Teaching for social justice requires an ability to address sensitive issues such as racism and sexism so that students can gain critical consciousness of these pervasive social realities. However, the empirical literature thus far provides minimal exploration of the factors teachers consider in deciding how to address these issues. This study explores this question through ethnographic case studies of two urban, 11th grade U.S. History classrooms. Differing classroom racial demographics and teacher instructional goals resulted in two distinct pedagogical approaches to social justice teaching. Despite differences in class makeup and teaching approach, students in both classrooms developed intellectual confidence and critical citizenship skills related to their growing sociopolitical awareness.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbowitzK.K.HarnishJ.Contemporary discourses of citizenshipReview of Educational Research7642006653–690
2.
Abu El-HajT.R.Becoming citizens in an era of globalization and transnational migration: Re-imagining citizenship as critical practiceTheory Into Practice4842009274–282
AuW.High-stakes testing and curriculum control: A qualitative metasynthesisFlindersD.J.ThorntonS.J.The curriculum studies reader4th ed.2007RoutledgeNew York, NY235–251
5.
AveryP.G.LevyS.A.SimmonsA.M.Deliberating controversial public issues as part of civic educationThe Social Studies10432013105–114
6.
BartonK.S.LevstikL.S.HistoryArthurJ.DaviesI.HahnC.The SAGE handbook of education for citizenship and democracy2008SageLos Angeles, CA355–366
7.
BartonK.McCullyA.Teaching controversial issues… where controversial issues really matterTeaching History127200713–19
8.
BolgatzJ.Talking race in the classroom2005Teachers College PressNew York, NY
9.
ByfordJ.LennonS.RussellW.B.Teaching controversial issues in the social studies: A research study of high school teachersClearing House8242009165–170
10.
DarderA.BaltodanoM.TorresR.D.The critical pedagogy reader2nd ed.2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
11.
den HeyerK.Between every “now” and “then”: A role for the study of historical agency in history and citizenship educationTheory Research in Social Education3142003411–434
12.
EngebretsonK.E.One novice teacher and her decisions to address or avoid controversial issues(press)The Journal of Social Studies Research201810.1016/j.jssr.2017.03.001i
13.
EpsteinS.E.LipschultzJ.Getting personal? Student talk about racismRace, Ethnicity and Education1532012379–404
14.
EpsteinT.Adolescents’ perspectives on racial diversity in U.S. history: Case studies from an urban classroomAmerican Educational Research Journal372000185–214
15.
EvansR.W.AveryP.G.PedersonP.V.Taboo topics: Cultural restraint on teaching social issuesClearing House7352000295–302
16.
FlynnN.K.Toward democratic discourse: Scaffolding student-led discussions in the social studiesTeachers College Record111820092021–2054
17.
FreireP.Pedagogy of the oppressed, 30th Anniversary Edition (M. B. Ramos, Trans.)1970/2008 ContinuumNew York, NY(Original work published 1970)
18.
FreireP.Pedagogy of hope1992ContinuumLondon
19.
GlaserB.StraussA.The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies of qualitative research1967Transaction PublishersNew Brunswick
20.
HackmanH.W.Five essential components for social justice educationEquity Excellence in Education382005103–109
21.
HarlowR.Innovations in teaching race and class inequality: Bittersweet candy and the vanishing dollarTeaching Sociology3722009194–204
22.
HessD.Discussing controversial public issues in secondary social studies classrooms: Learning from skilled teachersTheory and Research in Social Education301200210–41
23.
HessD.Discussion in social studies: Is it worth the trouble?Social Education6822004151–155
24.
HessD.How do teachers’ political views influence teaching about controversial issues?Democracy Education691200547–48
25.
HessD.E.Controversy in the classroom: The democratic power of discussion2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
26.
HessD.Discussions that drive democracyEducational Leadership691201169–73
27.
Hess, D. E., & McAvoy, P. (2009). To disclose or not to disclose: A controversial choice for teachers. In: Controversy in the classroom: The democratic power of discussion (pp. 97-110). New York, NY: Routledge.
28.
JohnsonL.MorrisP.Towards a framework for critical citizenship educationThe Curriculum Journal211201077–96
29.
JournellW.Social Studies, citizenship education, and the search for an American identity: An argument against a unifying narrativeJournal of Thought4620115–24
30.
JournellW.Teacher political disclosure as parrhēsiaTeachers College Record118520161–36
31.
KahneJ.MiddaughE.Democracy for some: The civic opportunity gap in high school(Circle Working Paper 59)2008Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement (CIRCLE)Medford, MA
32.
KahneJ.WestheimerJ.The limits of political efficacy: Educating citizens for a democratic societyPS: Political Science Politics3922006289–296
33.
KellyD.M.BrandesG.M.Shifting out of “neutral”: Beginning teachers’ struggles with teaching for social justicesCanadian Journal of Education2642001437–454
34.
