The impact of state intervention on changing patterns of skill formation and utilisation is examined with particular reference to youth employment in the engineering industry in the North West region of England over the period 1981–88. The apprenticeship system is being gradually superseded by the Youth Training Scheme (YTS) as the dominant mode of skill formation. This process of supersession, which in the paper is termed that of ‘colonisation’, is shown to be a highly uneven one, YTS having different impacts in different places. In case studies of the impact of the scheme on two local labour markets, Preston and Crewe, links are established between patterns of colonisation by YTS and (1) the nature of the preexisting training institutions, and (2) the state of the local labour market. YTS is shown to be bringing about far-reaching consequences for the process of skill formation and for patterns of labour-market segmentation.
AllenJ, 1988, “Fragmented firms, disorganised labour?”, in The Economy in Question Eds AllenJMasseyD (Sage, London) pp 184–228
3.
AllenV, 1977, “The differentiation of the working class”, in Class and Class Structure Ed. HuntA (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 61–79
4.
AshbyP, 1989, “Training and Enterprise Councils: Assessing the gamble”Policy Studies10(2) 31–40
5.
AshtonDNMaguireMJ, 1983The Vanishing Youth Labour MarketYouth Aid, 17 Brownhill Road, London SE6
6.
BeecheyV, 1985, “The shape of the workforce to come”Marxism Today (August) 11–16
7.
BennettRJMcCoshanASellgrenJ, 1990, “TECs and VET: The practical requirements of organisation and geography”Regional Studies24(1) 65–69
8.
BosanquetNDoeringerPB, 1973, “Is there a dual labour market in Britain?”Economic Journal82421–435
9.
BowersJDeatonDTurkJ, 1982Labour Hoarding in British Industry (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
10.
CBI, 1989Training and Enterprise Councils—The Way ForwardConfederation of British Industry, Centre Point, New Oxford Street, London WC1
11.
ChallisBMasonCParkesD, 1986, “YTS and the local authority”Research and Development Series number 37 (Manpower Services Commission, Moorfoot, Sheffield S1 4PQ)
12.
CockburnC, 1983Brothers: Male Dominance and Technological Change (Pluto Press, London)
13.
CraigCRuberyJTarlingRWilkinsonF, 1982, “Labour market structure, industrial organisation and low pay”, OP-54, Department of Applied Economics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
14.
DeakinBMPrattenCF, 1987, “Economic effects of YTS”Employment Gazette95491–497
15.
Department of Employment, 1988Employment for the 1990s cmnd 540 (HMSO, London)
16.
DuttonP, 1986, “The impact of YTS on engineering apprenticeship: A local labour market study”, research report, Institute for Employment, University of Warwick, Coventry
17.
FairleyJGrahlJ, 1983, “Conservative training policy and the alternatives”, in Socialist Economic Review 1983 Eds SawyerMSchottK (Merlin Press, London)
18.
Financial Times1989a, “Training proposals in White Paper attacked”, 9 January
19.
Financial Times1989b, “Unions angry over move on YTS”, 20 February
20.
Financial Times1989c, “Employers to take lead on training”, 11 March
21.
FinnD, 1987Training Without Jobs: New Deals and Broken Promises (Macmillan, London)
22.
FinnD, 1988, “Training and employment schemes for the long term unemployed: British Government policy for the 1990s”Work, Employment and Society2521–534
23.
GoldsteinN, 1984, “The new training initiative: A great leap backward”Capital and Class2383–106
24.
GreenAEOwenDW, 1989, “The changing geography of occupations in engineering in Britain, 1978–1987”Regional Studies23(1) 27–42
25.
HakimC, 1987, “Trends in the flexible workforce”Employment Gazette95549–561
HaughtonG, 1989, “Understanding local labour markets and skills mismatch”, paper presented at the seminar “Skills Mismatch, Training and Local Labour Market Policy into the 1990s”, Leeds, May, available from Centre for Urban Development and Environmental Management, Department of Urban Planning, Leeds Polytechnic, Leeds
28.
HCEC, 1987Skills Shortages: Minutes of Evidence House of Commons Employment Committee (HMSO, London)
29.
HolmesJ, 1986, “The organisation and locational structure of production subcontracting”, in Production, Work, Territory: The Geographical Anatomy of Industrial Capitalism Eds ScottAJStorperM (Allen and Unwin, Winchester, MA) pp 80–106
30.
HuntJSmallP, 1981Employing Young People: A Study of Employers' Attitudes, Policies and Practice (Scottish Council for Research in Education, Edinburgh)
31.
