The analysis in this paper is directed at comparing the relative effectiveness of two different methods of meeting the Bush Administration's goals outlined in the Clean Air Plan. The analytical vehicle used in the analysis consists of a computable general equilibrium model composed of twelve producing sectors, thirteen consuming sectors, six household categories classified by income, a foreign sector, and a government. First, it is found that irrespective of what type of strategy is followed to improve environmental quality, both output and consumption decline as does household utility. Hence, there is a quantifiable trade-off between economic activity (economic growth) and the quality of the environment. Beyond this, the aggregate loss in production and economic welfare (measured by consumption expenditures and utility) is less under a policy which stresses reliance on alternative fuels (brought about by taxation) than through one that requires the installation of pollution-abatement devices (that is, regulation).
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArrowK JCheneryH BMinhasB SSolowR M, 1961, “Capital-labor substitution and economic efficiency”Review of Economics and Statistics43225–235.
2.
BallardC LFullertonDShovenJ BWhalleyJ, 1985A General Equilibrium Model for Tax Policy Evaluation (The University of Chicago, Press, Chicago, IL).
3.
BaumolW JOatesW, 1988The Theory of Environmental Policy (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
4.
BLS, 1986Consumer Expenditure Survey: Interview Survey, 1984 Bureau of Labor Statistics (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
5.
BohiD, 1981Analyzing Demand Behavior (The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD).
6.
BoydR, 1988, “The direct and indirect effects of tax reform on agriculture”, technical bulletin number 1743, Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC.
CBO, 1990Reducing the Deficit: Spending and Revenue Options Congressional Budget Office (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
9.
CEA, 1990Economic Report of the President Council of Economic Advisors (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
10.
CrandallRGruenspechtHKeelerTLaveL, 1986Regulating the Automobile (The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC).
11.
DahlC A, 1986, “Gasoline demand survey”The Energy Journal767–82.
12.
DasguptaPHealG, 1979Economic Theory and Exhaustible Resources (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
13.
DeatonAMuellbauerJ, 1980Economics and Consumer Behavior (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
14.
EIA, various years a Coal Production Energy Information Administration (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
15.
EIA, various years b Petroleum Supply Annual Energy Information Administration (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
16.
FreemanS D, 1990, “Statement before the House Ways and Means Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives”, 6 March 1990; available from Committee on Ways and Means, US House of Representatives, Washington DC 20510.
17.
FriedmanL S, 1984Microeconomic Policy Analysis (McGraw-Hill, New York).
18.
HarbergerA, 1962, “The incidence of corporate taxation”Journal of Political Economy70215–240.
19.
HarbergerA, 1974Taxation and Welfare (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
20.
HarringtonDSchluterGO'BrienP, 1986Agriculture's Link to the Macroeconomy AIB 504, Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC.
21.
HeadyF ODillonJ L, 1961Agricultural Production Functions (Iowa State University Press, Ames, IA).
22.
HertelT W, 1988, “Economywide analysis of U.S. agriculture: What have we learned and how can we teach it?”, staff paper 88–8, Department of Agricultural Economics, Purdue University, West Lafeyette, IN 47907.
23.
HertelT WTsigasM E, 1987, “Tax policy and U.S. agriculture: A general equilibrium analysis”, staff paper 87–2, Department of Agricultural Economics, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907.
24.
HuangW-YUriN D, 1990, “An analytical framework for assessing the benefits and costs of policies related to protecting groundwater quality”Environment and Planning A221469–1486.
25.
HuangW-YUriN D, 1991, “An analysis of the marginal value of cropland and nitrogen fertilizer use under alternative farm programs”Agricultural Systems forthcoming.
26.
HudsonE AJorgensonD W, 1974, “Energy policy and economic growth”The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science5461–514.
27.
JohanssonP O, 1987The Economic Theory and Measurement of Environmental Benefits (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
28.
JohnsonO, 1990The 1990 Information Please Almanac (Houghton Mifflin, Boston, MA).
29.
JorgensonD W, 1984, “Econometric methods for applied general equilibrium analysis”, in Applied General Equilibrium Analysis Eds ScarfH EShovenJ B (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 139–203.
30.
KokoskiMSmithV K, 1987, “A general equilibrium analysis of partial-equilibrium welfare measures: The case of climate change”American Economic Review77331–341.
31.
KoskoresN, 1990, “Statement before the Committee on Ways and Means, U.S. House of Representatives”, 6 March 1990; available from Committee on Ways and Means, US House of Representatives, Washington DC 20510.
32.
LabysW CYangC, 1989, “A sensitivity analysis of the linear complementary programming model: Appalachian steam coal and natural gas”, in Quantitative Methods for Market Oriented Economic Analysis over Space and Time Eds LabysWTakayamaTUriN D (Gower, Aldershot, Hants) pp 69–86.
33.
McGartlandA, 1988, “A comparison of two marketable discharge permits systems”Journal of Environmental Economics and Management1535–44.
34.
MacKinnonJ, 1984, “Comments”, in Applied General Equilibrium Analysis Eds ScarfH EShovenJ B (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 203–208.
35.
MaloneyMMcCormickR, 1982, “A positive theory of environmental quality regulation”Journal of Law and Economics2599–124.
36.
MaluegD, 1989, “Emission credit trading and the incentive to adopt new pollution abatement technology”Journal of Environmental Economics and Management1652–57.
37.
MaluegD, 1990, “Welfare consequence of emission credit trading”Journal of Environmental Economics and Management1866–77.
38.
MathiesenL, 1985a, “Computational experience in solving equilibrium models by a sequence of linear complementary problems”Operations Research331225–1250.
39.
MathiesenL, 1985b, “Computation of economic equilibrium by a sequence of linear complementary problems”Mathematical Programming Study number 23.
40.
MixonJ WUriN D, 1985Managerial Economics (Macmillan, New York).
41.
MontgomeryDMarcussR, 1990, “Statement before the committee on Ways and Means, U.S. House of Representatives”, 7 March 1990; available from Committee on Ways and Means, US House of Representatives, Washington DC 20510.
ScarfH E, 1967, “The approximation of fixed points of a continuous mapping”SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics151328–1343.
44.
SeskinEAndersonRReidR, 1983, “An empirical analysis of economic strategies for controlling air pollution”Journal of Environmental Economics and Management10112–124.
45.
ShovenJ BWhalleyJ, 1972, “A general equilibrium calculation of the effects of differential taxation of income from capital in the U.S.”Journal of Public Economics1281–322.
46.
TakayamaTUriN D, 1983, “A note on spatial and temporal price and allocation modelling”Regional Science and Urban Economics13455–470.
47.
The White House, 1989Fact Sheet: President Bush's Clean Air PlanOffice of the Press Secretary, The White House, Washington, DC, 12 June.
48.
TietenbergT, 1980, “Transferable discharge permits and the control of stationary source air pollution: A survey and synthesis”Land Economics56391–416.
49.
USGAO, 1982A Market Approach to Air Pollution Control Could Reduce Compliance Costs without Jeopardizing Clean Air GoalsUS General Accounting Office, Washington, DC 20503, 23 March.
50.
UriN D, 1982The Demand for Energy and Conservation in the United States (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT).
51.
UriN D, 1983New Dimensions in Public Utility Pricing (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT).
52.
UriN D, 1984, “The impact of technical change on the aggregate production function”Applied Economics16555–567.
53.
YoheG, 1979, “The backward incidence of pollution control”The Journal of Environmental Economics and Management6187–198.
