The policy literature offers many valid criticisms of government housing programs, but does not adequately trace housing-agency failures to their causes in the broader political and economic contexts of peripheral capitalist countries. The literature especially lacks an understanding of the role of interests within the state which benefit from housing programs in their current distorted form. In response to these analytical shortcomings, the author of this paper adapts a geographically hierarchical and comparative framework from locality studies that is capable of revealing both structural commonalities and contextual particularities of housing-agency behavior. The research is an examination and comparison of the performance of the major housing agencies in Brazil, Ecuador, and Jamaica. The diversity of economic resources and political regimes in these countries during the last three decades provides a spectrum of regional experiences. The investigation unfolds with the setting of the context of dependent capitalism, without which it is not possible to understand either the prominence or the incapacity of Latin American housing agencies. Next, the research adopts an historical vantage point to reveal key actors and events in housing-agency institutionalization. Having set the structural and historical contexts, the author then examines motives related to the state and its agents that help to explain why working-class housing programs have become self-centered patronage bureaucracies, to the neglect of their socially progressive goals. The author then explains how housing agencies have primarily used rhetoric, plans, and images, not material investment, to legitimize themselves to the disenfranchised working class. The final section synthesizes the paper's main points thereby establishing a political economic context for understanding Latin American housing programs.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbranchesS, 1978The Divided Leviathan: State and Economic Policy Formation in Authoritarian Brazil PhD dissertation, Department of Political Science, Cornell University, 410 Thurston Avenue, Ithaca, NY 14853
2.
AcostaA, 1990La Deuda Eterna: Una Historia de la Deuda Externa Ecuatoriana (Editorial El Duende, Quito)
3.
AzevedoSde AndradeGama L A, 1982Habitação e Poder: Da Fundação de Casa Popular ao Banco Nacional de Habitação (Zahar, Rio de Janeiro)
4.
BatleyR, 1983Power Through Bureaucracy: Urban Political Analysis in Brazil (St Martin's Press, New York)
5.
BEV, 1990aQuinto Contrato Colectivo de Trabajo, celebrado entre el BEV y el Sindicato de Trabajadores Bancarios del BEV Matriz Quito (internal document), Banco Ecuatoriano de la Vivienda, Calle Cordero y 10 de Agosto, Quito, Ecuador
6.
BEV, 1990bIndices de Morosidad (internal document, June), Banco Ecuatoriano de la Vivienda, Calle Cordero y 10 de Agosto, Quito, Ecuador
7.
BhaskarR, 1979The Possibility of Naturalism (Harvester Press, Hassocks)
8.
BNH, 1982Annual Report—1981 (English edition), Banco Nacional da Habitação, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
9.
BNH, 1984Relatório Anual—1984 Banco Nacional de Habitação, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil (BNH is now defunct. Its documents are available from The Library of Caixa Econômica Federal, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil)
10.
BoccoA M, 1987Auge Petrolero, Modernización y Subdesarrollo: El Ecuador de los Años Setenta (Corporación Editora Nacional, PO Box 4147, Quito, Ecuador)
11.
BromleyR, 1977Development Planning in Ecuador (Latin American Publications Fund, London)
12.
BrowettJ, 1985, “The newly industrializing countries and radical theories of development”World Development13789–803
13.
BurgessR, 1985, “The limits of state self-help housing programmes”Development and Change16271–312
14.
CaporasoJZareB, 1981, “An interpretation and evaluation of dependency theory”, in From Dependency to Development: Strategies to Overcome Underdevelopment and Inequality Ed. MuñozH (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
15.
CardosoF HFalettoE, 1979Dependency and Development in Latin America (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
16.
CargillM, 1987, “The NHT ripoff”The Gleaner 12 February, Kingston
17.
CheckowayB, 1980, “Large builders, federal housing programs, and postwar suburbanization”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research421–45
18.
ConaghanC, 1988Restructuring Domination: Industrialists and the State in Ecuador (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
19.
ConnollyP, 1990, “Housing and the state in Mexico”, in Housing Policy in Developing Countries Ed. ShidloG (Routledge, Chapman and Hall Inc., New York) pp 5–32
20.
