This paper investigates consumer's behavioural loyalty to online supermarkets over time. We use three measures of behavioural loyalty (share of category requirements, repertoire size, and polarisation index) from four major online supermarkets in the UK across five categories. We find that loyalty to online supermarkets is high in the categories we examined, though it declined somewhat from 2005 to 2009 and subsequently remained stable from 2010 to 2014. We also extensively test the generalisability of the well-known Dirichlet model to the choice of online supermarkets. We find that the model gives better fit from 2010 to 2014 than from 2005 to 2009 and can describe loyalty and competition in this context.
AllenbyG.M.RossiP.E.Quality perceptions and asymmetric switching between brandsMark. Sci1031991185–204
2.
BanelisM.RiebeE.RungieC.Empirical evidence of repertoire sizeAustralas. Mark. J.211201359–65
3.
BartholomeuszS.UK retailers embrace online salesThe Australian News Corp Australia, online2014
4.
BhatS.FoxR.An investigation of jeopardy effects in store choiceJ. Retailing Consum. Serv331996129–133
5.
BhattacharyaC.B.Is your brand's loyalty too much, too little, or just right? Explaining deviations in loyalty from the Dirichlet normInt. J. Res. Mark1451997421–435
6.
BhattacharyaC.B.FaderP.S.LodishL.M.DesarboW.S.The relationship between the marketing mix and share of category requirementsMark. Lett7119965–18
ColomboR.JiangW.Portfolio size of brand purchases in dirichlet marketsof Conference; ANZMAC, Melbourne2002
11.
CorsiA.RungieC.CasiniL.Is the polarization index a valid measure of loyalty for evaluating changes over time?J. Prod. Brand Manag2022011111–120
12.
Dall'Olmo RileyF.SinghJ.BlanksonC.The Routledge Companion to Contemporary Brand Management2016RoutledgeAbingdon, United Kingdom
13.
DanaherP.J.WilsonI.W.DavisR.A.A comparison of online and offline consumer brand loyaltyMark. Sci2242003461–476
14.
DawesJ.Regularities in buyer behaviour and brand performance; the case of Australian beerJ. Brand Manag1532008198–208
15.
DawesJ.Reasons for variation in SCR for private label brandsEur. J. Mark4711/1220131804–1824
16.
DawesJ.Nenycz-ThielM.Comparing retailer purchase patterns and brand metrics for in-store and online grocery purchasingJ Mark Manag303–42014364–382
17.
DawesJ.Meyer-WaardenL.DriesenerC.Has brand loyalty declined? A longitudinal analysis of repeat purchase behavior in the UK and the USAJ. Bus. Res6822015425–432
18.
DriesenerC.Empirical generalisations in the parameter values of the Dirichlet model: An examination across 50 categoriesEhrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science, University of South Australia, Adelaide2017
EastR.HarrisP.LomaxW.WillsonG.HammondK.Customer defection from supermarketsKingston University, Kingston1997
21.
EhrenbergA.Regularities of behaviourAppl. Stat15196613–27
22.
EhrenbergA.A hope for the future of statistics: MsodAm. Stat4431990195–196
23.
EhrenbergA.UnclesM.D.GoodhardtG.G.Understanding brand performance measures: using Dirichlet benchmarksJ. Bus. Res571220041307–1325
24.
ElliotS.FowellS.Expectations versus reality: a snapshot of consumer experiences with internet retailingInt. J. Inf. Manag2052000323–336
25.
ElmsJ.De KervenoaelR.HallsworthA.Internet or store? An ethnographic study of consumers’ internet and store-based grocery shopping practicesJ. Retailing Consum. Serv3212016234–243
26.
FaderP.S.SchmittleinD.C.Excess behavioral loyalty for high-share brands: deviations from the Dirichlet model for repeat purchasingJ Mark. Res3041993478–493
27.
FarrisP.W.BendleN.T.PfeiferP.E.ReibsteinD.J.Marketing Metrics: 50+ Metrics Every Executive Should Master2006Wharton School PublishingUpper Saddle River, NJ50
28.
FreemanM.Experiences of Users From Online Grocery Stores. Self-Service in the Internet Age2009SpringerLondon139–160
29.
GeuensM.BrengmanM.S'JegersR.Food retailing, now and in the future. A consumer perspectiveJ Retailing Consum. Serv1042003241–251
30.
GoodhardtG.J.EhrenbergA.ChatfieldC.The Dirichlet: a comprehensive model of buying behaviourJ. R. Stat Soc14751984621–655
31.
GrahamC.D.A.What's the point of marketing anyway? The prevalence, temporal extent and implications of long-term market share equilibriumJ. Mark. Manag259–102009867–874
32.
HandC.RileyF.D.O.HarrisP.SinghJ.RettieR.Online grocery shopping: the influence of situational factorsEur. J. Mark439/1020091205–1219
33.
HuangC.Y.Excess loyalty in online retailingInt. J. Electron Commerce1622011115–134
34.
