Patterns of intraurban accessibility to primary medical care in four major Scottish cities are examined in the context of existing public policy and against the background of intraurban patterns of community well-being. Certain regularities are observed in the spatial ecology of family doctors' surgeries, and the notion of an ‘inverse care law’ is discussed. A modified interaction model is introduced and used to analyse local accessibility to primary care facilities. Results indicate that disparities in accessibility tend to compound many other patterns of socioeconomic disadvantage. The formulation of public policies concerned with medical deprivation and area deprivation is discussed in the light of these results.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BackettE M, 1954“Adolescence and the family doctor”British Medical Journal1934
2.
BibleB L, 1970“Physicians' views of medical practice in nonmetropolitan communities”Public Health Reports8511–21
3.
BradleyJ EKirbyA MTaylorP J, 1976Distance Decay and Dental Decay seminar paper 31, Department of Geography, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, England
4.
BrownR G SWalkerC, 1973“Doctors' dilemma”New Society538183–184
5.
ButlerJ RBevanJ MTaylorR C, 1973Family Doctors and Public Policy (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon)
6.
CalvoA BMarksD H, 1973“Location of health care facilities: An analytical approach”Socio-Economic Planning Sciences7407–422
7.
CartwrightA, 1967Patients and Their Doctors (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon)
8.
CartwrightAO'BrienM, 1976“Social class variations in health care and in the nature of general practitioner consultations” in Sociological Review Monograph 22. The Sociology of the NHS Ed. StaceyA
9.
CoatesB EJohnstonR JKnoxP. L., 1977Geography and Inequality (Oxford University Press, London)
10.
CoatesB ERawstronE M, 1971Regional Variations in Britain (Batsford, London)
11.
CochraneA L, 1972Effectiveness and Efficiency. Random Reflections on Health Services (Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust, London)
12.
CooperM HCulyerA J, 1967“An economic assessment of some aspects of the operation of the National Health Service”Health Services Financing, Appendix A (British Medical Association, London)
13.
DearM, 1974“A paradigm for public facility location theory”Antipode646–50
14.
DisekerR AChappellJ A, 1976“Relative importance of variables in determination of practice location: A pilot study”Social Science and Medicine10559–564
15.
EaricksonR, 1970“The spatial behavior of hospital patients” RP-124, Department of Geography, University of Chicago, Chicago, Ill.
16.
EleshDSchollaertP T, 1971“Race and urban medicine: Factors affecting the distribution of physicians in Chicago” DP, Institute for Research on Poverty, University of Wisconsin, Madison
17.
Foreman-PeckJ SGripaiosP A, 1977“Inner city problems and inner city policies”Regional Studies11(6) 401–412
18.
GirtJ L, 1972“Distance and patterns of revealed ill-health in a spatially dispersed population: The problem of ascertaining optimal locations for general medical facilities” paper presented to IGU Commission on Medical Geography, Guelph, Ontario
19.
HartJ T, 1971“The inverse care law”Lancet1405–412
20.
HarveyD, 1971“Social processes, spatial form and the redistribution of real income in an urban system” in Regional Forecasting Eds ChisholmMFreyA EHaggettP, (Butterworth, London)
21.
HarveyD, 1973Social Justice and the City (Edward Arnold, London)
22.
HillmanM, 1973Personal Mobility (Political and Economic Planning, London)
23.
HodgeD CGatrellA, 1976“Spatial constraint and the location of urban public facilities”Environment and Planning A8215–230
24.
Hopkins E J and others, 1968“The relation of patients' age, sex and distance from surgery to the demand on the family doctor”Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners16368–378
25.
HoweG M, 1970National Atlas of Disease Mortality in the United Kingdom (Nelson, London)
26.
HoweG M, 1976“Aspects of medical geography” in Man in Urban Environments Eds HarrisonG AGibsonJ B, (Oxford University Press, London)
27.
JamesE F, 1961“The general practitioner and the hospital”Lanceti1361–1363
28.
LankfordP, 1971“The changing location of physicians”Antipode368–72
29.
LiebersonS, 1958“Ethnic groups and the practice of medicine”American Sociological Review23542–549
30.
MassamB, 1975Location and Space in Social Administration (Edward Arnold, London)
31.
MechanicD, 1968Medical Sociology: A Selective View (Free Press, New York)
32.
MechanicDVolkartE H, 1962“Illness behaviour and medical diagnosis”Journal of Health and Human Behavior186–92
33.
MonroeC BMcGrewJ C, 1975“Efficiency, equity and multiple facility location”Proceedings of the Association of American Geographers7142–146
34.