ConwayD, 1985, “Changing perspectives on squatter settlements, intraurban mobility, and constraints on housing choice of the Third World urban poor”Urban Geography6170–192
CorbridgeS, 1986Capitalist World Development: A Critique of Radical Development Theory (Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ)
23.
CorrE G, 1972The Political Process in ColombiaThe University of Denver, Social Science Foundation, and Graduate School of International Studies, Denver, CO
24.
CoxK RMairA, 1991, “From localised social structures to localities as agents”Environment and Planning A23197–213
25.
DuncanSSavageM, 1991, “New perspectives on the locality debate”Environment and Planning A23155–164
26.
EdieC, 1991Democracy by Default: Dependency and Clientelism in Jamaica (Lynne Rienner Publishers, Boulder, CO)
27.
EvansP, 1985, “After dependency: Recent studies of class, state, and industrialization”Latin American Research Review20149–160
28.
FernandezG, 1982, “The role of the state in Latin America” PhD dissertation, Department of History, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI 53706
29.
GayR, 1991, “Community organization and clientelist politics in contemporary Brazil: A case study from suburban Rio de Janeiro”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research14648–666
30.
GeigerP PDavidovichF R, 1986, “The spatial strategies of the stage in the political-economic development of Brazil”, in Work, Production, Territory: The Geographical Anatomy of Industrial Capitalism Eds ScottAStorperM (Allen and Unwin, London) pp 281–300
31.
AlanGilbert, 1990, “The provision of public services and the debt crisis in Latin America: The case of Bogotá”Economic Geography66349–362
32.
AlanGilbert, 1991, “Comparative analysis: Studying housing processes in Latin American cities”, in Housing the Poor in the Developing World: Methods of Analysis, Case Studies and Policy Eds TippleA GWillisK W (Routledge, Champan and Hall, Andover, Hants) pp 81–95
33.
AlanGilbertGoodmanD, 1976, “Regional income disparities and economic development”, in Development Planning and Spatial Structure Ed. GilbertA (John Wiley, New York) pp 115–135
34.
AlanGilbertGuglerJ, 1982Cities, Poverty, and Development: Urbanization in the Third World (Oxford University Press, New York)
35.
AlanGilbertWardP, 1985Housing, the State and the Poor: Policy and Practice in Three Latin American Cities (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
36.
AnneGilbert, 1988, “The new regional geography in English and French-speaking countries”Progress in Human Geography12208–228
37.
GlasserD E, 1988, “The growing housing crisis in Ecuador”, in Spontaneous Shelter: International Perspectives and Prospects Ed PattonC V (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA) pp 78–102
38.
GoldingB, 1982A National Housing Policy for JamaicaMinistry of Construction (Housing), 2 Hagley Park Road, Kingston 10, Jamaica
39.
GoldsonB, 1983–84, “Trends in Housing Costs II”Housing and Finance Winter, 16–18
40.
GriffithEFordL, 1980, “A model of Latin American city structure”Geographical Review70397–422
41.
HandelmanH, 1988, “The role of the state in sheltering the urban poor”, in Spontaneous Shelter: International Perspectives and Prospects Ed. PattonC V (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA) pp 326–347
42.
HarloeMPickvanceCUrryJ, 1990Place, Policy and Politics (Unwin Hyman, London)
43.
HayesM D, 1984Latin America and the U.S. National Interest: A Basis for U.S. Foreign Policy (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
44.
IULA/CEDCADEL, 1990Desarrollo Local. Volumen 4: Vivienda, Tierra Urbana y Servicios Básicos para Sectores Pobres de América LatinaCuadernos del Centro de Capacitación y Desarrollo de los Gobiernos Locales, Quito, Ecuador
45.
JacksonS, 1988, “Caribbean Housing Finance Corporation Limited: A case analysis”, Master's paper, Business Administration, Nova University, 3301 College Avenue, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33314
46.
JacksonS, 1990, “Loan affordability and repayment plans”Housing and Finance June; The Building Societies Association of Jamaica Ltd., 73–75 Half Way Tree Road, Kingston 10, Jamaica; pp 32–35
47.
JaguaribeH, 1973Political Development: A General Theory and a Latin American Case Study (Harper and Row, New York)
48.
JonesEWebberMTurnerM, 1987Jamaica Shelter Sector Strategy, Phase 1—Final Report USAID Sponsored ‘U.I. Project 3666–02’, February; copy available from USAID, Office of Housing and Urban Programs, Room 6212 NS, Washington, DC 20523
49.