JohnsonT.The myth of declining brand loyaltyJ. Advert. Res24119849–17
KengK.A.EhrenbergA.Patterns of store choiceJ. Mark. Res211984399–409
37.
KnoxS.D.DenisonT.J.Store loyalty: its impact on retail revenue: an empirical study of purchasing behaviour in the UKJ. Retailing Consum. Serv71200033–45
38.
LeicesterA.OldfieldZ.Using scanner technology to collect expenditure dataFiscal Stud303/42009309–337
McPheeW.N.Formal Theories of Mass Behaviour1963The Free Press of GlencoeNew York
41.
MelisK.CampoK.BreugelmansE.LameyL.The impact of the multi-channel retail mix on online store choice: does online experience matter?J. Retailing9122015272–288
42.
MundtK.DawesJ.SharpB.Can a brand outperform competitors on cross-category loyalty? An examination of cross-selling metrics in two financial services marketsJ. Consum. Mark2372006465–469
RomaniukJ.DawesJ.Nenycz-ThielM.Generalizations regarding the growth and decline of manufacturer and store brandsJ. Retailing Consum. Serv2152014725–734
49.
RossiterJ.R.PercyL.Visual communication in advertisingColumbia University, Graduate School of Business1979
50.
RungieC.LaurentG.Brand loyalty vs. Loyalty to product attributesDiamantopoulosA.Quantitative Marketing and Marketing Management2012Springer423–444
51.
RungieC.LaurentG.SternP.Changes in loyaltyPresented at; ANZMAC, Melbourne2002
52.
RungieC.M.UnclesM.D.LaurentG.Integrating consumer characteristics into the stochastic modelling of purchase loyaltyEur. J. Mark471020136
53.
SabavalaD.J.MorrisonD.G.A model of tv show loyaltyJ. Advert. Res17December, 6197735–43
54.
SchmidB.GeyerG.WolffW.SchmidR.Stanoevska-SlabevaK.Representation and automatic evaluation of empirical, especially quantitative knowledge#5003–0343721996
55.
SharpB.How brands growSharpB.How Brands Grow2010Oxford University PressMelbourne, Australia16–27
56.
SharpB.WrightM.GoodhardtG.Purchase loyalty is polarised into either repertoire or subscription patternsAustrala. Mark. J.10320027–20
57.
SharpB.WrightM.DawesJ.DriesenerC.Meyer-WaardenL.StocchiL.It's a dirichlet world: modeling individuals’ loyalties reveals how brands compete, grow, and declineJ. Advert. Res5222012203–213
58.
SrinivasanS.S.AndersonR.PonnavoluK.Customer loyalty in e-commerce: an exploration of its antecedents and consequencesJ. Retailing781200241–50
59.
SternP.HammondK.The relationship between customer loyalty and purchase incidenceMark. Lett15120045–19
60.
TellisG.J.Advertising exposure, loyalty, and brand purchase: a two-stage model of choiceJ. Mark. Res25May1988134–144
61.
TrinhG.Predicting variation in repertoire size with the NBD modelAustralas. Mark. J.2222014111–116
62.
TrinhG.AnesburyZ.W.An investigation in brand growth and decline across categoriesInt. J. Mark Res5732015347–356
63.
TrinhG.LamD.Understanding the attendance at cultural venues and events with stochastic preference modelsJ. Bus. Res69920163538–3544
64.
TrinhG.RomaniukJ.TanusondjajaA.Benchmarking buyer behavior towards new brandsMark. Lett2742015743–752
65.
UnclesM.HammondK.Grocery store patronageInt. Rev. Retail Distrib. Consum. Res531995287–302
66.
UnclesM.D.EllisK.The buying of own labelsEur. J. Mark233198947–70
67.
UnclesM.D.KwokS.Generalizing patterns of store-type patronage: an analysis across major Chinese citiesInt. Rev. Retail Distrib. Consum. Res1852008473–493
68.
UnclesM.D.KwokS.Patterns of store patronage in urban ChinaJ. Bus. Res621200968–81
69.
UnclesM.D.HammondK.A.EhrenbergA.DaviesR.E.A replication study of two brand-loyalty measuresEur. J. Oper. Res7621994375–385
70.
UnclesM.D.EhrenbergA.HammondK.Patterns of buyer behavior: regularities, models, and extensionsMark. Sci1431995G71–G78
71.
WoodA.Multichannel shopping: Crossing the channelsAdMap, Warc2011
72.
WrightM.RiebeE.Double jeopardy in brand defectionEur. J. Mark4462010860–873
WrigleyN.DunnR.Stochastic panel-data models of urban shopping behaviour: 2. Multistore purchasing patterns and the Dirichlet modelEnviron. Plan. A161984759–778
75.
WrigleyN.DunnR.Stochastic panel-data models of urban shopping behavior: 4. Incorporating independent variables into the NBD and Dirichlet modelsEnviron. Plan. A171985319–331
