The recent rapid increase in producer service activity has been presented as an alternative source of economic growth to that created by manufacturing. Evidence from a survey of firms in Auckland, New Zealand throws doubt on the ability of producer services to generate regional growth. The dynamics of individual firms are different to the momentum of producer services as viewed through aggregate economic data. The sample of producer services firms in the Auckland region are characterised by a narrow income base, a lack of innovative activity, a propensity to expand via branch offices rather than through local investment, and close links with inward investment. A cautious approach to public policy initiatives aimed at producer services is therefore advised.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenJ, 1988, “Service industries: Uneven development and uneven knowledge”Area2015–22.
2.
BarrasR, 1984, “Growth and technical change in the UK service sector”, Technical Change Centre, 114 Cromwell Road, London, SW7 4ES.
3.
BarrasR, 1985, “Information technology and the service revolution”Policy Studies514–24.
4.
BeyersWAlvineMJohnsonE, 1985, “The service economy: Export of services in the Central Puget Sound Region”, Central Puget Sound Development District, Seattle, WA.
5.
BeyersWAlvineM, 1985, “Export services and post industrial society”Papers of the Regional Science Association5733–45.
6.
BrittonS, 1989, “Understanding the service economy: A preliminary review of theory”, OP-24, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Private Bag, Auckland 1.
7.
CoffeyWPolèseM, 1987, “Trade and location in producer services: A Canadian perspective”Environment and Planning A19597–611
8.
Committee on Invisible Exports, 1982, “World invisible trade”, Committee on Invisible Exports, British Invisible Exports Council, Dunster House, 37 Mincing Lane, London EC3R 7BQ.
9.
DanielsPLeyshonAThriftN, 1988, “Trends in the growth and location of professional producer services: UK property consultants”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geographie79162–174.
10.
DanielsPThriftNLeyshonA, 1989, “Internationalisation of professional producer services: Accountacy conglomerates”, in Multinational Service Firms Ed. EnderwickP (Routledge, Chapman and Hall, Andover, Hants) pp 132–154.
11.
EnderwickP, 1989, “Some economics of service sector multinational enterprises”, in Multinational Service Firms Ed. EnderwickP (Routledge, Chapman and Hall, Andover, Hants) pp 3–34.
12.
FeketekutyGHanserK, 1985, “Information technology and trade in services”Economic Impact5222–28.
13.
FineB, 1982Theories of the Capitalist Economy (Macmillan, London).
GoddardJGillespieA, 1986, “Advanced telecommunications and regional economic development”The Geographical Journal152383–397.
16.
GoodwinMDuncanS, 1986, “The local state and local economic policy: Political mobilisation or economic regeneration”Capital and Class number 27, 14–36.
17.
GrubelH, 1987, “All traded services are embodied in materials or people”World Economy10319–330.
18.
HallP, 1986, “The New Zealand urban system: Deurbanisation at the southern periphery of the world”New Zealand Geographer4265–69.
19.
HarrisR, 1987, “The role of manufacturing in regional growth”Regional Studies21301–312.
20.
HowellsJ, 1987, “Developments in the location, technology and industrial organisation of computer services: Some trends and research issues”Regional Studies21493–503.
21.
HowellsJ, 1989, “Externalisation and the formation of new industrial operations: A neglected dimension in the dynamics of industrial location”Area20289–299.
22.
JenkinsR, 1987Transnational Capital and Uneven Development (Methuen, Andover, Hants).
23.
KaiserM, 1986, “The New Zealand software industry”, RP-11a, Department of Scientific and Industrial Research, Floors 5–9, Public Trust Building, 117–125 Lambton Quay, POB 1578, Wellington 1.
24.
KeebleDKellyT, 1986, “New firms and high technology industry in the United Kingdom: The case of computer-electronics”, in New Firms and Regional Development in Europe Eds KeebleDWeverE (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants) pp 75–104.
25.
KutscherRMarkJ, 1983, “The service producing sector: Some common perceptions”Monthly Labour Review number 106, 21–24.
26.
LangdaleJ, 1985, “Electronic funds transfer and the internationalisation of the banking and finance industry”Geoforum161–13.
27.
