Using Decision Trees to Identify Tourism Stakeholders: The Case of Two Eastern North Carolina Counties

Abstract

This paper explores stakeholder involvement in tourism planning, development, and management. For tourism planners to include stakeholders in the tourism planning process those stakeholders and their interests need to be identified. The research reported in this paper describes and applies an analytical technique that is not traditionally used to identify stakeholders. A questionnaire was developed and mailed to stakeholders in two rural communities in North Carolina. The data were analysed with an Exhaustive Chi-square Automatic Interaction Detection decision tree. From the results of the decision tree, stakeholder groups were identified in relation to their support for sustainable tourism development in their community.

Keywords

decision tree analysis stakeholder inclusion sustainable tourism tourism planning

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

Hafer

Long

Perdue

(1993) ‘Rural Residents, Attitudes Toward Recreation and Tourism Development’, Journal of Travel Research, 31, 4, 27–33.

Andereck

K. L.

Vogt

C. A.

(2000) ‘The Relationship Between Residents, Attitudes Toward Tourism and Tourism Development Options’, Journal of Travel Research, 39, 27–36.

Ansari

W. E.

Phillips

C. J.

(2001) ‘Interprofessional Collaboration: A stakeholder approach to evaluation of voluntary participation in community partnerships’, Journal of Interprofessional Care, 15, 4, 351–368.

Arimond

Elfessi

(2001) ‘A Clustering Method for Categorical Data in Tourism Market Segmentation Research’, Journal of Travel Research, 39, 391–397.

Arnstein

S. R.

(1969) ‘A Ladder of Citizen Participation’, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35, 4, 216–224.

Babbie

(1995) ‘The Practice of Social Research’, 7th edn, Wadsworth Publishing Company, Belmont.

Beierle

T. C.

(1998) ‘Public Participation in Environmental Decisions: An evaluation framework using social goals’, Resources for the Future, Washington, DC.

Bramwell

Sharman

(1999) ‘Collaboration in Local Tourism Policymaking’, Annals of Tourism Research, 26, 2, 392–415.

Briassoulis

(2002) ‘Sustainable Tourism and the Question of the Commons’, Annals of Tourism Research, 29, 4, 1065–1085.

10.

Brunt

Courtney

(1999) ‘Host Perceptions of Sociocultural Impacts’, Annals of Tourism Research, 26, 3, 493–515.

11.

Byrd

E. T.

(1997) ‘Barriers to Rural Tourism: A comparison of the perceptions of the host community, local business owners, and tourists’, Unpublished master's thesis, North Carolina State University, United States.

12.

Carmin

Darnall

Mil-Homens

(2003) ‘Stakeholder Involvement in the Design of U.S. Voluntary Environmental Programs: Does sponsorship matter?, Policy Studies Journal, 31, 4, 527–543.

13.

Carter

Darlow

(1997) ‘Local Agenda 21 and Developers: Are we better equipped to build a consensus in the 1990s?’ Planning Practice and Research, 12, 1, 45–57.

14.

Clarkson

M. B. E.

(1995) ‘A Stakeholder Framework for Analyzing and Evaluation Corporate Social Performance’, The Academy of Management Review, 20, 1, 92–117.

15.

Cottrell

S. P.

(2001) ‘A Dutch International Development Approach: Sustainable tourism development’, Parks and Recreation, 36, 9, 86–93.

16.

Crosby

Kelly

Schaefer

(1986) ‘Citizens Panels: A new approach to citizen participation’, Public Management Forum, 46, 170–178.

17.

Curry

(2001) ‘Community Participation and Rural Policy: Representativeness in the development of Millennium Greens’, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 44, 4, 561–576.

18.

Davis

J. S.

Morais

D. B.

(2004) ‘Factions and Enclaves: Small towns and socially unsustainable tourism development’, Journal of Travel Research, 43, 3–10.

19.

De Lopez

T. T.

(2001) ‘Stakeholder Management for Conservation Projects: A case study of Ream National Park, Cambodia’, Environmental Management, 28, 1, 47–60.

20.

De Oliveira

J. A. P.

(2003) ‘Governmental Responses to Tourism Development: Three Brazilian case studies’, Tourism Management, 24, 97–110.

21.

Dillman

(2000) ‘Mail and Internet Surveys: The tailored design method’, 2nd edn, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York.

22.

Donaldson

Preston

L. E.

(1995) ‘The Stakeholder Theory of the Corporation: Concepts, evidence, and implications’, The Academy of Management Review, 20, 1, 65–91.

