The food crisis of 2007–08 generated widespread global concerns about land consolidation and agricultural transition, with renewed attention on foreign land investments and growing global markets for meat and biofuels. As part of and alongside this process, agriculture and land-use projects registered in the Kyoto Protocol's Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) continued to rise, representing almost a third of global projects and almost 50% of projects in Latin America. In this paper we conduct an analysis of the sustainable development claims of Latin American CDM projects, focusing particularly on their implications for land consolidation, regional food security, and agrarian justice. Our analysis suggests that in Latin America those benefiting most from the development and sale of carbon-offset projects have, to date, been large-scale corporations investing in industrial carbon projects such as large tree plantations, sugarcane, and large-scale, export-oriented livestock production. As such, we argue that the carbonization of agriculture through the CDM serves as a driver of ‘global green grabbing’ and that the scope and financialization of CDM projects in the agriculture and forestry sectors in Latin America may contribute to the maintenance of an agrarian system of ‘climate injustice’ rather than foster sustainable development across the region.
Akram-LodhiA HKayC (2008) Peasants and Globalisation: Political Economy, Rural Transformation and the Agrarian Question, London: Routledge
2.
AlarcónC (2009) “The politics of methane abatement and CDM projects based on industrial swine production in Chile”. In: BöhmSDabhiS (eds) Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets, London: Mayfly Books, pp. 72–85
3.
Alexandratos N, Bruinsma J, 2012, “World agriculture towards 2030/2050”, Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome
4.
AndersonE KZerriffiH (2012) “Seeing the trees for the carbon: agroforestry for development and carbon mitigation”. Climatic Change115(3–4): 741–757
5.
BadgleyCMoghtaderJQuinteroEZakemEChappellM JAvilés-VázquezKSamulonAPerfectoI (2007) “Organic agriculture and the global food supply”. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems22(2): 86–108
6.
BaileyI (2007) “Market environmentalism, new environmental policy instruments, and climate policy in the United Kingdom and Germany”. Annals of the Association of American Geographers97: 530–550
BeddingtonJ R (2012) “Agriculture: what next for agriculture after Durban?”. Science335: 289–290
9.
Berdegué J A, Fuentealba R, 2011, “Latin America: the state of smallholders in agriculture”, International Fund for Agricultural Development, Rome
10.
BohmSMisoczkyM CMoogS (2012) “Greening capitalism? A Marxist critique of carbon markets”. Organization Studies33: 1617–1638
11.
BondP (2011) “Emissions trading, new enclosures and eco-social contestation”. Antipode44: 684–701
12.
BorrasS MJrFrancoJ C (2012) “Global land grabbing and trajectories of agrarian change: a preliminary analysis”. Journal of Agrarian Change12(1): 34–59
13.
BorrasS MJrFrancoJ CGómezSKayCSpoorM (2012a) “Land grabbing in Latin America and the Caribbean”. Journal of Peasant Studies39(3–4): 845–872
14.
BorrasS MJrKayCGómezSWilkinsonJ (2012b) “Land grabbing and global capitalist accumulation: key features in Latin America”. Canadian Journal of Development Studies/Revue canadienne d'études du développement33: 402–416
15.
BoydE (2009) “Governing the Clean Development Mechanism: global rhetoric versus local realities in carbon sequestration projects”. Environment and Planning A41: 2380–2395
16.
BoydEBoykoffMNewellP (2011) “The ‘new’ carbon economy: what's new?”. Antipode43: 601–611
17.
BoykoffM TBumpusALivermanDRandallsS (2009) “Guest editorial.Theorizing the carbon economy: introduction to the special issue”. Environment and Planning A41: 2299–2304
18.
BumpusA GLivermanD M (2008) “Accumulation by decarbonization and the governance of carbon offsets”. Economic Geography84(2): 127–155
19.
CDM Rulebook, 2013 Clean Development Mechanism Rules, Practice and Procedures,http://www.cdmrulebook.org
20.
Chappell M J et al, 2013, “Food sovereignty: an alternative paradigm for poverty reduction and biodiversity conservation in Latin America” F1000Research doi:10.12688/f1000research.2-235.v1
21.
ClappJ (2014) “Financialization, distance and global food politics”. Journal of Peasant Studies41: 797–814
22.
CorberaEBrownK (2010) “Offsetting benefits? Analyzing access to forest carbon”. Environment and Planning A42: 1739–1761
23.
CorberaEFriedliC (2012) “Planting trees through the Clean Development Mechanism: a critical assessment”. Ephemera12: 206–241
24.
CorberaEJoverN (2012) “The undelivered promises of the Clean Development Mechanism: insights from three projects in Mexico”. Carbon Management3: 39–54
25.
DauvergnePNevilleK J (2010) “Forests, food, and fuel in the tropics: the uneven social and ecological consequences of the emerging political economy of biofuels”. Journal of Peasant Studies37: 631–660
26.
Davies N, 2007, “Truth about Kyoto: huge profits, little carbon saved” The Guardian 2 June, page 6
27.
de Schutter O, 2011, “Agroecology and the right to food: report submitted by the Special Rapporteur on the right to food”, 16th edition, United Nations Human Rights Council, New York
28.
ECLAC (2013) Foreign Direct Investment in Latin America 2012, Santiago: United NationsEconomic Commission for Latin America
29.
EllisJWinklerHCorfee-MorlotJGagnon-LebrunF (2007) “CDM: taking stock and looking forward”. Energy Policy35(1): 15–28
30.
FairbairnM (2014) “‘Like gold with yield’: evolving intersections between farmland and finance”. Journal of Peasant Studies41: 777–795
Fenhann J, 2012, “CDM Pipeline Project”, United Nations Environment Programme, Riso Centre on Energy, Climate and Sustainable Development
33.
