Efficacy of prophylactic antibiotics in craniofacial fracture management is controversial. The purpose of this study was to compare evidence-based literature recommendations regarding antibiotic prophylaxis in facial fracture management with expert-based practice. A systematic review of the literature was performed to identify published studies evaluating pre-, peri-, and postoperative efficacy of antibiotics in facial fracture management by facial third. Study level of evidence was assessed according to the American Society of Plastic Surgery criteria, and graded practice recommendations were made based on these assessments. Expert opinions were garnered during the Advanced Orbital Surgery Symposium in the form of surveys evaluating senior surgeon clinical antibiotic prescribing practices by time point and facial third. A total of 44 studies addressing antibiotic prophylaxis and facial fracture management were identified. Overall, studies were of poor quality, precluding formal quantitative analysis. Studies supported the use of perioperative antibiotics in all facial thirds, and preoperative antibiotics in comminuted mandible fractures. Postoperative antibiotics were not supported in any facial third. Survey respondents (n = 17) cumulatively reported their antibiotic prescribing practices over 286 practice years and 24,012 facial fracture cases. Percentages of prescribers administering pre-, intra-, and postoperative antibiotics, respectively, by facial third were as follows: upper face 47.1, 94.1, 70.6; midface 47.1, 100, 70.6%; and mandible 68.8, 94.1, 64.7%. Preoperative but not postoperative antibiotic use is recommended for comminuted mandible fractures. Frequent use of pre- and postoperative antibiotics in upper and midface fractures is not supported by literature recommendations, but with low-level evidence. Higher level studies may better guide clinical antibiotic prescribing practices.
LauderAJalisiSSpiegelJStramJDevaiahAAntibiotic prophylaxis in the management of complex midface and frontal sinus traumaLaryngoscope2010120101940–1945
2.
BagheriSCDimassiMShahriariAKhanHAJoCSteedMBFacial trauma coverage among level-1 trauma centers of the United StatesJ Oral Maxillofac Surg2008665963–967
3.
AllareddyVAllareddyVNalliahRPEpidemiology of facial fracture injuriesJ Oral Maxillofac Surg201169102613–2618
4.
ImaharaSDHopperRAWangJRivaraFPKleinMBPatterns and outcomes of pediatric facial fractures in the United States: a survey of the National Trauma Data BankJ Am Coll Surg20082075710–716
5.
DillonJKChristensenBMcDonaldTHuangSGaugerPGomezPThe financial burden of mandibular traumaJ Oral Maxillofac Surg20127092124–2134
6.
SingerAJHollanderJEQuinnJVEvaluation and management of traumatic lacerationsN Engl J Med1997337161142–1148
7.
BratzlerDWHuntDRThe surgical infection prevention and surgical care improvement projects: national initiatives to improve outcomes for patients having surgeryClin Infect Dis2006433322–330
8.
ClassenDCEvansRSPestotnikSLHornSDMenloveRLBurkeJPThe timing of prophylactic administration of antibiotics and the risk of surgical-wound infectionN Engl J Med19923265281–286
9.
NamiasNMeizosoJPLivingstonDH; SOSICK Investigators Group. Survey of surgical infections currently known (SOSICK): a multicenter examination of antimicrobial use from the surgical infection society scientific studies committeeSurg Infect (Larchmt)200895509–514
10.
DebbiaEASchitoGCGualcoLTonoliEDolcinoMMarcheseAMicrobial epidemiology patterns of surgical infection pathogensJ Chemother200113Spec No 184–88
11.
StulbergJJDelaneyCPNeuhauserDVAronDCFuPKoroukianSMAdherence to surgical care improvement project measures and the association with postoperative infectionsJAMA2010303242479–2485
12.
HawnMTRichmanJSVickCC, et al. Timing of surgical antibiotic prophylaxis and the risk of surgical site infectionJAMA Surg20131487649–657
13.