23.

Eherler

Lehmann

(n.d.) ‘Responder Profiling with CHIAD and Dependency Analysis’, Institute of Applied Economic Research, Limburgs Universitair Centrum, http://www.luc.ac.be/iteo/articles/lehmann.pdf (accessed 30th May, 2003).

24.

Fiorino

D. J.

(1990) ‘Citizen Participation and Environmental Risk: A survey of institutional mechanisms’, Science, Technology, and Human Values, 15, 2, 226–243.

25.

Freeman

R. E.

(1984) ‘Strategic Management: A stakeholder approach’, Pitman, Boston.

26.

Goeldner

C. R.

Ritchie

J. R. B.

(2002) ‘Tourism: Principles, practices, philosophies’, 9th edn, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New Jersey.

27.

Gunn

C. A.

(1994) ‘Tourism Planning: Basic concepts cases’, 3rd edn, Taylor & Francis: Washington, DC.

28.

Hardy

A. L.

Beeton

R. J. S.

(2001) ‘Sustainable Tourism or Maintainable Tourism: Managing resources for more than average outcomes’. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 9, 3, 168–192.

29.

Hassan

S. S.

(2000) ‘Determinants of Market Competitiveness in an Environmentally Sustainable Tourism Industry’, Journal of Travel Research, 38, 3, 239–245.

30.

Huba

G. J.

(2003) ‘CHAID. The Measurement Group’, http://www.themeasurementgroup.com/Definitions/CHAID.htm (accessed 30th May, 2003).

31.

Hunt

Haider

(2001) ‘Fair and Effective Decision Making in Forest Management Planning’. Society of Natural Resources. 14, 873–887.

32.

Inskeep

(1991) ‘Tourism Planning: An integrated and sustainable development approach’. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.

33.

Ioannides

(1995) ‘A Flawed Implementation of Sustainable Tourism: The experience of Akamas, Cyprus’. Tourism Management, 16, 8, 583–592.

34.

Jamal

T. B.

Getz

(1995) ‘Collaboration Theory and Community Tourism Planning’, Annals of Tourism Research, 22, 1, 186–204.

35.

Johnson

Scholes

(1999) ‘Exploring Corporate Strategy’, 5th edn, Prentice-Hall, Europe, London.

36.

Jones

T. M.

(1995) ‘Instrumental Stakeholder Theory: A synthesis of ethics and economics’, The Academy of Management Review, 20, 2, 404–437.

37.

Kass

G. V.

(1980) ‘An Exploratory Technique for Investigating Large Quantities of Categorical Data’, Applied Statistics, 29, 2, 119–127.

38.

Kavallinis

Pizam

(1994) ‘The Environmental Impact of Tourism: Whose responsibility is it anyway? The Case Study of Mykonos’, Journal of Travel Research, 33, 2, 26–32.

39.

Koskela

(1999) ‘Decision Trees’. http://www.hut.fi/u/timoko/treeprogs.html (accessed 30th May, 2003).

40.

Kotler

Bowen

Makens

(2003) ‘Marketing for Hospitality and Tourism’, 3rd edn, Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ.

41.

Lankford

S. V.

(1994). ‘Attitudes and Perceptions Toward Tourism and Rural Regional Development’, Journal of Travel Research, 32, 3, 35–43.

42.

Lankford

S. V.

Howard

D. R.

(1994) ‘Developing a Tourism Impact Attitude Scale’, Annals of Tourism Research, 21, 1, 121–139.

43.

Long

Perdue

Allen

(1990) ‘Rural Residents Perceptions and Attitudes by Community Level of Tourism’. Journal of Travel Research, 28, 3, 3–9.

44.

MacKay

K. J.

Andereck

K. L.

Vogt

C. A.

(2002) ‘Understanding Vacationing Motorist Niche Markets’, Journal of Travel Research, 40, 356–363.

45.

Maddox

R. N.

(1985) ‘Measuring Satisfaction with Tourism’, Journal of Travel Research, 23, 3, 2–5.

46.

Markwick

M. C.

(2000) ‘Golf Tourism Development, Stakeholders, Differing Discourses, and Alternative Agendas: The case of Malta’, Tourism Management, 21, 515–524.

47.

Martin

S. R.

(1995) ‘Montanans' Attitudes and Behavioral Intentions Toward Tourism: Implications for sustainability’, in McCool

S.F.

Watson

A.E.

