This article seeks to explain why marketing practitioners should continue to ignore marketing academic research. The reasons are organized into seven categories: customers, structure, causality, reductionism, precision, generalisations and replication. Evidence is drawn mostly from award winning articles. In the short term, the author advocates removing claims of usefulness from academic work, celebrating its academic value and maintaining the gap between academics and practitioners. In the long term, he anticipates the development of new approaches to academic work that might bridge the academic/practitioner gap.
AakerD.A.Strategic Marketing Management1988John Wiley & SonsNew York
2.
AbrahamsonE.Management fashionAcademy of Management Review2111996254–285
3.
AndersonN.The people make the paradigmJournal of Organizational Behavior191998323–328
4.
AndersonP.F.Marketing, scientific progress and scientific methodJournal of Marketing47198318–31
5.
ArmstrongJ.SPrediction of consumer behavior by experts and novicesJournal of Consumer Behavior181991251–256(September)
6.
BlaugM.The Methodology of Economics1992Cambridge University PressNew York
7.
BoltonM.J.StoicisG.B.Ties that do not bind: Musings on the specious relevance of academic researchPublic Administration Review6352003626–631
8.
BrownS.Art or science?: Fifty years of marketing debateJournal of Marketing Management121996243–267
9.
BuckleyM.R.The disconnect between the science and practice of managementBusiness Horizons19981–10(March/April)
10.
CarrollP.Big Blues – The Unmaking of IBM1993Crown PublishersNew York
11.
ChristensenC.M.The Innovator's Dilemma1997Harvard Business School PressBoston, MA
12.
CvitanovicP.Universality in Chaos1993Institute of Physics PublishingLondon
13.
DohertyN.DelenerN.Chaos theory: Marketing and management implicationsJournal of Marketing Theory and Practice94200166–75
14.
EhrenbergA.S.C.Theory or well-based results: Which comes first?LaurentG.LilienG.L.PrasB.Research Traditions in Marketing1994Kluwer Academic PublishersBoston, MA79–108
15.
EhrenbergA.S.C.UnclesM.D.GoodhardtG.J.Understanding brand performance measures: Using Dirichlet benchmarksJournal of Business Research571220041307–1325
16.
EpsteinL.KingG.The rules of inferenceThe University of Chicago Law Review6920021–133(Winter) 1
17.
FreedmanD.H.Is management still a science?Harvard Business Review199226–38(Nov-Dec)
GoodhardtG.J.EhrenbergA.S.C.ChatfieldC.The Dirichlet: A comprehensive model of buying behaviourJournal of the Royal Statistical Society A1471984621–655
20.
GreenleyG.E.Market orientation and company performance: Empirical evidence from the UKBritish Journal of Management6119951–13
21.
HartS.DiamantopoulosA.Linking market orientation to company performance: Preliminary work on Kohli and Jaworski's frameworkJournal of Strategic Marketing1199393–122
22.
HellerR.The Fate of IBM1994Little, Brown and CoLondon
23.
HibbertD.B.WilkinsonI.F.Chaos theory and the dynamics of marketing systemsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science2231994218–233
24.
HoJ.K.Bridging academic research and business practice with the new mediaInformation Resources Management Journal13220006–14
25.
HubbardR.ArmstrongS.J.Replication and extensions in marketing: Rarely published but quite contraryInternational Journal of Research in Marketing111994223–248(June)
26.
HubbardR.BrodieR.ArmstrongS.J.Knowledge development in marketing: The role of replication researchNew Zealand Journal of Business1419921–12
27.
HubbardR.VetterD.E.An empirical comparison of published replication research in accounting, economics, finance, management, and marketingJournal of Business Research351996153–164
28.
HuntS.DThe nature and scope of marketingJournal of Marketing40197617–28(July)
29.
HuntS.D.Marketing as a profession: On closing stakeholder gapsEuropean Journal of Marketing3632002305–312
30.
JaworskiB.J.KohliA.K.Market orientation: Antecedents and consequencesJournal of Marketing57199353–70(July)
31.
KaneE.J.Why journal editors should encourage the replication of applied econometric researchQuarterly Journal of Business Economics231984152–161(Winter)
32.
KohliA.K.JaworskiB.J.Market orientation: The construct, research propositions, and managerial implicationsJournal of Marketing5419901–18(April)
33.
KotlerP.The major tasks of marketing managementJournal of Marketing37197317–28(October)
34.
LeeS.KohS.YenD.TangH.Perception gaps between IS academics and IS practitioners: An exploratory studyInformation & Management401200251
35.
LeoneR.P.SchultzR.L.A study of marketing generalizationsJournal of Marketing44198010–18(Winter)
36.
LevyD.Chaos theory and strategy: Theory, application, and managerial implicationsStrategic Management Journal151994167–178
37.
LindsayR.M.EhrenbergA.The design of replicated studiesAmerican Statistician471993217–228(August)
38.
LynchJ.HooleyG.J.SheperdJ.Reflections on marketing effectiveness: Marketing audit of the 80'sProceedings of the 22nd Annual Conference of the Marketing Education Group: Glasgow Business School1989
39.
MayR.M.Simple mathematical models with very complicated dynamicsNature2611976459
40.
MaikenJ.M.What is the appropriate orientation for the marketing academician?FerrellConceptual and Theoretical Developments in Marketing1979American Marketing AssociationChicago, Il58
41.
MowdayR.T.Presidential address: Reaffirming our scholarly valuesAcademy of Management Review221997335–345
42.
MyersJ.G.What is the appropriate orientation for the marketing academician?FerrellConceptual and Theoretical Developments in Marketing1979American Marketing AssociationChicago, Il62
43.
MyersJ.G.MassyW.F.GreyserS.A.Marketing Research and Knowledge Development1980Prentice-HallEnglewood Cliffs, NJ
44.
NarverJ.C.SlaterS.F.The effect of market orientation on business profitabilityJournal of Marketing199020–35(October)
45.
PetersT.J.WatermanR.H.In Search of Excellence1982Random HouseCambridge
46.
PorterL.W.McKibbonL.E.Management Education and Development: Drift of Thrust into the 21st Century?1988McGraw-HillNew York
47.
RodgersF.G.The IBM Way: Insights into the World's Most Successful Marketing Organization1986Harper & RowNew York
48.
RosenthalR.RosnowR.L.Essentials of Behavioral Research: Methods and Data Analysis1984McGraw-HillNew York
49.
RynesS.L.BartunekJ.M.DaftR.L.Across the great divide: Knowledge creation and the transfer between practitioners and academicsAcademy of Management Journal4422001340–355
50.
SengeS.V.Bridging the gap between the practice and teaching of management accountingOhio CPA Journal474198849
51.
ThomasG.Introduction - A View From the TrenchThomasG.Travels in the Trench between Child Welfare Theory and Practice: A Case Study of Failed Promises and Prospects for Renewal1994Haworth PressNew York1–11
52.
WensleyR.Explaining success: The rule of ten percent and the example of market shareBusiness Strategy Review81199763–70
53.
WestingJ.H.Marketing Educators Must Switch to Helping Real World Meet Real ProblemsMarketing News2919773(July) 11
54.
WilkersonJ.M.On research relevance, professors’ “real world” experience, and management development: are we closing the gap?The Journal of Management Development1871999598–608
55.
WongE.MavondoF.When marketing orientation and leaning orientation do not pay: Evidence from the Australian building and construction industryProceedings of ANZMAC 2000 conference: Gold Coast Australia20001445–1450