KellyT.E.Discussing controversial issues: Four perspectives on the teacher's roleTheory Research in Social Education1421986113–138
35.
KleinmanS.CoppM.SandstromK.Making sexism visible: Birdcages, Martians, and pregnant menTeaching Sociology3422006126–142
36.
KumashiroK.Against repetition: Addressing resistance to anti-oppressive change in the practices of learning, teaching, supervising, and researchingHarvard Educational Review721200267–93
37.
Ladson-BillingsG.Yes, but how do we do it?LandsmanJ.LewisC.W.White teachers/diverse classrooms: A guide to building inclusive schools, promoting high expectations, and eliminating racism2006StylusSterling, VA29–42
38.
LashbrookJ.T.Fitting in: Exploring the emotional dimension of adolescent peer pressureAdolescence351402000747
39.
LevineP.The future of democracy: Developing the next generation of American citizens2007Tufts University PressMedford, MA
40.
LevinsonM.No citizen left behind2012Harvard University PressCambridge
41.
MartellC.C.Race and histories: Examining culturally relevant teaching in the U.S. history classroomTheory and Research in Social Education411201365–8810.1080/00933104.2013.755745
42.
Moya, J.C. (2012). Apprenticeships in power and critique: How classroom and youth organizing spaces provide Latino youth with opportunities for critical civic development. (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from 〈https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4kc242bq〉 (Moya_ucla_0031D_10642).
43.
OultonC.DayV.DillonJ.GraceM.Controversial issues–teachers’ attitudes and practices in the context of citizenship educationOxford Review of Education3042004489–507
44.
ParkerW.“Advanced” ideas about democracy: Toward a pluralist conception of citizenship educationTeachers College Record9811996104–125
45.
ParkerW.C.Public discourses in schools: Purposes, problems, possibilitiesEducational Researcher358200611–18
46.
ParkerW.C.Constructing public schooling today: Derision, multiculturalism, nationalismEducational Theory6142011413–432
47.
Parkhouse, H. (2016). Critical pedagogy in US History classrooms: Conscientization and contradictory consciousness. (Doctoral dissertation). The University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC
48.
Parkhouse, H., Boyd, A.S., & Pennell, S.M. (2017).Theoretical and historical foundations of social justice teaching. In S.M. Pennell, A.S. Boyd, H. Parkhouse, and A. LaGarry (Eds.). Possibilities in practice: Social justice teaching in the disciplines (pp. 15-24). Rotterdam, Netherlands: Sense.
49.
RossiJ.A.The dialogue of democracyThe Social Studies9732006112–120
50.
RubinB.“There's still not justice”: Youth civic identity development amid distinct school and community contextsTeachers College Record10922007449–481
51.
RyanJ.E.Five miles away, a world apart: One city, two schools, and the story of educational opportunity in modern America2010Oxford University Press
52.
SensoyÖ.DiAngeloR.Is everyone really equal?: An introduction to key concepts in social justice education2012Teachers College PressNew York, NY
53.
SobierajS.BerryJ.M.From incivility to outrage: Political discourse in blogs, talk radio, and cable newsPolitical Communication281201119–41
54.
SwalwellK.“With great power comes great responsibility”: Privileged students’ conceptions of justice-oriented citizenshipDemocracy and Education21120131–11
55.
TannebaumR.P.Dialogue, discussion, and democracy in the social studies classroomSocial Studies Research Practice83201399–109
56.
TatumB.D.Talking about race, learning about racism: The application of racial identity development theory in the classroomHarvard Educational Review62119921–24
57.
TatumB.D.BrownP.C.Breaking the silence: Talking about race in schoolsKnowledge Quest272199812–16
58.
TysonC.A.“Get up offa that thing”: African American middle school students respond to literature to develop a framework for understanding social actionTheory Research in Social Education301200242–65
59.
UrrietaL.Dis-connections in “American” citizenship and the post/neo-colonial: People of Mexican descent and whitestream pedagogy and curriculumTheory Research in Social Education3242004433–458
60.
WashingtonE.Y.HumphriesE.K.A social studies teacher's sense making of controversial issues discussions of race in a predominantly white, rural high school classroomTheory and Research in Social Education391201192–114
61.
WatersonR.A.The examination of pedagogical approaches to teaching controversial public issues: Explicitly teaching the holocaust and comparative genocideSocial Studies Research Practice4220091–24
62.
WeltonA.D.HarrisT.O.La LondeP.G.MoyerR.T.Social justice education in a diverse classroom: Examining high school discussions about race, power, and privilegeEquity Excellence in Education4842015549–570
63.
WestheimerJ.Politics and patriotism in educationDeVitisJ.L.Critical civic literacy: A reader2011Peter LangNew York, NY81–92
64.
WestheimerJ.KahneJ.What kind of citizen? The politics of educating for democracyAmerican Educational Research Journal4122004237–269
