This study examined the historical perspectives of eleven emergent bilingual and bilingual students at two middle schools. Data analysis revealed that the participants’ perspectives on U.S. history reflected three schematic narrative templates focused on nation-building, equality, and discrimination. The participants primarily employed the (in)equality narratives when discussing aspects of U.S. history directly linked to their identities. The findings add to the extant research on student historical perspectives and use of schematic narrative templates. The findings further suggest that engaging (emergent) bilingual students in examining multiple perspectives and conducting critical history inquiry can contribute to notions of culturally and linguistically responsive social studies instruction.
AlmarzaD.J.Contexts shaping minority language students’ perceptions of American historyJournal of Social Studies Research25220014–22
2.
AlridgeD.P.The limits of master narratives in history textbooks: An analysis of representations of Martin Luther King, JrTeachers College Record10842006662–686
3.
AnS.Learning US history in an age of globalization and transnational migrationJournal of Curriculum Studies412009763–78710.1080/00220270903095993
4.
AnS.Korean American high school students’ perspectives on U.S. historySocial Studies103201212–1910.1080/00377996.2011.581711
5.
AndersonB.Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism2nd ed.1991VersoNew York, NY
6.
BartonK.C.A sociocultural perspective on children's understanding of historical change: Comparative findings from Northern Ireland and the United StatesAmerican Educational Research Journal3842001881–91310.3102/00028312038004881
7.
BartonK.C.Elicitation techniques: Getting people to talk about ideas they don't usually talk aboutTheory & Research in Social Education4322015179–20510.1080/00933104.2015.1034392
8.
BartonK.C.AveryP.G.Research on social studies education: Diverse students, settings, and methodsGitomerD.H.BellC.A.Handbook of research on teaching5th ed.2016American Educational Research AssociationWashington, DC985–1038
9.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good2004Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesMahweh, NJ
10.
BartonK.C.McCullyA.W.You can form your own point of view”: Internally persuasive discourse in Northern Ireland students’ encounters with historyTeachers College Record11212010142–181
11.
BuseyC.L.Más que esclavos: A BlackCrit examination of the treatment of Afro-Latin@s in U.S. High school world history textbooksJournal of Latinos and Education20171–1810.1080/15348431.2017.1386102
12.
BuseyC.L.RussellW.B.IIIWe want to learn”: Middle school Latino/a students discuss social studies curriculum and pedagogyRMLE Online39420161–2010.1080/19404476.2016.1155921
13.
BuseyC.L.WalkerI.A dream and a bus: Black critical patriotism in elementary social studies standardsTheory & Research in Social Education452017456–48810.1080/00933104.2017.1320251
14.
CarreteroM.van AlphenF.Do master narratives change among high school students? A characterization of how national history is representedCognition and Instruction322014290–31210.1080/07370008.2014.919298
15.
CasanaveC.P.Writing up your researchHeighamJ.CrokerR.A.Qualitative research in applied linguistics: A practical introduction2009Palgrave MacmillanNew York, NY288–305
16.
ChoiY.Teaching social studies for newcomer English language learners: Toward culturally relevant pedagogyMulticultural Perspectives15201312–1810.1080/15210960.2013.754640
17.
ChoiY.LimJ.H.AnS.Marginalized students’ uneasy learning: Korean immigrant students’ experiences of learning social studiesSocial Studies Research & Practice6320111–17
18.
ChoS.ReichG.A.New immigrants, new challenges: High school social studies teachers and English language learner instructionSocial Studies9962008235–24210.3200/TSSS.99.6.235-242
19.
CoffeyA.AtkinsonP.Making sense of qualitative data: Complementary research strategies1996SageThousand Oaks, CA
20.
CreswellJ.W.Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches3rd ed.2009SageThousand Oaks, CA
21.
DanY.ToddR.LanW.Consensus and difference: American students’ perspectives on the national historyEducation13122010331–341
DerooM.R.Translanguaging pedagogy to support bi/multilingual students’ language learning in social studies: “How we communicate everything” SlapacA.CoppersmithS.Beyond language learning instruction: Transformative supports for emergent bilinguals and educators2019IGI GlobalHershey, PA233–261
24.
DeutschN.L.Pride in the projects: Teens building identities in urban contexts2008New York University PressNew York, NY
25.
DíazE.DerooM.R.Latinxs in contention: A systemic functional linguistic analysis of 11th-grade U.S. History textbooksTheory & Research in Social Education20201–2810.1080/00933104.2020.1731637
26.
DongY.R.Tapping into English language learners’ (ELLs’) prior knowledge in social studies instructionThe Social Studies10842017143–15110.1080/00377996.2017.1342161
27.
EnrightK.A.Language and literacy for a new mainstreamAmerican Educational Research Journal48201180–11810.3102/0002831210368989
28.
EpsteinT.L.Deconstructing differences in African-American and European-American adolescents’ perspectives on U.S. historyCurriculum Inquiry2841998397–42310.1111/0362-6784.00100
29.
EpsteinT.L.Adolescents’ perspectives on racial diversity in U.S. history: Case studies from an urban classroomAmerican Educational Research Journal372000185–214
30.