Antimicrobial prophylaxis for surgeryTreat Guidel Med Lett20121012273–78, quiz 79–80
ShuttleworthGNDavidDBPottsMJBellCNGuestPGLesson of the week: orbital trauma. Do not blow your noseBMJ199931871901054–1055
18.
CourtneyDJThomasSWhitfieldPHIsolated orbital blowout fractures: survey and reviewBr J Oral Maxillofac Surg2000385496–504
19.
BuiPDemianNBeetarPInfection rate in mandibular angle fractures treated with a 2.0-mm 8-hole curved strut plateJ Oral Maxillofac Surg2009674804–808
20.
ZixJSchallerBIizukaTLiegerOThe role of postoperative prophylactic antibiotics in the treatment of facial fractures: a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot clinical study. Part 1: orbital fractures in 62 patientsBr J Oral Maxillofac Surg2013514332–336
21.
KyzasPAUse of antibiotics in the treatment of mandible fractures: a systematic reviewJ Oral Maxillofac Surg20116941129–1145
22.
AndreasenJOJensenSSSchwartzOHillerupYA systematic review of prophylactic antibiotics in the surgical treatment of maxillofacial fracturesJ Oral Maxillofac Surg200664111664–1668
23.
MilesBAPotterJKEllisEIIIThe efficacy of postoperative antibiotic regimens in the open treatment of mandibular fractures: a prospective randomized trialJ Oral Maxillofac Surg2006644576–582
24.
AbubakerAORollertMKPostoperative antibiotic prophylaxis in mandibular fractures: A preliminary randomized, double-blind, and placebo-controlled clinical studyJ Oral Maxillofac Surg200159121415–1419
25.
HeitJMStevensMRJeffordsKComparison of ceftriaxone with penicillin for antibiotic prophylaxis for compound mandible fracturesOral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod1997834423–426
26.
GerlachKPapeHPerioperative antibiotic prophylaxis in mandibular fracture treatmentChemioterapia19876(2, Suppl): 568
27.
BellamyJLMolendijkJReddySK, et al. Severe infectious complications following frontal sinus fracture: the impact of operative delay and perioperative antibiotic usePlast Reconstr Surg20131321154–162
28.
KnepilGJLoukotaRAOutcomes of prophylactic antibiotics following surgery for zygomatic bone fracturesJ Craniomaxillofac Surg2010382131–133
29.
GhazalGJaquiéryCHammerBNon-surgical treatment of mandibular fractures—survey of 28 patientsInt J Oral Maxillofac Surg2004332141–145
30.
EllisEIIIWalkerLRTreatment of mandibular angle fractures using one noncompression miniplateJ Oral Maxillofac Surg1996547864–871, discussion 871–872
31.
CholeRAYeeJAntibiotic prophylaxis for facial fractures. A prospective, randomized clinical trialArch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1987113101055–1057
32.
ZallenRDCurryJTA study of antibiotic usage in compound mandibular fracturesJ Oral Surg1975336431–434
33.
AdalarasanSMohanAPasupathySProphylactic antibiotics in maxillofacial fractures: a requisite?J Craniofac Surg20102141009–1011
34.
LovatoCWagnerJDInfection rates following perioperative prophylactic antibiotics versus postoperative extended regimen prophylactic antibiotics in surgical management of mandibular fracturesJ Oral Maxillofac Surg2009674827–832
35.
MalanchukVOKopchakAVRisk factors for development of infection in patients with mandibular fractures located in the tooth-bearing areaJ Craniomaxillofac Surg200735157–62
36.
JamesRBFredricksonCKentJNProspective study of mandibular fracturesJ Oral Surg1981394275–281
37.
HindawiYHOakleyGMKinsellaCRJrCrayJJLindsayKScifresAMAntibiotic duration and postoperative infection rates in mandibular fracturesJ Craniofac Surg20112241375–1377
38.
SenelFCJessenGSMeloMDObeidGInfection following treatment of mandible fractures: the role of immunosuppression and polysubstance abuseOral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod2007103138–42
39.
