The fashion for Marxist analysis in planning theory has all but passed without a satisfactory answer being given to the question: what does the theory tell planners to do? This question can only be answered by conceiving of planning as a political activity in the broadest sense, and by examining Marxian political theory which deals with its subject through the perspective of class conflict. The Marxian concept of class, however, is problematic. In this paper recent developments in Marxian class theory are traced and a movement is found away from a reductionist structural perspective towards one which accepts the importance of nonclass as well as class structures, the existence of new classes cutting across the economic categories of capital and labour, and the significance of individual interests and subjectivity, in short a movement towards pluralism. A critique of reductionism is offered, focusing initially on the work of Harvey, and concludes with some tentative answers to the question posed above.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbercrombieNUrryJ, 1983Capital, Labour and the Middle ClassesAllen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
2.
AlfordR RFriedlandR, 1985Powers of Theory: Capitalism, the State and DemocracyCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
BeethamD, 1985Max Weber and the Theory of Modern Politicssecond edition (Polity Press, Cambridge)
5.
BensonJ K, 1975, “The interorganizational network as a political economy”Administrative Science Quarterly20 (June) 229–249
6.
BensonJ KWeitzelC, 1985, “Social structure and social practice in interorganizational policy analysis”, in Policy Implementation in Federal and Unitary Systems, Questions of Analysis and Design Eds HanfKToonenT A J (Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht) pp 267–285
7.
BentleyA, 1935The Process of GovernmentPrincipia Press, IL)
8.
BermanM, 1984, “The signs in the street: A response to Perry Anderson”New Left Review144114–123
9.
BourdieuP, 1977Outline of a Theory of PracticeCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
10.
BrysonJ MRoeringW D, 1987, “Applying private-sector strategic planning in the public sector”Journal of the American Planning Association539–21
11.
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grass RootsEdward Arnold, London)
12.
CawsonASaundersP, 1983, “Corporatism, competitive politics and class struggle”, in Capital and Politics Ed. KingR (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Andover, Hants) pp 8–27
13.
CrensonM, 1983Neighbourhood PoliticsHarvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
14.
DahlR A, 1982Dilemmas of Pluralist Democracy, Autonomy versus ControlYale University Press, New Haven, CT)
15.
DahlR A, 1985A Preface to Economic DemocracyUniversity of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
16.
DahlR ALindblomC E, 1953Politics, Economics and WelfareHarper and Row, New York)
17.
de NeufvilleJ, 1987, “Knowledge and action, making the link”Journal of Planning Education and Research686–92
18.
FainsteinN IFainsteinS S, 1979, “New debates in urban planning: The impact of Marxist theory within the United States”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research3381–403
19.
FaludiA, 1987A Decision-centred View of Environmental PlanningPergamon Press, Oxford)
20.
ForesterJ, 1980, “Critical theory and planning practice”Journal of the American Association of Planners46275–286
21.
FriedmannJ, 1987Planning in the Public DomainPrinceton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
22.
GiddensA, 1973The Class Structure of the Advanced SocietiesCentury Hutchinson, London)
23.
GiddensA, 1979Central Problems in Social TheoryMacmillan, London)
24.
GottdienerM, 1987The Decline of Urban Politics, Political Theory and the Crisis of the Local StateSage, Beverly Hills, CA)
25.
HallS, 1977, “The political and the economic in Marx's theory of classes”, in Class and Class Structure Ed. HuntA (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 15–60
26.
HarveyD, 1982The Limits to CapitalBasil Blackwell, Oxford)
27.
HarveyD, 1985a, “Class structure and the theory of residential differentiation”, in The Urbanization of Capital Ed. HarveyD (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 109–124
28.
HarveyD, 1985b, “The place of urban politics in the geography of uneven capitalist development”, in The Urbanization of Capital Ed. HarveyD (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 125–164
29.
HarveyD, 1985c, “On planning the ideology of planning”, in The Urbanization of Capital Ed. HarveyD (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 165–184
30.
HarveyD, 1985dConsciousness and the Urban ExperienceBasil Blackwell, Oxford)
31.
HarveyD, 1987a, “Flexible accumulation through urbanization: Reflections on ‘post-modernism’ in the American city”Antipode19260–286
32.
HarveyD, 1987b, “Three myths in search of a reality”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space5367–376
33.
