diego, CA) pp 49–68
73.
MummeSBathC RAssettoV, 1988, “Political development and environmental policy in Mexico”Latin American Research Review237–34
74.
GlennNakano E, 1992, “From servitude to service work: Historical continuities in the racial division of paid reproductive labor”Signs181–43
75.
NashR, 1989The Rights of Nature (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI)
76.
NCC, 1993, “Anti-immigrant legislation: 1993 California legislative session”, New California Coalition; copy available from the Committee for Human and Immigrant Rights, Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles, 621 S Virgil Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90005
77.
OngPBlumenbergE, 1993, “An unnatural trade-off: Latinos and environmental justice”, in Latinos in a Changing U.S. Economy Eds MoralesRBonillaF (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 207–225
78.
PartridgeE (Ed.), 1981Responsibilities to Future Generations (Prometheus, Buffalo, NY)
79.
PasternakJ, 1991, “Firms find a haven from U.S. environmental rules”Los Angeles Times 19 November, pp A1, A24
80.
PastorMAyonD (Eds), 1992Encuentro: Mexico in Los Angeles (International and Public Affairs, Occidental College, Los Angeles)
81.
PincetlS, 1994, “Challenges to citizenship: Latino immigrants and political organizing in the Los Angeles area”Environment and Planning A26895–914
82.
PulidoL, 1994“Reconstructing Chicano environmental history: The early pesticide campaign of the UFW, 1965–71”New Scholar forthcoming
83.
RawlsJ, 1971A Theory of Justice (Belknap Press, Cambridge, MA)
RoqueJTau LeeP, 1993, “Environmental Justice and comparative risk: A report of the Environmental Justice Workgroup of the California Comparative Risk Project”, September; copy available from the Department of Health Services, State of California, 2151 Berkeley Way, Berkeley, CA 94704–1011
86.
RotellaS, 1992, “Activists unite to oppose new incinerator”Los Angeles Times 30 March, pp A3, A21
87.
RubioLTrejoG, 1993, “Reform, globalization, and structural dependence: New economic ties between Mexico and California”, in The California—Mexico Connection Eds LowenthalABurgessK (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 51–65
88.
RuffinsP, 1991, “Environmental commitment as if people didn't matter”, in Environmental Racism: Issues and Dilemmas Eds BryantBMohaiP (Office of Minority Affairs, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 51–57
SanchezM, 1993, Presentation at the Gathering of the Southwest Network for Economic and Environmental Justice, Tijuana, Mexico, 20 August; copy available from Southwest Organizing Project, 211 10th Street SW, Albuquerque, NM 87102
91.
SapiroV, 1984, “Women, citizenship, and nationality: Immigration and naturalization policies in the U.S.”Politics and Society111–26
92.
SassenS, 1991The Global City (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
93.
SCAQMD, 1989, “The path to clean air: Attainment strategies, summary of the Air Quality Management Plan”, copy available from South Coast Air Quality Management District, 21865 Copley Drive, Diamond Bar, CA 91765
94.
SCAQMD, 1992a, “South Coast Air Quality Management District's report to the governing board regarding the recommendations of the Special Commission on Air Quality and the Economy and recommendations to adopt certain recommendations”, agenda 35, 7 August; copy available from South Coast Air Quality Management District, 21865 Copley Drive, Diamond Bar, CA 91765
95.
SCAQMD, 1992b, “Reconsideration of the nine rejected recommendations of the Special Commission on Air Quality and the Economy”, agenda 18, 18 September; copy available from South Coast Air Quality Management District, 21865 Copley Drive, Diamond Bar, CA 91765
96.
SchefferV, 1991The Shaping of Environmentalism in America (University of Washington Press, Seattle, WA)
97.
ShklarJ, 1991American Citizenship: The Quest for Inclusion (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
98.
SklairL, 1992, “The maquila industry and the creation of a transnational capitalist class in the United States—Mexico border region”, in Changing Boundaries in the Americas Ed. HerzogL (Center for US—Mexico Studies, University of California, San Diego, San Diego, CA) pp 69–88
99.
