Subject matter knowledge influences instructional decision-making, particularly for novice teachers. Moreover, teacher candidates’ abilities to create critical pedagogy is influenced by their subject matter knowledge and their opportunity to interact with critical curriculum. Using a researcher-designed task intended to develop teacher candidates’ subject matter knowledge, this qualitative action research study investigated the degree to which the task supported candidates’ critical consciousness and their selection and framing of content for an instructional unit. The findings illustrate inconsistencies in candidates’ abilities to use new subject matter knowledge in ways that conceptualize social studies curriculum in critical ways. These inconsistencies suggest that teacher educators should consider using a critical rationale-based pedagogy as a means to assist teacher candidates to move towards critical pedagogy in ways that subject matter knowledge alone cannot.
AuW.BrownA.L.CalderónD.Reclaiming the multicultural roots of U.S. curriculum: Communities of color and official knowledge in education2016Teachers College PressNew York, NY
2.
BainR.MirelJ.Setting up camp at the great instructional divide: Educating beginning history teachersJournal of Teacher Education57200621210.1177/0022487105285892
3.
BallD.L.ThamesM.H.PhelpsG.Content knowledge for teaching: What makes it so special?Journal of Teacher Education592008389–40710.1177/0022487108324554
4.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good2009RoutledgeNew York, NY(Original work published 2004)
5.
BerchiniC.N.Learning to teach and critical pedagogy: Struggling with a “do as I say, not as I do” pedagogyEnglish Education462014247–267
6.
ChandlerP.T.Critical race theory and social studies: Centering the Native American experienceJournal of Social Studies Research34201029–58
7.
ChandlerP.T.What does it mean to “do race” in social studies? Racial pedagogical content knowledgeChandlerP.T.Doing race in social studies: Critical perspectives2015Information AgeCharlotte, NC1–10
8.
CheckJ.SchuttR.K.Research methods in education2012SAGEThousand Oaks, CA
9.
Cochran-SmithM.LytleS.L.Inside/outside: Teacher research and knowledge1993Teachers College PressNew York, NY
10.
CunninghamD.L.Understanding pedagogical reasoning in history teaching through the case of cultivating historical empathyTheory & Research in Social Education352007592–63010.1080/00933104.2007.10473352
11.
DarderA.BaltodanoM.TorresR.D.The critical pedagogy reader2nd ed.2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
12.
EpsteinT.Interpreting national history: Race, identity, and pedagogy in classrooms and communities2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
13.
FreireP.Education for critical consciousness1974ContinuumLondon, UK
14.
FreireP.TransRamosM.B.Pedagogy of the oppressed, 30th Anniversary edition2008ContinuumNew York, NY(Original work published 1970)
15.
GirouxH.Theories of reproduction and resistance in the new sociology of education: A critical analysisHarvard Educational Review531983257–29310.17763/haer.53.3.a67x4u33g7682734
16.
GirouxH.A.Teacher education and democratic schoolingDarderA.BaltodanoM.TorresR.D.The critical pedagogy reader2009RoutledgeNew York, NY438–459
17.
GirouxH.A.On critical pedagogy2011Bloomsbury PublishingLondon, UK
18.
GlesneC.Becoming qualitative researchers: An introduction4th ed.2011PearsonBoston, MA
19.
GorskiP.C.Reaching and teaching students in poverty: Strategies for erasing the opportunity gap2013Teachers CollegeNew York, NY
20.
GrantS.G.From inquiry arc to instructional practice: The potential of the C3 FrameworkSocial Education7762013322–326
21.
GrantS.G.Teaching practices in history educationMetzgerS.A.HarrisL.M.The Wiley international handbook of history teaching and learning2018John Wiley & SonsHoboken, NJ419–448
22.
GrantS.G.GradwellJ.M.Teaching history with big ideas: Cases of ambitious teachers2010Rowman & Littlefield EducationLanham, MD
23.
GrantS.G.LeeJ.SwanK.Teaching social studies: A methods book for methods teachers2017Information AgeCharlotte, NC
24.
HarrisL.M.GirardB.Instructional significance for teaching history: A preliminary frameworkJournal of Social Studies Research3842014215–22510.1016/j.jssr.2014.02.003
25.
HawleyT.S.Purpose into practice: The problems and possibilities of rationale-based practice in social studiesTheory & Research in Social Education382010131–16210.1080/00933104.2010.10473419
26.
HelmerK.Disruptive practices: Enacting critical pedagogy through meditation, community building, and explorative spaces in a graduate course for pre-service teachersJournal of Classroom Interaction492201433–40
JournellW.What preservice social studies teachers (don't) know about politics and current events - and why it mattersTheory & Research in Social Education412013316–35110.1090/00933104.2013.812050
29.
JournellW.Teaching politics in the U.S. history classroomThe History Teacher48201455–69
30.
JournellW.Fake news, alternative facts, and Trump: Teaching social studies in a post truth eraSocial Studies Journal3720178–21
31.
KahanJ.A.CooperD.A.BetheaK.A.The role of mathematics teachers’ content knowledge in their teaching: A framework for research applied to the study of student teachersJournal of Mathematics Teacher Education62003223–25210.1023/A:1025175812582
32.
KincheloeJ.L.Critical pedagogy primer2008Peter LangNew York, NY
33.
KingL.ForwardChandlerP.T.Doing race in social studies: Critical perspectives2015Information AgeCharlotte, NCix–xii
Ladson-BillingsG.Critical race theory perspectives on the social studies: The profession, policies, and curriculum2003Information AgeCharlotte, NC
36.
LevinsonM.No citizen left behind2012Harvard PressCambridge, MA
37.
LevstikL.S.Articulating the silences: Teachers’ and adolescents’ conceptions of historical significanceStearnsP.N.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York, NY284–305
38.