IDS, 1989, “White Paper recasts U.K. training”, IDS European Report number 326, page 15
32.
IDS/PA, 1987, “United Kingdom”, IDS/PA European Report number 286, pp 6–7
33.
IER, 1987Review of the Economy and Employment, 1987Institute for Employment Research, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL
34.
ImrieRF, 1986, “Work decentralisation from large to small firms: A preliminary analysis of subcontracting”Environment and Planning A18949–965
35.
JacksonM, 1986, “A seat at the table?”, in Challenging the MSC on Education, Training and Jobs: Enquiry Into a National Disaster Eds BennCFairleyJ (Pluto Press, London) pp 117–200
36.
JenkinsRBrymanAFordJKeilTBeardsworthA, 1983, “Information and the labour market: The impact of recession”Sociology17260–267
37.
JohnstonT, 1987, “Manpower policy—pragmatism or principles?”Royal Bank of Scotland Review number 155, 3–13
38.
Labour Research Department, 1984, “Youth: Whither YTS?”Labour Research73253–255
39.
LaslettRELaidlawCJ, 1985Regional Profile: Trends in Engineering Manpower and Training in the North West of England from 1978 (Engineering Industry Training Board, Watford)
40.
LeeDJ, 1972, “Very small firms and the training of engineering craftsmen”British Journal of Industrial Relations10240–255
41.
LeeGWrenchJ, 1984, “Routes into segmented youth labour markets”International Journal of Social Economics1177–90
42.
LindleyRM, 1975, “The demand for apprentice recruits by the engineering industry”Scottish Journal of Political Economy22(1) 1–24
43.
LittlerCRSalamanG, 1984Class at Work: The Design, Allocation and Control of Jobs (Batsford, London)
44.
LivockR, 1983, “Screening in the recruitment of young workers”, RP-41, Department of Employment, Caxton House, Tothill Street, London SW1
45.
LloydPE, 1983, “North West England 1975–1980: Industrial change and job generation under conditions of recession”, final report to the Social Science Research Council; available from Centre for Urban and Regional Industrial Development, School of Geography, Manchester University, Manchester
46.
LloydPECarterDEPeckJA, 1986, “Young people in the labour market: A profile of the YTS scheme in Preston”, final report to the Manpower Services Commission, available from Centre for Urban and Regional Industrial Development, School of Geography, Manchester University, Manchester
47.
LloydPEShuttJ, 1985, “Recession and restructuring in the North West region 1975–82: The implications of recent events”, in Politics and Method: Contrasting Studies in Industrial Geography Eds MasseyDMeeganR (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 13–60
48.
ManwaringT, 1984, “The extended internal labour market”Cambridge Journal of Economics8161–187
49.
MarkallG, 1983, “Cheap labour …? A review of work experience on employer's premises in Central Liverpool”, OP-2, Youth Aid, 17 Brownhill Road, London SE6
50.
MartinR, 1988, “Technological change and manual work”, in Employment in Britain Ed. GallieD (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 102–127
51.
MasonG, 1987, “The short-term thinking behind skill shortage”The Guardian 19 March
52.
MasonG, 1988Occupational Profile: Trends in Employment and Training of Craftsmen and Craftswomen in the Engineering Industry (Engineering Industry Training Board, 54 Clarendon Road, PO Box 176, Watford WD1 1LB)
53.
MoreC, 1980Skill and the English Working Class, 1870–1914 (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants)
54.
MoreC, 1982, “Skill and the survival of apprenticeship”, in The Degradation of Work? Skill, Deskilling and the Labour Process Ed. WoodS (Hutchinson Education, London) pp 109–121
55.
MoulaertF, 1987, “An institutional revisit to the Storper—Walker theory of labour”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research11309–330
56.
MSC, 1975Vocational Preparation for Young People (Manpower Services Commission, Moorfoot, Sheffield)
57.
MSC, 1982Youth Task Group Report (Manpower Services Commission, Moorfoot, Sheffield)
58.
MSC, 1985Development of the Youth Training Scheme: A Report (Manpower Services Commission, Moorfoot, Sheffield)
59.
PeckJA, 1988The Structure and Segmentation of Local Labour Markets: Aspects of the Geographical Anatomy of Youth Employment in Great Britain PhD thesis, School of Geography, Manchester University, Manchester
60.
PeckJA, 1989, “Labour market segmentation theory”Labour and Industry2(1) 119–144
61.
PeckJA, 1990a, “The state and the regulation of local labour markets: Observations on the geography of the Youth Training Scheme”Area22(1) 17–27
62.
PeckJA, 1990b, “Training for enterprise?”Local Work142–6
63.