LewisJ, 1988, “Services post industrial transformation or flexible production”, in Services and Uneven Development Ed. MarshallJ (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 279–282.
28.
MacInnesJ, 1987Thatcherism at Work (Open University Press, Milton Keynes).
29.
MacPhersonA, 1988, “Industrial innovation in the small business sector: Empirical evidence from metropolitan Toronto”Environment and Planning A20953–971.
30.
MarkJ, 1982, “Measuring productivity in service industries”Monthly Labour Review number 105, 3–8.
31.
MarksP, 1983, “The slowdown in labour productivity growth rates 1961–1981”New Zealand Economic Papers171–16.
32.
MarkusenJ, 1989, “Service trade by the multinational enterprise”, in Multinational Service Firms Ed. EnderwickP (Routledge, Chapman and Hall, Andover, Hants) pp 35–60.
33.
MarshallJ, 1988Services and Uneven Development (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
34.
MarshallJ, 1989, “Corporate reorganisation and the geography of services: Evidence from the motor vehicle aftermarket in the West Midlands region of the UK”Regional Studies23139–150.
35.
MarshallJDamesickPWoodP, 1987, “Understanding the location and role of producer services in the United Kingdom”Environment and Planning A11575–593.
36.
NusbaumerJ, 1987The Service Economy: Lever to Growth (Kluwer-Nijhoff, Boston, MA).
37.
PerryM, 1986Small Factories and Economic Development (Gower, Aldershot, Hants).
38.
PerryM, 1989a, “The demand and supply of business services in the Auckland region”, OP-26, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Private Bag, Auckland 1.
39.
PerryM, 1989b, “The international and regional context of the advertising industry in New Zealand”, OP-25, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Private Bag, Auckland 1.
40.
PerryM, 1990a, “Business service specialisation and regional economic change”Regional Studies24195–209.
41.
PerryM, 1990b, “The internationalisation of advertising”Geoforum2235–50.
42.
PetersonJ, 1989, “International trade in services: The Uruquay Round and cultural and information services”National Westminster Bank Review August issue, pp 56–67.
43.
PollertA, 1987, “The ‘flexible firm’: A model in search of reality (or a policy in search of a practice)?”, Warwick Papers in Industrial Relations 19, School of Industrial and Business Studies, University of Warwick, Warwick.
44.
PredA, 1977City Systems in Advanced Economies (John Wiley, New York).
45.
QuinnJ, 1987, “The impacts of technology in the services sectors”, in Technology and Global Industry Eds GuileBBrooksH (National Academy Press, Washington, DC) pp 119–159.
46.
Regional Studies Association, 1983Report of an Inquiry into Regional Problems in the United Kingdom (Geo Books, Norwich).
47.
RowthornBWellsJ, 1987Deindustrialisation and Foreign Trade (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
48.
RiddleD, 1986Service Led Growth: The Role of the Service Sector in World Development (Praeger, New York).
49.
RimmerP, 1986, “Australian and Japanese international engineering consultancy services”, Pacific Economic Papers 131, Australian-Japan Research Centre, Australian National University, Canberra.
50.
SavageJ, 1988, “Financial centre prospects for New Zealand”, RM 41, New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, POB 3479, Wellington.
51.
SayerA, 1989, “Postfordism in question”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research13666–696.
52.
ScottA, 1988, “Flexible production systems and regional development: The rise of new industrial spaces in North America and Western Europe”International Journal of Urban and Regional Studies22171–185.
53.
StanbackTNoyelleT, 1982Cities in Transition: Changing Job Structures in Atlanta, Denver, Buffalo, Phoenix, Columbus (Ohio), Nashville and Charlotte (Rowman and Allanheld, Totowa, NJ).
ThirlwellA, 1982, “Deindustrialisation in the United Kingdom”Lloyds Bank Review number 144, 22–37.
56.
ThriftN, 1987, “The fixers: The urban geography of international capital”, in Global Restructuring and Territorial Development Eds HendersonJCastellsM (Sage, London) pp 203–233.
57.
UNCTNC, 1987, “Foreign direct investment, the service sector and international banking” UNCTNC Current Series A7, United Nations Centre on Transnational Corporations, New York
