This paper investigates what choices teachers made and what rationales they offered related to the inclusion and exclusion of primary source photographs for a hypothetical unit about the U.S. Civil Rights Movement in order to better understand teachers’ curricular decision-making as it relates to representing the histories of oppressed people. Elementary and secondary social studies/history teachers from three different in-service and pre-service cohorts (n=62) selected and discarded images from a bank of 25 famous and lesser-known photographs. Their decisions and explanations were coded for emergent themes. Findings reveal that these teachers tended to be guided by criteria both technical (how they might teach using a particular photograph) and philosophical (why they might teach about a particular photograph), with narrow definitions of what they deemed relevant and appropriate for their students. Their choices constructed a sanitized narrative of the Civil Rights Movement that largely avoided a discussion of racism.
AldridgeD.The limits of the master narratives in history textbooks: An analysis of representations of Martin Luther KingTeachers College Record10442006662–686
2.
AuW.Social studies, social justice: W(h)ither the social studies in high stakes testingTeacher Education Quarterly33200943–59
3.
Menkart, D., Murray, A.M., & View, J.L. (Eds.) (2004) Putting the Movement Back into Civil Rights Teaching: A Resource Guide for Classrooms and Communities. Washington, DC: Teaching for Change and the Poverty and Race Research Action Council.
4.
ViewJ.L.Critical history teaching: Towards a human rights agenda for pre- and in-service teachersHoosainR.SaliliF.Democracy and Multicultural Education, in the series “Research in Multicultural Education and International Perspectives”2010Information Age Publishing, IncCharlotte, NC149–172
5.
ViewJ.L.I was and am: Historical counter-narrative as nonviolent resistance in the United StatesAmsterR.Ndura-OuedraogoE.Exploring the Power of Nonviolence: Peace, politics, and practice2013Syracuse University PressSyracuse, NY57–77
6.
BanduraA.Social cognitive theory: An agentic perspectiveAnnual Review of Psychology5220011–26
7.
BartonK.C.History: From learning narratives to thinking historicallyRussellW.B.Contemporary social studies: An essential reader2011Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC357–383
8.
BrownA.L.BrownK.D.Strange fruit indeed: Interrogating contemporary textbook representations of racial violence toward African AmericansTeachers College Record1121201031–67
9.
Brown-JeffyS.CooperJ.E.Toward a conceptual framework of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy: An overview of the conceptual and theoretical literatureTeacher Education Quarterly381201165–84(Winter)
10.
ColdronJ.SmithR.Active location in teachers’ construction of their professional identitiesJournal of. Curriculum Studies3161999711–726
11.
CherryholmesC.What to teach?Theory and Research in Social Education412013566–574
12.
CreswellJ.W.Educational research; Planning, conducting, and evaluating quantitative and qualitative research3rd ed.2008PearsonUpper Saddle River, NJ
13.
CornblethC.Reconsidering social studies curriculumTheory and Research in Social Education82198531–45
14.
CornblethC.Climates of constraint/restraint of teachers and teachingStanleyW.B.Critical issues in social studies research for the 21st century2001Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT73–95
15.
EpsteinT.Interpreting national history: Race, identity, and pedagogy in classrooms and communities2009RoutledgeNew York, NY
16.
EvansR.W.Pedagogic creed as foundation: An approach to teaching social studies methodsThe Social Studies992200857–60
17.
Feiman-NemserS.Teacher learning: How do teachers learn to teach?Cochran-SmithM.Feiman-NemserS.McIntyreD.J.Handbook of research on teacher education, Enduring questions in changing contexts3rd ed.2008RoutledgeNew York, NY697–705
18.
FosterS.J.HogeD.RoschR.H.Thinking aloud about history: Children's and adolescent's responses to historical photographsTheory & Research in Social Education2721999179–214
19.
GayG.Culturally responsive teaching: Theory research, and practice2000Teachers College PressNew York, NY
20.
GrantS.G.Measuring history: Cases of state-level testing across the United States2008Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC
21.
HarperD.Talking about pictures: a case for photo elicitationVisual Studies171200213–26
22.
HansenD.T.Values and purpose in teacher educationCochran-SmithM.Feiman-NemserS.McIntyreD.J.Handbook of research on teacher education: Enduring questions in changing contexts3rd ed.2008RoutledgeNew York, NY10–26
23.
HayesC.JuárezB.There is no culturally relevant teaching spoken here: a critical race perspectiveDemocracy & Education20120121–14
24.
HowardG.We can't teach what we don't know: White teachers, multiracial schools2nd ed.2006Teachers College PressNew York, NY
25.
Ladson-BillingsG.But that's just good teaching! The case for culturally relevant pedagogyTheory into Practice3431995159–165
26.
HollingerD.A.National solidarity at the end of the twentieth century: Reflections on the United States and liberal nationalismJournal of American History8421997559–569(Retrieved from) 〈http://www.jstor.org/stable/2952570〉
27.
HurworthRosalindPhoto-interviewingQualitative Research Journal41200473–79
28.
LarsonB.E.KepierT.A.Instructional strategies for middle and secondary social studies: Methods, assessment and classroom management2011RoutledgeNew York, NY
29.
LevstikL.S.Articulating the silences: Teachers’ and adolescents’ conceptions of historical significanceStearnsP.N.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York, NY284–305
30.
MaxwellJ.A.Qualitative research design: An interactive approach3rd ed.2013SageLos Angeles, CA
31.
McCutcheonG.Developing the curriculum: Solo and group deliberation1995LongmanWhite Plains, NY
32.
McNeilL.M.Faking equalityValenzuelaA.Leaving children behind2005State University of New York PressAlbany, NY57–112
33.
Monte-SanoC.BudanoC.Developing and enacting pedagogical content knowledge for teaching history: An exploration of two novice teachers’ growth over three yearsJournal of the Learning Sciences2222013171–211
34.
PattonM.Q.Qualitative research and evaluation methods3rd ed.2002SageThousand Oaks, CA
35.
SalinasC.CastroA.J.Disrupting official curriculum: Cultural biography and the curriculum decision-making of Latino preservice teachersTheory and Research in Social Education3832010428–463
36.
WineburgS.Historical thinking and other unnatural acts: Charting the future of teaching the past2001Temple University PressPhiladelphia, PA