KatzmannM, 1977Cities and Frontiers in Modern Brazil (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
50.
KayC, 1989Latin American Theories of Development and Underdevelopment (Routledge, Chapman and Hall Inc., New York)
51.
KlakT, 1990, “Spatially and socially progressive state policy and programs: The case of Brazil's National Housing Bank”Annals of the Association of American Geographers50571–589
52.
KlakT, 1991, “Analysis of government mortgage records: Insights for state theory and housing policy with reference to Jamaica”, in Housing the Poor in the Developing World: Methods of Analysis, Case Studies and Policy Eds TippleA GWillisK (Routledge, Chapman and Hall, Andover, Hants) pp 96–112
53.
KlakT, 1992a, “Excluding the poor from low income housing programs: The roles of state agencies and USAID in Jamaica”Antipode2487–112
54.
KlakT, 1992b, “What causes arrears in government mortgage programs? Seven beliefs and empirical evidence from Jamaica”Journal of the American Planning Association58(3) 336–345
55.
KlakT, 1992c, “Recession, the state and working class shelter: A comparison of Quito and Guayaquil during the 1980s”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie83(2) 120–137
56.
KlakTHeyJ, 1992, “Gender and state bias in Jamaican housing programs”World Development20213–227
57.
LandivarJ, 1986The Role of Housing in Development Models: The Case of Ecuador 1962–82 New Series (Monographs), Centre for Development Studies, University College of Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP
58.
LawsonVKlakT, 1990, “Conceptual linkages in the study of production and reproduction in Latin American cities”Economic Geography66311–327
59.
LimG C, 1987, “Housing policies for the urban poor in developing countries”Journal of the American Planning Association53176–185
60.
LimG C, 1988, “Theory and taxonomy of sectoral, distribution, and spatial policies”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy6225–236
61.
LowderS, 1986Inside Third World Cities (Croom Helm, London)
62.
McAfeeK, 1990, “IMF, World Bank, USAID in the Caribbean”NACLA, Report on the Americas23(5) 14–41
63.
McKnightF, 1986, “Needed: A vibrant NHT”The Gleaner 25 May, pages 12, 23
64.
McTaggartW D, 1988, “Geographical perspectives on spontaneous shelter”, in Spontaneous Shelter: International Perspectives and Prospects Ed. PattonC V (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA) pp 25–48
65.
GomesMaia G, 1986The Roots of State Intervention in the Brazilian Economy (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT)
66.
MalpezziS, 1990, “Urban housing and financial markets: Some international comparisons”Urban Studies27(6) 971–1022
67.
Marshall-SilvaJ, 1988, “Ecuador: Windfalls of a new exporter”, in Oil Windfalls: Blessing or Curse? Ed GelbA (The World Bank, Washington, DC) pp 170–196
68.
MitchellJ, 1991, “Economic crisis and investment in the built environment: The case of Venezuela”, paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association of American Geographers, Miami, April; copy available from the author
69.
MoserC, 1987, “Mobilization is women's work: Struggles for infrastructure in Guayaquil, Ecuador”, in Women, Human Settlements, and Housing Eds MoserCPeakeL (Tavistock Publications, Andover, Hants) pp 166–194
70.
MouzelisN, 1988a, “Marxism or post-Marxism?”New Left Review167107–123
71.
MouzelisN, 1988b, “Sociology of development: Reflections on the present crisis”Sociology2223–44
72.
MurphyA, 1991, “Regions as social constructs: The gap between theory and practice”Progress in Human Geography1523–35
73.
O'DonnellG, 1988Bureaucratic Authoritarianism (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
74.
O'LoughlinJ, 1988, “Political geography: Bringing the context back in”Progress in Human Geography12121–137
75.
PalmerE KPattonC V, 1988, “Evolution of Third World shelter policies”, in Spontaneous Shelter: International Perspectives and Prospects Ed. PattonC V (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA) pp 3–24
76.
PayneJ, 1968Patterns of Conflict in Colombia (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
77.