EpsteinT.L.Racial identity and young people's perspectives on social educationTheory Into Practice401200142–47
31.
EpsteinT.L.Interpreting national history: Race, identity, and pedagogy in classroom and communities2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
32.
EricksonF.Qualitative methods in research on teachingWittrockM.C.Handbook of research on teaching3rd ed.1986MacmillanNew York, NY119–161
33.
FlyvbjergB.Making social science matter: Why social inquiry fails and how it can succeed again2001Cambridge University PressNew York, NY
34.
FránquizM.SalinasC.In search of the civic histories, identities, and experiences of Latina/o immigrant studentsRamirezP.C.FaltisC.J.JongE.J.D.Learning from emergent bilingual Latinx learners in K-12: Critical teacher education2018RoutledgeNew York, NY123–136
35.
GarcíaO.KleifgenJ.FalchiL.From English language learners to emergent bilinguals: A research initiative of the campaign for educational equity2008Teachers College PressNew York, NY
36.
HarrisL.M.HalvorsenA.-L.Aponte-MartínezG.J.“[My] family has gone through that”: How high school students determine the trustworthiness of historical documentsThe Journal of Social Studies Research4022016109–12110.1016/j.jssr.2015.06.007
37.
HarrisR.ReynoldsR.The history curriculum and its personal connection to students from minority ethnic backgroundsJournal of Curriculum Studies462014464–48610.1080/00220272.2014.881925
38.
HilburnJ.Challenges facing immigrant students beyond the linguistic domain in a new gateway stateUrban Review462014654–68010.1007/s11256-014-0273-x
39.
JaffeeA.T.Community, voice, and inquiry: Teaching global history for English language learnersThe Social Studies10720161–1310.1080/00377996.2016.1140626
40.
JaffeeA.T.Social studies pedagogy for Latino/a newcomer youth: Toward a theory of culturally and linguistically relevant citizenship educationTheory & Research in Social Education4422016147–18310.1080/00933104.2016.1171184
41.
JaffeeA.T.Developing culturally and linguistically relevant historical thinking skills: Lessons from U.S. history teachers for newcomer English language learnersde OliveiraL.C.ObenchainK.M.Teaching history and social studies to English language learners: Preparing pre-service and in-service teachers2018Palgrave MacmillanCham, Switzerland7–37
42.
JaffeeA.T.YoderP.J.Teaching social studies to English language learners: Current research, theories, and pedagogical practicesde OliveiraL.C.Handbook of TESOL in K-122019John Wiley & SonsHoboken, NJ307–321https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119421702.ch20
43.
Jimenez-SilvaM.HindeE.HernandezN.J.How are teachers of social studies addressing the needs of English language learners in their classrooms?PasseJ.FitchettP.G.The status of social studies: Views from the field2013Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC275–286
44.
JournellW.Setting out the (un) welcome mat: A portrayal of immigration in state standards for American historyThe Social Studies10042009160–16810.3200/tsss.100.4.160-168
45.
JunH.“I think the comfort women are us”: National identity and affective historical empathy in students’ understanding of “comfort women” in South KoreaThe Journal of Social Studies Research44120207–1910.1016/j.jssr.2019.09.005
46.
KeeganP.Migrant youth from West African countries enacting affective citizenshipTheory & Research in Social Education4732019347–37310.1080/00933104.2019.1611514
47.
KreftingL.Rigor in qualitative research: The assessment of trustworthinessMilinkiA.K.Cases in qualitative research: Research reports for discussion and evaluation1999PyrczakLos Angeles, CA173–181
48.
KvaleS.Doing interviews2007SageThousand Oaks, CA
49.
LevstikL.S.BartonK.C.Researching history education: Theory, method and context2008RoutledgeNew York, NY
50.
LevyS.A.Heritage, history, and identityTeachers College Record116620141–34
51.
LevyS.A.How students navigate the construction of heritage narrativesTheory & Research in Social Education4522017157–18810.1080/00933104.2016.1240636
52.
MarshallC.RossmanG.B.Designing qualitative research5th ed.2011SageThousand Oaks, CA
53.
MartellC.C.Race and histories: Examining culturally relevant teaching in the U.S. history classroomTheory & Research in Social Education411201365–8810.1080/00933104.2013.755745
54.
MillerJ.M.U.S. history state assessments, discourse demands, and English learners’ achievement: Evidence for the importance of reading and writing instruction in U.S. history for English learnersThe Journal of Social Studies Research4242018375–39210.1016/j.jssr.2017.12.001
NordgrenK.How to do things with history: Use of history as a link between historical consciousness and historical cultureTheory & Research in Social Education4442016479–50410.1080/00933104.2016.1211046
57.
O'BrienJ.The system is broken and it's failing these kids: High school social studies teachers’ attitudes towards training for ELLsThe Journal of Social Studies Research351201122–38
58.
de OliveiraL.C.Knowing and writing school history: The language of students’ expository writing and teachers’ expectations2011Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC
59.
PalmerD.MartínezR.A.Teacher agency in bilingual spaces: A fresh look at preparing teachers to educate latina/o bilingual childrenReviews of Research in Education372013269–29710.3102/0091732X12463556
60.