FurrAMSchweinfurthJMMayWLFactors associated with long-term complications after repair of mandibular fracturesLaryngoscope20061163427–430
40.
Ben SimonGJBushSSelvaDMcNabAAOrbital cellulitis: a rare complication after orbital blowout fractureOphthalmology2005112112030–2034
41.
LeeTTRatzkerPAGalarzaMVillanuevaPAEarly combined management of frontal sinus and orbital and facial fracturesJ Trauma1998444665–669
42.
ChoiDSpannRTraumatic cerebrospinal fluid leakage: risk factors and the use of prophylactic antibioticsBr J Neurosurg1996106571–575
43.
SilverHSFucciMJFlanaganJCLowryLDSevere orbital infection as a complication of orbital fractureArch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg19921188845–848, discussion 882
44.
HallSCOfodileFAMandibular fractures in an American inner city: the Harlem Hospital Center experienceJ Natl Med Assoc1991835421–423
45.
GoldfarbMSHoffmanDSRosenbergSOrbital cellulitis and orbital fracturesAnn Ophthalmol198719397–99, 115
LarsenODNielsenAMandibular fractures. II. A follow-up study of 229 patientsScand J Plast Reconstr Surg1976103219–226
48.
KerrNWSome observations on infection in maxillo-facial fracturesBr J Oral Surg196642132–136
49.
AbubakerAOUse of prophylactic antibiotics in preventing infection of traumatic injuriesDent Clin North Am2009534707–715, vi vi
50.
EllisEIIIMilesBAFractures of the mandible: a technical perspectivePlast Reconstr Surg200712070276S–89S
51.
SrinivasanDWhearNShettySAntibiotics for patients with zygomatic fractures into the maxillary antrumBr J Oral Maxillofac Surg2006445424–425
52.
StaceyDHDoyleJFMountDLSnyderMCGutowskiKAManagement of mandible fracturesPlast Reconstr Surg2006117348e–60e
53.
MartinBGhoshAAntibiotics in orbital floor fracturesEmerg Med J200320166
54.
NewlandsCBaggsPRKendrickROrbital trauma. Antibiotic prophylaxis needs to be given only in certain circumstancesBMJ19993197208516–517
55.
McLoughlinPGilhoolyMWoodGThe management of zygomatic complex fractures—results of a surveyBr J Oral Maxillofac Surg1994325284–288
56.
PatersonAWBarnardNAIrvineGHNaso-orbital fracture leading to orbital cellulitis, and visual loss as a complication of chronic sinusitisBr J Oral Maxillofac Surg199432280–82
57.
WestfallCTShoreJWIsolated fractures of the orbital floor: risk of infection and the role of antibiotic prophylaxisOphthalmic Surg1991227409–411
GreenbergRNJamesRBMarierRLWoodWHSandersCVKentJNMicrobiologic and antibiotic aspects of infections in the oral and maxillofacial regionJ Oral Surg19793712873–884
60.
BratzlerDWHouckPM; Surgical Infection Prevention Guideline Writers Workgroup. Antimicrobial prophylaxis for surgery: an advisory statement from the National Surgical Infection Prevention ProjectAm J Surg20051894395–404
61.
MithaniSKKelamisJAMundingerGS, et al. The prevalence of cervical spine injury, head injury, or both with isolated and multiple craniomaxillofacial fracturesPlast Reconstr Surg20121291163e, author reply 163e–164e
62.
MulliganRPMahabirRCThe prevalence of cervical spine injury, head injury, or both with isolated and multiple craniomaxillofacial fracturesPlast Reconstr Surg201012651647–1651
63.
BellamyJLMundingerGSReddySKFloresJMRodriguezEDDorafsharAHLe Fort II fractures are associated with death: a comparison of simple and complex midface fracturesJ Oral Maxillofac Surg20137191556–1562
64.
VacaEEMundingerGSKelamisJA, et al. Facial fractures with concomitant open globe injury: mechanisms and fracture patterns associated with blindnessPlast Reconstr Surg201313161317–1328