GilbertsonTReyesO (2009) Carbon Trading: How it Works and Why it Fails, Uppsala: Dag Hammarskjöld Foundation
34.
GodfrayH C JBeddingtonJ RCruteI RHaddadLLawrenceDMuirJ FPrettyJRobinsonSThomasS MToulminC (2010) “Food security: the challenge of feeding 9 billion people”. Science327(5967): 812–818
35.
Gutiérrez-Vélez V H, Defenders of the Land, Pinedo-Vásquez M, Uriarte M, Padoch C, Baethgen W, Fernandes K, Lim Y, 2011, “High-yield oil palm expansion spares land at the expense of forests in the Peruvian Amazon” Environmental Research Letters6(4) 044029
36.
IAASTD (2009) Agriculture at a Crossroads: Global Summary for Decision Makers, Washington, DC: International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science and Technology for Development, Island Press
37.
JaroszL (2009) “Energy, climate change, meat, and markets: mapping the coordinates of the current world food crisis”. Geography Compass3: 2065–2083
38.
KosoyNCorberaE (2010) “Payments for ecosystem services as commodity fetishism”. Ecological Economics69: 1228–1236
39.
LiT M (2014) “What is land? Assembling a resource for global investment”. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series39: 589–602
40.
LohmannL (2010a) “Uncertainty markets and carbon markets: variations on Polanyian themes”. New Political Economy15: 225–254
McAfeeKShapiroE N (2010) “Payments for ecosystem services in Mexico: nature, neoliberalism, social movements and the state”. Annals of the Association of American Geographers100: 579–599
43.
McMichaelP (2008) “Peasants make their own history, but not just as they please”. Journal of Agrarian Change8(2–3): 205–228
44.
McMichaelP (2010) “Agrofuels in the food regime”. Journal of Peasant Studies37: 609–629
45.
McMichaelP (2012) “Food regime crisis and reevaluating the agrarian question”. In: AlmasRCampbellH (eds) Rethinking Agricultural Policy Regimes: Food Security, Climate Change and the Future Resilience of Global Agriculture, Bingley, Yorks: Emerald Group, pp. 99–122
46.
NiernenbergD (2005) Happier Meals, Washington, DC: Worldwatch Institute
47.
OlsenK H (2007) “The clean development mechanism's contribution to sustainable development: a review of the literature”. Climatic Change84(1): 59–73
48.
OteroGPechlanerGGurcanE C (2013) “The political economy of ‘food security’ and trade: uneven and combined dependency”. Rural Sociology78: 263–289
49.
PatelR (2009) “Food sovereignty”. Journal of Peasant Studies36: 663–673
50.
PaulssonE (2009) “A review of the CDM literature: from fine-tuning to critical scrutiny?”. International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics9(1): 63–80
51.
RobertsJ TParksB C (2007) A Climate of Injustice: Global Inequality, North–South Politics, and Climate Policy, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
52.
Robinson T P et al, 2011, “Global livestock production systems”, Food and Agriculture Organization and International Livestock Research Institute, Rome
53.
SasakiNPutzF E (2009) “Critical need for new definitions of “forest” and ‘forest degradation’ in global climate change agreements”. Conservation Letters2(5): 226–232
54.
SikorT (2013) “Global land governance: from territory to flow?”. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability5: 522–527
55.
ThomasSDarguschPHarrisonSHerbohnJ (2010) “Why are there so few afforestation and reforestation Clean Development Mechanism projects?”. Land Use Policy27: 880–887
56.
TschakertPCoomesO TPotvinC (2007) “Indigenous livelihoods, slash-and-burn agriculture, and carbon stocks in Eastern Panama”. Ecological Economics60: 807–820
57.
TscharntkeTCloughYWangerT CJacksonLMotzkeIPerfectoIVandermeerJWhitbreadA (2012) “Global food security, biodiversity conservation and the future of agricultural intensification”. Biological Conservation151(1): 53–59
58.
TubielloFNRahmanAMannWSchmidhuberJKolevaMMüllerA (2009) “Carbon financial mechanisms for agriculture and rural development: challenges and opportunities along the Bali roadmap: an editorial essay”. Climatic Change97: 3–21
59.
TubielloFNSalvatoreMRossiSFerraraAFittonNSmithP (2013) “The FAOSTAT database of greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture”. Environmental Research Letters8: 015009doi:10.1088/1748-9326/8/1/015009
60.
Tubiello F N, Salvatore M, Golec R D C, Ferrara A, Rossi S, Biancalani R, Federici S, Jacobs H, Flammini A, 2014, “Agriculture, forestry and other land use emissions by sources and removals by sinks”, Statistics Division, Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome
VorleyBCotulaLChanM-K (2012) Tipping the Balance: Policies to Shape Agricultural Investments and Markets in Favour of Small-scale Farmers, London: International Institute for Environmental Development
64.
Wilkes A, Tennigkeit T, Solymosi K, 2013, “National integrated mitigation planning in agriculture: a review paper”, Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome
65.
WittmanH (2011) “Food sovereignty: a new rights framework for food and nature?”. Environment and Society: Advances in Research2(1): 87–105
66.
WittmanH KCaronC (2009) “Carbon offsets and inequality: social costs and co-benefits in Guatemala and Sri Lanka”. Society and Natural Resources22: 710–726
67.
World Bank, 2014, “State and trends of carbon pricing”, World Bank, Washington, DC
68.
ZaksD P MBarfordC CRamankuttyNFoleyJ A (2009) “Producer and consumer responsibility for greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural production—a perspective from the Brazilian Amazon”. Environmental Research Letters4(4): 044010