PattonM.Q.Qualitative research and evaluative methods3rd ed.2002SageThousand Oaks, CA
61.
PeckC.L.It's not like [I'm] Chinese and Canadian. I am in between”: Ethnicity and students’ conceptions of historical significanceTheory & Research in Social Education3842010574–61710.1080/00933104.2010.10473440
62.
PeckC.L.Intersections of students’ ethnic identifications and understandings of historyEpsteinT.PeckC.L.Teaching and learning difficult histories in international contexts: A critical sociocultural approach2018RoutledgeNew York, NY231–246
63.
PeckC.L.National, ethnic, and indigenous identities and perspectives in history educationMetzgerS.A.HarrisL.M.The Wiley international handbook of history teaching and learning2018John Wiley & SonsHoboken, NJ311–333
64.
SalinasC.AlarcónJ.D.Exploring the civic identities of Latina/o high school students: Reframing the historical narrativeInternational Journal of Multicultural Education181201668–87
65.
SalinasC.RodríguezN.N.BlevinsB.Emergent bilinguals in the social studesManfraM.M.BolickC.M.The wiley handbook of social studies research2017Wiley BlackwellMalden, MA440–460
66.
SantiagoM.Erasing differences for the sake of inclusion: How Mexican/Mexican American students construct historical narrativesTheory & Research in Social Education451201743–7410.1080/00933104.2016.1211971
67.
SantiagoM.From multicultural to romanticized representations of the past: How Mendez v. Westminster's significance shapeshifts to appeal to different contextsThe Journal of Social Studies Research441202091–10310.1016/j.jssr.2019.04.004
68.
SantiagoM.Patrón-VargasJ.The fluidity of historical analysis: Students’ interpretations of Mendez v. WestminsterAssociation of Mexican American Educators Journal13120191–1810.24974/amae.13.1.422
69.
SchleppegrellM.J.the language of schooling: A functional linguistics perspective2004RoutledgeNew York, NY
70.
SchleppegrellM.J.AchugarM.OteizaT.The grammar of history: Enhancing content-based instruction through a functional focus on languageTesol Quarterly38200467–9310.2307/3588259
71.
ShearS.B.KnowlesR.T.SodenG.J.CastroA.J.Manifesting destiny: Re/presentations of indigenous peoples in K-12 U.S. History standardsTheory & Research in Social Education431201568–10110.1080/00933104.2014.999849
72.
SilvermanD.Doing qualitative research2nd ed.2005Thousand Oaks, CA
73.
SuhY.AnS.ForestD.Immigration, imagined communities, and collective memories of Asian American experiences: A content analysis of Asian American experiences in Virginia U.S. History textbooksThe Journal of Social Studies Research391201539–5110.1016/j.jssr.2014.05.002
74.
TerzianS.G.YeagerE.A.That's when we became a nation”: Urban Latino adolescents and the designation of historical significanceUrban Education421200752–8110.1177/0042085906294027
75.
VanSledrightB.A.Narratives of nation-state, historical knowledge, and school history educationReview of Research in Education3212008109–14610.3102/0091732X07311065
76.
Vasquez HeiligJ.BrownK.D.BrownA.L.The illusion of inclusion: A critical race theory textual analysis of race and standardsHarvard Educational Review822012403–424
77.
WertschJ.V.Is it possible to teach beliefs, as well as knowledge about history?StearnsP.N.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York, NY38–50
78.
WillsJ.S.Misremembering as mediated action: Schematic narrative templates and elementary students’ narration of the pastTheory & Research in Social Education3912011115–14410.1080/00933104.2011.10473449
79.
WoodsonA.N.We're just ordinary people: Messianic master narratives and black youths’ civic agencyTheory & Research in Social Education4422016184–21110.1080/00933104.2016.1170645
80.
WoodsonA.N.“There ain't no White people here”: Master narratives of the Civil Rights Movement in the stories of urban youthUrban Education5232017316–34210.1177/0042085915602543
81.
YoderP.J.“He wants to get rid of all the Muslims”: Mexican American and Muslim students’ use of history regarding candidate TrumpTheory & Research in Social Education4832020346–37410.1080/00933104.2020.1773364
82.
YoderP.J.JaffeeA.T.Multiple perspectives: Engaging diverse voices in the social studies classroomde OliveiraL.C.ObenchainK.KenneyR.OliveiraA.Teaching the content areas to English language learners in secondary schools2019SpringerCham, Switzerland327–340
YoderP.J.van HoverS.Teaching history to ELLs in standards-based settings: Implications for teacher educatorsde OliveiraL.C.ObenchainK.M.Teaching history and social studies to English language learners: Preparing pre-service and in-service teachers2018Palgrave MacmillanCham, Switzerland39–65
85.
ZhangY.Supporting English language learners in social studies: Language-focused strategiesThe Social Studies10852017204–20910.1080/00377996.2017.1354808
86.
YoderP.J.Middle school emergent bilingual and bilingual students’ perspectives on U.S. history2016University of Virginia(Unpublished doctoral dissertation)