HealeyPMcNamaraPElsonMDoakA, 1988The British Planning System in Practice: Land Use Planning and the Mediation of Urban ChangeCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
34.
HenigJ, 1982Neighbourhood Mobilization, Redevelopment and ResponseRutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ)
35.
HindessB, 1978, “Classes and politics in Marxist theory”, in Power and the State Eds LittlejohnGSmartBWakefordJYuval-DavisN (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants) pp 72–97
36.
HirstP, 1977, “Economic classes and politics”, in Class and Class Structure Ed. HuntA (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 125–154
37.
HochC, 1984, “Doing good and being right, the pragmatic connection in planning theory”Journal of the American Planning Association50335–343
38.
HoffJ, 1985, “The concept of class and public employees”Acta Sociologica28207–226
39.
HousemanG L, 1982City of the Right, Urban Applications of American Conservative ThoughtGreenwood Press, Westport, CT)
40.
JessopB, 1982The Capitalist State, Marxist Theories and MethodsMartin Robertson, Oxford)
41.
JonesG W, 1986, “The crisis in British central — local relationships”, paper presented at the Conference of the Structure of Government Research Committee of the International Political Science Association, Pittsburgh, 12 December 1986, “Governing in the Midst of Change”; paper obtainable from G W Jones, London School of Economics, Houghton Street, London WC2
42.
KaufmanJ LJacobsH M, 1987, “A public planning perspective on strategic planning”Journal of the American Planning Association5323–33
43.
KingR J, 1989, “Capital switching and the role of ground rent: 1. Theoretical problems”Environment and Planning A21445–462
44.
LowN PPowerJ M, 1984, “Policy systems in an Australian metropolitan region: Political and economic determinants of change in Victoria”Progress in Planning33147–215
45.
McConnellG, 1967Private Power and American DemocracyAlfred A Knopf, New York)
46.
MarxK, 1962aThe Class Struggles in France in Selected Worksvolume 1 (Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow) pp 118–242
47.
MarxK, 1962bThe Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte in Selected Worksvolume 1 (Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow) pp 247–344
MasseyD, 1984Spatial Divisions of LabourMacmillan, London)
50.
MillJ S, 1971On LibertyDent, London)
51.
MollenkopfJ, 1983The Contested CityPrinceton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
52.
MoserS TLowN P, 1986, “The central business district of Melbourne and the dispersal and reconcentration of capital”Environment and Planning A181447–1461
53.
OlsonM, 1965The Logic of Collective ActionHarvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
54.
ParkinA, 1984, “The states and the cities: A comparative perspective”, in Australian Urban Politics, Critical Perspectives Eds HalliganJParisC (Longman Cheshire, Melbourne) pp 15–30
SmithN, 1987a, “Dangers of the empirical turn: Some comments on the CURS initiative”Antipode1959–68
67.
SmithN, 1987b, “Rascal concepts, minimalizing discourse, and the politics of geography”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space5377–383
68.
ThriftN, 1987, “Introduction, the geography of late twentieth century class formation”, in Class and Space, the Making of Urban Society Eds ThriftNWilliamsP (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Andover, Hants) pp 207–253
69.
ThriftNWilliamsP, 1987Class and Space, the Making of Urban SocietyRoutledge and Kegan Paul, Andover, Hants)
70.
UrryJ, 1973, “Towards a structural theory of the middle class”Acta Sociologica16175–187
71.
UrryJ, 1981The Anatomy of Capitalist Societies, the Economy, Civil Society and the StateMacmillan, London)
72.
Van TilJ, 1984, “Citizen participation in the future”Policy Studies Review3311–322
73.
WasteR J, 1987Power and Pluralism in American Cities, Researching the Urban LaboratoryGreenwood Press, Westport, CT)
74.
WrightE O, 1976, “Class boundaries in advanced capitalist societies”New Left Reviewnumber 98, 3–41
75.
WrightE O, 1980, “Varieties of Marxist conceptions of class structure”Politics and Society9323–370
76.
WrightE O, 1984, “A general framework for the analysis of class structure”Politics and Society13383–423
77.
ZeiglerH, 1980, “Interest groups and public policy, a comparative revisionist perspective”, in Interest Groups and Public Policy Ed. ScottR (Macmillan, Melbourne) pp 1–16