PeckJA, 1990c, “The Youth Training Scheme: Regional policy in reverse?”Policy and Politics18135–143
64.
PeckJA, 1990d“Post-corporatism” in Practice: TECs and the Local Politics of Training SPA Working Paper, number 9; available from SPA, School of Geography, Manchester University, Manchester M13 9PL
65.
PeckJAEmmerichM, 1991Challenging the TECsCentre for Local Economic Strategies, Manchester; available from CLES, Alberton House, St Mary's Parsonage, Manchester M3 2WJ
66.
PeckJAHaughtonGFLloydPE, 1987, “Skills in flux: Inertia and change in the engineering industry”, final report to the Economic and Social Research Council; available from Centre for Urban and Regional Industrial Development, School of Geography, Manchester University, Manchester
67.
PeckJALloydPE, 1989, “Conceptualising processes of skill change: A local labour market approach”, in Labour, Environment and Industrial Change Eds LingeGJRvan der KnappG A (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants) pp 107–127
68.
PeckJALloydPECarterDE, 1986, “The impact of new funding regimes on YTS: The experience of ex-mode B1 providers”, final report to the Manpower Services Commission; available from CURID, School of Geography, Manchester University, Manchester
69.
PhillipsATaylorB, 1980, “Sex and skill: Notes towards a feminist economics”Feminist Review679–88
70.
PioreMJ, 1980, “Economic fluctuation, job security and labor-market duality in Italy, France and the United States”Politics and Society9379–407
71.
PraisSJ, 1988, “Qualified manpower in engineering: Britain and other industrially advanced countries”National Institute Economic Review number 127, 76–83
72.
RobertsK, 1984School-leavers and Their Prospects: Youth and the Labour Market in the 1980s (Open University Press, Milton Keynes)
73.
RobertsonDB, 1986, “Mrs Thatcher's employment prescription: An active neo-liberal labour market policy”Journal of Public Policy6275–296
74.
SabelC, 1982Work and Politics: The Division of Labor in Industry (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
75.
St John-BrooksC, 1985, “Who controls training? The rise of the Manpower Services Commission”, Fabian Tract number 506 (The Fabian Society, London)
76.
ShinkinsS, 1988Training for Tomorrow RP-10 (Engineering Industry Training Board, 54 Clarendon Road, PO Box 176, Watford WD1 1LB)
77.
ShuttJWhittingtonR, 1987, “Fragmentation strategies and the rise of small units: Cases from the North West”Regional Studies21(1) 13–23
78.
SolomosJ, 1985, “Extended review: Youth training, unemployment and state policies”Sociological Review33343–353
79.
StreeckW, 1989, “Skills and the limits of neoliberalism: The enterprise of the future as a place of learning”Work, Employment and Society3(1) 89–104
80.
StringerJKWilliamsonP, 1987, “Policy implementation, policy development and policy change: The Youth Training Scheme”Public Policy and Administration2(3) 35–56
81.
TowersB, 1989Training and Enterprise Councils: A Briefing for Unemployed Centres, Trade Unions and Community Groups (Merseyside Trade Union, Community and Unemployed Resource Centre, 24 Hardman Street, Liverpool L1 9AX)
82.
Training Agency, 1989a, “Skills supply and demand”Labour Market Quarterly Review (January) 6
83.
Training Agency, 1989bTraining and Enterprise Councils: A Prospectus for the 1990s (Training Agency, Moorfoot, Sheffield S1 4PQ)
84.
Training Commission, 1988Skills Monitoring Report August; available from Training Commission, Moorfoot, Sheffield S1
85.
YoungD, 1982, “Worried about unemployment? How you can help …”The Director (August) 34–35
86.
Youthaid, 1981Quality or Collapse? Youthaid Review of the Youth Opportunities ProgrammeYouthaid, 17 Brownhill Road, London SE6
87.
Youth Training Board, 1985, “YTS progress”, unpublished Youth Training Board paper YTB/85/15 (Manpower Services Commission, Moorfoot, Sheffield S1 4PQ)
88.
YTS Monitoring Unit, 1985The Great Training Robbery Continues: A Follow-up Investigation of the Role of Private Training Agencies in Birmingham/Solihull/(Trade Union Resources Centre, Birmingham)
89.
ZeitlinJ, 1979, “Craft control and the division of labour: Engineers and compositors in Britain, 1890–1930”Cambridge Journal of Economics3263–274
90.
ZeitlinJ, 1981Craft Regulation and the Division of Labour: Engineers and Compositors in Britain, 1890–1914 PhD thesis, Department of Social History, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL
