This paper tests both the internal and external validity of the Erdem and Swait (1998) brand equity framework using two measurement modelling approaches, namely the relatively new Best-Worst scaling (BWS) method (Finn and Louviere, 1992; Marley and Louviere, 2005) and the more traditional confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) method. Data were collected from the Australian banking and mobile services sectors. We find the measurement models derived from BWS outperformed the models based on CFA of the rating data in predicting both stated and real brand choices. The findings have implications for both academics and practitioners in brand equity measurement and management.
AakerD.A.Managing Brand Equity: Capitalizing on the Value of a Brand Name1991The Free PressNew York
2.
AkaikeH.Factor analysis and AICPsychometrika5331987317–332
3.
AlmquistE.LeeJ.What do customers really want?Harvard Business Review874200923
4.
AndrichD.Rasch Models for Measurement1988SageNewbury Park
5.
AugerP.DevinneyT.M.LouviereJ.J.Using Best-Worst scaling methodology to investigate consumer ethical beliefs across countriesJournal of Business Ethics7032007299–326
6.
BagozziR.P.YiY.On the use of structural equation models in experimental designsJournal of Marketing Research2631989271–284
7.
BollenK.A.Structural Equations with Latent Variables1989John Wiley and Sons Inc
8.
BondT.G.FoxC.M.Applying the Rasch Model: Fundamental Measurement in the Human Sciences2001ErlbaumMahwah, NJ
9.
BrodieR.J.GlynnM.S.van DurmeJ.Towards a theory of marketplace equity: integrating branding and relationship thinking with financial thinkingMarketing Theory2120025–28
10.
ChurchillG.A.Jr.A paradigm for developing better measures of marketing constructsJournal of Marketing Research161197964–73
11.
CohenS., 2003. Maximum difference scaling: improved measures of importance and preference for segmentation.Sawtooth Software Conference Proceedings, Seqium, WA.
12.
CoulburnC.J.DinitzJ.H.Handbook of Combinatorial Designs2007Boca Raton FL, CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
13.
CronbachL.J.Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of testsPsychometrika1631951297–334
14.
ErdemT.SwaitJ.Brand equity as a signalling phenomenonJournal of Consumer Psychology721998131–157
15.
ErdemT.SwaitJ.D.Sales promotions consistency and consumer preferencesJournal of Marketing Research3432002320–340
16.
ErdemT.SwaitJ.D.Brand credibility and its role in brand choice and considerationJournal of Consumer Research3112004191–199
17.
ErdemT.SwaitJ.BroniarczykS.ChakravartiD.KapfererJ.N.KeaneM.RobertsJ.SteenkampJ.ZettelmeyerF.Brand equity, consumer learning and choiceMarketing Letters1031999301–318
18.
ErdemT.SwaitJ.D.LouviereJ.The impact of brand credibility on consumer price sensitivities across multiple product categoriesInternational Journal of Research in Marketing19120021–19
19.
ErdemT.SwaitJ.ValenzuelaA.Brands as signals: a cross-country validation studyJournal of Marketing701200634–49
20.
FinnA.LouviereJ.J.Determining the appropriate response to evidence of public concern: the case of food safetyJournal of Public Policy and Marketing111199212–25
21.
FornellC.LarckerD.F.Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement errorJournal of Marketing Research181198139–50
22.
GerbingD.W.AndersonJ.C.An updated paradigm for scale development incorporating unidimensionality and its assessmentJournal of Marketing Research2521988186–192
23.
GreenP.E.On the design of choice experiments involving multifactor alternativesJournal of Consumer Research12197461–68
24.
HaydukL.A.Structural Equation Modeling with LISREL: Essentials and Advances1987John Hopkins University PressBaltimore, MD
25.
JöreskogK.G.Statistical analysis of sets of congeneric testsPsychometrika3621971109–133
26.
JöreskogK.G.SörbomD.Recent developments in structural equation modellingJournal of Marketing Research1941982404–416
27.
KellerK.L.Conceptualizing, measuring, and managing customer-based brand equityJournal of Marketing57119931–22
28.
KimJ.MorrisJ.D.SwaitJ.Antecedents of true brand loyaltyJournal of Advertising372200899–117
29.
KrishnanH.S.Characteristics of memory associations: a consumer-based brand equity perspectiveInternational Journal of Research in Marketing1341996389–405
30.
LeeJ.A.SoutarJ.N.LouviereJ.J.Measuring values using Best-Worst scaling: the LOV examplePsychology and Marketing241220071043–1058
31.
LeeJ.A.SoutarJ.N.LouviereJ.J.The Best-Worst scaling approach: an alternative to Swartz's Values SurveyJournal of Personality Assessment9042008335–347
32.
LouviereJ.J.HensherD.A.SwaitJ.D.Stated Choice Methods: Analysis and Application2000Cambridge University PressCambridge, UK
33.
MariA., 2008. Mobile banking to reach 900 million users by 2014. <http://www.vnunet.com>.
34.
MarleyA.A.LouviereJ.J.Some probabilistic models of best, worst, and Best-Worst choicesJournal of Mathematical Psychology4962005464–480
35.
McFaddenD.Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behaviorZarembkaP.E.Frontiers in Econometrics1974Academic PressNew York105–142
NelsonP.Information and consumer behaviourJournal of Political Economy7821970311–329
38.
NetemeyerR.G.KrishnanB.PulligC.WangG.YagciM.DeanD.RicksJ.WirthF.Developing and validating measures of facets of customer-based brand equityJournal of Business Research5722004209–224
39.
NunallyJ.C.BernsteinL.H.Psychometric Theory1994McGraw-HillNew York
40.
ParkC.S.ShrinivasanV.A survey-based method for measuring and understanding brand equity and its extendibilityJournal of Marketing Research3121994271–288
41.
PeterJ.P.Reliability: a review of psychometric basics and recent marketing practicesJournal of Marketing Research16119796–17
42.
SpenceM.Market Signalling: Information Transfer in Hiring and Related Screening Processes1974Harvard University PressCambridge, MA
43.
SteenkampJ.de JongM.G.BaumgartnerH.Socially desirable response tendencies in survey researchJournal of Marketing Research4722010199–214
44.
StiglerG.J.The economics of informationJournal of Political Economy6931961213–225
45.
ThurstoneL.L.A law of comparative judgementPsychological Review3441927273–286
46.
WangP.MenictasC.LouviereJ.J.Comparing structural equation models with discrete choice experiments for modelling brand equity and predicting brand choicesAustralasian Marketing Journal152200712–25
47.
WashburnJ.H.TillB.D.PriluckR.Brand alliance and customer-based brand-equity effectsPsychology and Marketing2172004487–508
48.
YooB.DonthuN.LeeS.An examination of selected marketing mix elements and brand equityJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science2822000195–211