SmithS, 1989, “Society, space and citizenship: A human geography for the ‘new times’?”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: New Series14144–156
100.
SNEEJ, 1992, “Statement of solidarity”, Southwest Network for Economic and Environmental Justice; copy available from the Southwest Organizing Project, 211 10th Street SW, Albuquerque, NM 87102
101.
SojaE, 1989Postmodern Geographies (Verso, New York)
102.
SolisR, 1993, Presentation at the Gathering of the Southwest Network for Economic and Environmental Justice, Tijuana, Mexico, 20 August; copy available from Southwest Organizing Project, 211 10th Street SW, Albuquerque, NM 87102
103.
SRC, 1992, “Are we losing our competitive edge?”, Senate Republican Caucus; copy available from California State Senator Leonard, 1020 N Street, Suite 534, Sacramento, CA 95814
104.
StallB, 1993, “Regulations, taxes blamed for state's woes”Los Angeles Times 25 March, pp A1, A28
105.
StammerL, 1990, “Jackson calls on minorities to take up environmental battle”Los Angeles Times 3 April, pp A3, A28
106.
StoneC, 1974Should Trees Have Standing? Toward Legal Rights for Natural Objects (William Kaufmann, Los Altos, CA)
107.
StorperMScottA J, 1989, “The geographical foundations and social regulation of flexible production complexes”, in The Power of Geography Eds WolchJDearM (Unwin Hyman, Winchester, MA) pp 21–40
108.
SWOP, 1990, “Major national environmental organizations and problems of the ‘environmental movement’”, briefing paper; copy available from Southwest Organizing Project, 211 10th Street SW, Albuquerque, NM 87102
109.
SzekelyG, 1993, “California and Mexico: Facing the Pacific Rim”, in The California—Mexico Connection Eds LowenthalABurgessK (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 113–128
110.
TaylorD, 1993, “Environmentalism and the politics of inclusion”, in Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots Ed. BullardR (South End Press, Boston, MA) pp 53–61
111.
TEF1993, “Will NAFTA protect the environment?”The Environmental Forum (March/April) 28–35
112.
ToppingK, 1988, “Transmittal of report and ordinance restricting metal plating to the inner M3 zone to City Council”, 14 July; copy available from author
113.
TurnerEAllenJ P, 1990An Atlas of Population Patterns in Metropolitan Los Angeles and Orange Counties (Department of Geography, California State University, Northridge, Northridge, CA)
114.
UCC, 1987, “Toxic wastes and race in the United States”, United Church of Christ, 105 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016
115.
UCC, 1991, “Principles of environmental justice”, Proceedings of the First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit, Washington, DC, October; copy available from United Church of Christ, Commission for Racial Justice, 105 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016
116.
USGAO, 1983, “Siting of hazardous waste landfills and their correlation with racial and economic status of surrounding communities”, US General Accounting Office, Washington, DC
117.
USGAO, 1991, “US—Mexico trade: Some US wood firms relocated from Los Angeles area to Mexico”, report to the Chairman, Committee on Energy and Commerce, House of Representatives GAO/NSIAD 91–191, US General Accounting Office, Washington, DC
WhiteJHolmesBGoodwinE, 1993, “Regulating reform issues”, memorandum to Environmental Recovery Group; copy available from Labor/Community Strategy Center, 3780 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 1200, Los Angeles, CA 90010
120.
YoungI M, 1983, “Justice and hazardous waste”, in The Applied Turn in Contemporary Philosophy. Bowling Green studies in Applied Philosophy, Volume 1 Eds BradieMAttigTRescherN (Bowling Green State University Press, Bowling Green, OH) pp 171–183
121.
YoungI M, 1990Justice and the Politics of Difference (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
122.
ZupanJ, 1973The Distribution of Air Quality in the New York Region (John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