PetersonGKlakT, 1990Shelter Sector Mortgage Credit and Subsidy Policy: The National Housing Trust and Caribbean Housing Finance Corporation. Executive ReportUSAID and the Jamaican Ministries of Construction (Housing) and Development, Planning and Production, Kingston; copy available from USAID, Office of Housing and Urban Programs, Room 6212 NS, Washington, DC 20523
78.
PickvanceC, 1990, “Introduction: The institutional context of local economic development”, in Place, Policy, Politics: Do Localities Matter? Eds HarloeMPickvanceCUrryJ (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 1–41
79.
PintoF, 1991, “El financiamiento de la vivienda”El Comercio (Quito) 30 April, pp 3–8
80.
PortesA, 1985, “Latin American class structures: Their composition and change during the last decades”Latin American Research Review207–39
81.
PotterR, 1990, “Shelter in urban Barbados, West Indies: Vernacular architecture, land tenure and self-help”, in Cities and Development in the Third World Eds PotterRSalavA (Mansell, London) pp 70–85
82.
PudupM B, 1988, “Arguments within regional geography”Progress in Human Geography12369–390
83.
RondinelliD, 1983Secondary Cities in Developing Countries (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA)
84.
RoxboroughI, 1979Theories of Underdevelopment (Humanities Press, Atlantic Highlands, NJ)
85.
SalauA, 1990, “Urbanization, housing and social services in Nigeria: The challenge of meeting basic needs”, in Cities and Development in the Third World Eds. PotterRSalauA (Mansell, London) pp 51–69
86.
SantosM, 1979Shared Space: The Two Circuits of the Urban Economy in Underdeveloped Countries (Methuen, New York)
87.
SayerA, 1984Methods in Social Science (Hutchinson Education, London)
88.
ShidloG (Ed.), 1990aHousing Policy in Developing Countries (Routledge, Chapman and Hall Inc., New York)
89.
ShidloG, 1990b, “Housing policy in Brazil”, in Housing Policy in Developing Countries Ed. ShidloG (Routledge, Chapman and Hall Inc., New York) pp 33–47
90.
SiqueiraW, 1985BNH Não!Federação Nacional dos Administradores de Empresas, Rio de Janeiro; copy available from the author
91.
SmithNDennisW, 1987, “The restructuring of geographical scale: Coalescence and fragmentation of the northern core region”Economic Geography63160–182
92.
StoneC, 1986Class, State and Democracy in Jamaica (Praeger, New York)
93.
StruykR, 1987, “The housing needs assessment model”Journal of the American Planning Association53227–234
94.
TaylorP, 1989Political Geography: World-economy, nation-state and locality2nd edition (John Wiley, New York)
95.
The Gleaner1985, “Agency has money but few NHT units this year for contributors” 23 February, Kingston
96.
TherbornG, 1980The Ideology of Power and the Power of Ideology (Verso, London)
97.
TVA, 1988Alternative Approaches to Improving Mortgage Affordability: Final ReportTrevor Hamilton and Associates, report submitted to Jamaica's National Housing Trust (October); copy available from the author
98.
UN Habitat, 1987Global Report on Human Settlements (Oxford University Press, New York)
99.
USAID, 1988Jamaica Project Paper: Jamaica Shelter and Urban Services PolicyUnited States Agency for International Development, Office of Housing and Urban Programs, Room 6212 NS, Washington, DC 20523
100.
ValençaM, 1992, “The inevitable crisis of the Brazilian Housing Finance System”Urban Studies2939–56
101.
VelascoP, 1990La Politicas Financieras del Banco Ecuatoriano de la Vivienda para la Vivienda Popular y su Incidencia en la Estabilidad Financiera de la Institución Master's Thesis, Facultad de Economia, Pontificia Universidad Católica del Ecuador, Quito, Ecuador
102.
WalkerRStorperM, 1989The Capitalist Imperative: Territory, Technology and Industrial Growth (Basil Blackwell, New York)
103.
WardP, 1986Welfare Politics in Mexico: Papering over the Cracks (Allen and Unwin, Winchester, MA)
104.
WattsM, 1987, “Conjunctures and crisis: Food, ecology and population, and the internationalization of capital”Journal of Geography86292–299
105.
World Bank, 1985The World Bank Project Performance Audit Report: Jamaica Sites and Services RN. 5862 (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
106.
World Bank, 1991World Development Report 1991 (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