LoewenJ.W.Teaching what really happened: How to avoid the tyranny of textbooks and get students excited about doing history2010Teachers College PressNew York, NY
39.
LortieD.Schoolteacher: A sociological study1975University of Chicago PressLondon
40.
LoveB.DuncanE.K.Put some respect on our name: Why every black & brown girl needs to learn about radical feminist leadershipOccasional Papers Series3820171–6
41.
MartellC.M.Learning to teach history as interpretation: A longitudinal study of beginning teachersJournal of Social Studies Research37201317–3110.1016/J.Jssr.2012.12.001
42.
McClarenP.Critical pedagogy: A look at the major conceptsDarderA.BaltodanoM.TorresR.D.The critical pedagogy reader2009RoutledgeNew York, NY61–83
43.
McCrumE.History teachers’ thinking about the nature of their subjectsTeaching and Teacher Education35201373–8010.1016/j.tate.2013.05.004
44.
McDiarmidG.W.Vinten-JohansenP.A catwalk across the great divide: Redesigning the history teaching methods courseStearnsP.N.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York, NY156–177
45.
MillsG.E.Action research: A guide for the teacher researcher2nd ed.2003Pearson EducationUpper Saddle River, NJ
46.
Monte-SanoC.Learning to open up history for students: Preservice teachers’ emerging pedagogical content knowledgeJournal of Teacher Education622011260–27210.1177/0022487110397842
47.
Monte-SanoC.BudanoC.Developing and enacting pedagogical content knowledge for teaching history: An exploration of two novice teachers’ growth over three yearsThe Journal of the Learning Sciences2222012171–21110.1080/10508406.2012.742016
48.
MuellerR.G.ColleyL.M.ThackerE.S.What should I teach? Conceptualizing subject matterGrantS.SwanK.LeeJ.Teaching social studies: A methods book for methods teachers2017Grant, Swan and Lee163–169
49.
MuellerR.G.ColleyL.M.ThackerE.S.What should I teach? An examination of supporting social studies teacher candidates’ subject matter choicesSocial Studies Journal391201946–61
50.
National Council for the Social StudiesCollege, career, and civic life (C3) framework for social studies state standards: Guidance for enhancing the rigor of k-12 civics, economics, geography, and history2013Silver SpringMDNCSS
51.
ParisD.AlimH.S.Culturally sustaining pedagogies: Teaching and learning for justice in a changing world2017Teachers CollegeNew York, NY
52.
ParkhouseH.Pedagogies of naming, questioning, and demystification: A study of two critical U.S. History classroomsTheory & Research in Social Education462018277–31710.1080/00933104.2017.1389327
53.
RossE.W.Broadening the circle of critical pedagogyMcCraryN.E.RossE.W.Working for social justice inside and outside the classroom: A community of students, teachers, researchers, and activists2016Peter LangNew York, NY209–218
54.
SabzalianL.The tensions between Indigenous sovereignty and multicultural citizenship education: Toward an anticolonial approach to civic educationTheory & Research in Social Education4732019311–34610.1080/00933104.2019.1639572
55.
SalinasC.BlevinsB.Examining the intellectual biography of pre-service teachers: Elements of “critical” teacher knowledgeTeacher Education Quarterly4020137–24
56.
SalinasC.BlevinsB.Critical historical inquiry: How might pre-service teachers confront master historical narratives?Social Studies Research and Practice93201435–50
57.
SalinasC.CastroA.J.Disrupting the official curriculum: Cultural biography and the curriculum decision making of Latino preservice teachersTheory & Research in Social Education382010428–46310.1080/00933104.2010.10473433
58.
SardabiN.BiriaR.GolestanA.A.Reshaping teacher professional identity through critical pedagogy-informed teacher educationInternational Journal of Instruction112018617–63410.12973/iji.2018.11342a
59.
ShearS.B.KnowlesR.SodenG.CastroA.Manifesting destiny: Re/presentations of indigenous people in K-12 U.S. History curriculumTheory & Research in Social Education431201568–10110.1080/00933104.2014.999849
60.
ShortK.G.Teacher research for teacher educatorsPattersonL.Minnick SantaC.ShortK.G.SmithK.Teachers are researchers: Reflection and action1993Newark, DE: International Reading Association155–159
61.
SungP.YangM.Exploring disciplinary background effect on social studies teachers’ knowledge and pedagogyThe Journal of Educational Research106201377–8810.1080/00220671.2012.658453
62.
SwalwellK.PellegrinoA.M.ViewJ.L.Teachers’ curricular choices when teaching histories of oppressed people: Capturing the U.S. Civil Rights MovementJournal of Social Studies Research39201579–9410.1016/j.jssr.2014.11.003
63.
VickeryA.E.After the March, What?: Black women and the feminist movementSocial Studies Research and Practice1332018402–41110.1108/SSRP-05-2018-0020
64.
WansinkB.G.AkkermanS.WubbelsT.The certainty paradox of student history teachers: Balancing between historical facts and interpretationTeaching and Teacher Education56201694–10510.1016/j.tate.2016.02.005
65.
WestheimerJ.KahneJ.What kind of citizen? The politics of educating for democracyAmerican Educational Research Journal412004237–269
66.
WineburgS.S.WilsonS.M.Subject-matter knowledge in the teaching of historyBrophyJ.Advances in research on teaching1991JAI PressGreenwich, CT305–347
67.
WoodsonA.N.We're just ordinary people: Messianic master narra- tives and Black youths’ civic agencyTheory & Research in Social Education442016184–21110.1080/00933104.2016.1170645
68.
YinR.K.Qualitative research from start to finish2011The Guilford PressNew York, NY