MorrillR, 1967“The movement of persons and the transportation problem” in Studies in Geography 13. Quantitative Geography. Part 1: Economic and Cultural Topics Eds GarrisonW LMarbleD F, (Department of Geography, Northwestern University, Evanston, Ill.)
35.
MorrillR, 1974“Efficiency and equity of optimum location models”Antipode641–46
36.
MorrillREaricksonR JReesP, 1970“Factors influencing distances travelled to hospitals”Economic Geography46161–171
37.
NormanJ C, 1970Medicine in the Ghetto (Appleton, New York)
38.
NoyceJSnaithA HTrickeyA J, 1974“Regional variations in the allocation of financial resources to the community health services”Lanceti1186–1194
39.
PahlR E, 1967“Sociological models in geography” in Models in Geography Eds ChorleyR JHaggettP, (Methuen, London)
40.
PahlR E, 1970Whose City? (Longman, London)
41.
PahlR E, 1971“Poverty and the urban system” in Spatial Policy Problems of the British Economy Eds ChisholmMMannersG, (Cambridge University Press, London)
42.
PEP, 1944Planning Broadsheet 222, 30 June (Political and Economic Planning, London)
43.
PredA, 1977City-Systems in Advanced Economics (Hutchinson, London)
44.
Purola R and others, 1968The Utilization of the Medical Services and Its Relationship to Morbidity, Health Resources and Social Factors (Research Institute for Social Security, Helsinki)
45.
PyleG, 1968“The geography of disease in large cities III. Geosocial pathology in Chicago” WP-4 (Chicago Regional Hospital Study, Chicago, Ill.)
46.
ReesP, 1967“Movement and distribution of physicians in metropolitan Chicago” WP-12, Chicago Regional Hospital Study, Chicago, Ill.
47.
ReinM, 1969“Social class and the utilization of medical care services”Journal of the American Hospital Association4343–59
48.
RexJMooreR, 1967Race, Community and Conflict (Oxford University Press, London)
49.
RichardsonI MDingwall-FordyceI, 1968“Patient geography in general practice”Lanceti1290–1293
50.
RobsonB T, 1975Urban Social Areas (Oxford University Press, London)
51.
Royal College of General Practitioners, 1977Trends in General Practice (British Medical Association, London)
52.
RyanM, 1968“Health centre policy in England and Wales”British Journal of Sociology1934–46
53.
SalkeverD S, 1976“Accessibility and the demand for preventive care”Social Science and Medicine10469–475
54.
ScottA J, 1970“Location–allocation systems: A review”Geographical Analysis230–42
55.
Scottish Development Department, 1976Four Cities Change Study (mimeographed reports, unpublished)
56.
Scottish Home and Health Department, 1975Scottish Health Statistics 1973 (HMSO, Edinburgh)
57.
Seebohm Report, 1968Report of the Committee on Local Authority and Allied Personal Social Services Cmnd 3703 (HMSO, London)
58.
ShannonG WDeverG E, 1974Health Care Delivery: Spatial Perspectives (McGraw-Hill, New York)
59.
SmithD M, 1977Human Geography: A Welfare Approach (Edward Arnold, London)
60.
Social Trends, 1973“Health and personal social services”Social Trends4123–141
61.
SumnerG, 1971“Trends in the location of primary medical care in Britain”Antipode346–53
62.
SymonsJ G, 1971“Some comments on equity and efficiency in public facility location models”Antipode354–67
63.
TitmussR M, 1950Problems of Social Policy (Longman, London)
64.
TitmussR M, 1968Commitment to Welfare (George Allen and Unwin, London)
65.
TornqvistGNordbeckSRystedtBGouldP, 1971Lund Studies in Geography C 12. Multiple Location Analysis (Department of Geography, Lund University, Sweden)
66.
TownsendE, 1969“Problems in designated areas”Medical World914–27
67.
TownsendP, 1974“Inequality and the Health Service”Lanceti1179–1190
68.
VaughanD H, 1967“Dispersion of patients in urban general practice”The Medical Officer 23 June 337–340
69.
de ViseP, 1973“Misused and misplaced hospitals and doctors: A location analysis of the urban health care crisis” Resource Paper 22, Commission on College Geography, Washington, DC
70.
WachsMKumagaiT G, 1973“Physical accessibility as a social indicator”Socio-Economic Planning Sciences7437–456
71.
Willinck Report, 1957Report of the Committee to Consider the Future Numbers of Medical Practitioners and the Appropriate Intake of Medical Students (HMSO, London)