(eds), ‘Linking Tourism, The Environment, and Sustainability — Topical volume of compiled papers from a special session of the annual meeting of the National Recreation and Park Association’, Intermountain Research Station, Ogden, UT, pp. 69–76.

48.

Mason

Cheyne

(2000) ‘Resident's Attitudes to Proposed Tourism Development’, Annals of Tourism Research, 27, 2, 391–411.

49.

Mathieson

Wall

(1982) ‘Tourism: Economic, physical, and social impacts’, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York.

50.

McFarlane

B. L.

Boxall

P. C.

(2000) ‘Factors Influencing Forest Values and Attitudes of Two Stakeholder Groups: The case of the Foothills Model Forest, Alberta, Canada’, Society and Natural Resources, 13, 649–661.

51.

The Measurement Group. (2003) ‘Data Mining and Statistical Modeling’, http://www.themeasurementgroup.com/datamining.htm (accessed 15th June, 2003).

52.

Murphy

P. E.

(1983) ‘Perceptions and Attitudes of Decision Making Groups in Tourism Centers’, Journal of Travel Research, 21, 3, 8–12.

53.

Murphy

P. E.

(1985) ‘Tourism: A Community Approach’, Methuen, London.

54.

Owen

J. T.

(1998) ‘Market Segmentation in Hospitality Research: No longer a sequential process’, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 10, 7, 289–296.

55.

Perdue

Long

Allen

(1990) ‘Resident Support for Sustainable Tourism development’, Annals of Tourism Research, 17, 586–599.

56.

Pizam

(1978) ‘Tourism's Impacts: The social costs to the destination community as perceived by its residents’, Journal of Travel Research, 16, 4, 8–12.

57.

Pizam

Uriely

Reichel

(2000) ‘The Intensity of Tourist-Host Social Relationship and its Effects on Satisfaction and Change of Attitudes: The case of working tourist in Israel’, Tourism Management, 21, 395–406.

58.

Reed

M. G.

(1997) ‘Power Relations and Community Based Planning’, Annals of Tourism Research, 24, 3, 566–591.

59.

Robson

(1996) ‘From Shareholders to Stakeholder: Critical issues for tourism marketers’, Tourism Management, 17, 7, 533–540.

60.

Ryan

(2002) ‘Equity, Management, Power Sharing and Sustainability — Issues of the ‘New Tourism’’, Tourism Management, 23, 17–26.

61.

Sautter

E. T.

Leisen

(1999) ‘Managing Stakeholders: A tourism planning model’, Annuals of Tourism Research, 26, 2, 312–328.

62.

King

Simrell C.

Feltey

K. M.

(1998) ‘The Question of Participation: Toward authentic public participation in public administration’, Public Administration Review, 58, 4, 317–326.

63.

Southgate

Sharpley

(2002) ‘Tourism, Development and the Environment’, in Sharpley

Telfer

D. J.

(eds), ‘Tourism and Development: Concepts and issues’, Channel View Publications, Cleveland, pp. 231–262.

64.

SPSS. (2002) ‘Introduction to Answer Tree’, SPSS, Chicago, IL.

65.

SPSS. (2003) ‘How Decision Tree Results are Different in Answer Tree 3.1/3.0’, http://www.spss.com/spssbi/answertree/decisiontrees.htm (accessed 30th May, 2003).

66.

Steelman

T. A.

(2001) ‘Elite and Participatory Policymaking: Finding balance in a case of national forest planning’, Policy Studies Journal, 29, 1, 71–89.

67.

Stein

T. V.

Anderson

D. H.

Kelly

(1999) ‘Using Stakeholders' Values to Apply Ecosystem Management in an Upper Midwest Landscape’, Environmental Management, 24, 3, 399–413.

68.

Stoney

Winstanley

(2001) ‘Stakeholding: Confusion or Utopia? Mapping the Conceptual Terrain’, Journal of Management Studies, 38, 5, 603–626.

69.

Vincent

V. C.

Thompson

W. T.

(2002) ‘Assessing Community Support and Sustainability for Ecotourism Development’, Journal of Travel Research, 41, 153–160.

70.

Williams

Lawson

(2001) ‘Community Issues and Resident Opinions of Tourism’, Annals of Tourism Research, 28, 2, 269–290.

71.

Yuksel

Bramwell

Yuksel

(1999) ‘Stakeholder Interviews and Tourism Planning at Pamukkale, Turkey’, Tourism Management, 20, 351–360.