The regulation of advertising is a controversial and difficult process. Over the past three decades, two attempts have been made in Australia to produce more acceptable ads. This paper reviews these systems using a macro framework for analysis which contextualises advertising in society. The systems have the fundamental process of handling complaints about advertising in common, however there are advantages and disadvantages of each and these are discussed. Important insights for the development of regulation of advertising are presented together with critical implications for the future of the industry.
Advertising Standards Council.1993. About the ASC. July. Sydney.
6.
ArmstrongG.M.OzanneJ.L.An Evaluation of NAD/NARB Purpose and PerformanceJournal of Advertising12198315–523
7.
Australian Association of National AdvertisersAdvancing the Interests of Advertisers1993AANASydney
8.
Australian Association of National Advertisers 1997.Advertising Self-Regulation: The facts, the figures, the future.Sydney.
9.
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.1997. Determination Revoking Authorisations granted to the Media Council of Australia. 9 July, Dickson ACT, Commonwealth of Australia.
BestB.International Business and Ethics: The Role for Ethical DisplacementBusiness and the Contemporary World11997209–227IX
12.
BlakeneyM.Regulation by Raised Eyebrows? The Australian Broadcasting Tribunal and the Federation of Australian Commercial Television StationsTomasicR.LucasR.Power, Regulation and Resistance: Studies in the Sociology of Law. CCAE Series in Administrative Studies 81986School of Administrative StudiesCanberra CAE28–35
13.
BlakeneyM.BarnesS.Advertising Regulation in Australia: An EvaluationThe Adelaide Law Review8198229–601 February
14.
BoddewynJ.J.Outside Participation in Advertising Self-Regulation: The Case of the Advertising Standards Authority UKJournal of Consumer Policy6198377–93
15.
BoddewynJ.J.Advertising Self-Regulation: Private Government and Agent of Public PolicyJournal of Public Policy and Marketing41985129–141
16.
BoddewynJ.J.Advertising Self-Regulation and Outside Participation: A Multinational Comparison1988Quorum BooksConnecticut
17.
BoddewynJ.J.Global Perspectives on Advertising Self-Regulation1992Quorum BooksWestport, Connecticut
18.
ByrtW.Business and Government in Australia1990MacmillanAustralia
19.
Canadian Advertising Foundation, 1991. Canadian Code of Advertising Standards. CAF, April, Canada.
20.
CarmanJ.M.HarrisR.G.Public Regulation of Marketing Activity: Part III: A Typology of Regulatory Failures and Implications for Marketing and Public PolicyJournal of Macromarketing. Spring198651–64
21.
DrakeR.The Portrayal of Women in AdvertisingConsuming Interest211988December
22.
DucretA.Deregulation and the Trade Practices ActHeadB.McCoyE.Deregulation or Better Regulation?: Issues for the Public Sector, 1991MacmillanAustralia70–79
23.
FraserH., 1999. Personal conversation with ex-Chief Executive of Advertising Standards Board. Sydney.
24.
GuptaA.K.LadL.J.Industry Self-Regulation: An Economic Organisational and Political AnalysisAcademy of Management Review81983416–4253
25.
HarkerD., 1996. Advertising Self-Regulation: An Assessment of the Effectiveness of the Advertising Standards Council in Australia. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Griffith University, Australia.
26.
HarkerD.The Control of Advertising in New Zealand and Australia: Learning from Success and FailurePolicy Organisation and Society14199757–81Winter
27.
HarkerD.Achieving Acceptable Advertising: An Analysis of Advertising Regulation in Five CountriesInternational Marketing Review, 1521998101–118
28.
HarkerD.Complaints about Advertising: Whats Really Happening?Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal Vol. 32000198–206no. 4
29.
HarrisR.G.CarmanJ.M.Public Regulation of Marketing Activity: Part I: Institutional Typologies of Market FailureJournal of Macromarketing198349–58Spring
30.
HarrisR.G.CarmanJ.M.Public Regulation of Marketing Activity: Part II: Regulatory Responses to Market FailuresJournal of Macromarketing198441–52Spring
31.
Internet 1995.Advertising Self-Regulation.The Better Business Bureau Web Server, June 8th.
32.
JewellL.ReitzH.J.Group Effectiveness in OrganizationsScott Foresman1981
33.
LaBarberaP.A.Analyzing and Advancing the State of the Art of Advertising Self-RegulationJournal of Advertising9198027–384
Media Council of Australia 1996.Media Release, September 27, Sydney.
36.
Media Council of Australia.1994. The Media Council of Australia. Sydney.
37.
MiracleG.E., NevettT., 1987. Voluntary Regulation of Advertising: A Comparative Analysis of the UK and US. D C Heath, Mass., US.
38.
MittalB.Public assessment of TV advertisements: Faint praise and harsh criticismJournal of Advertising Research34199435–531
39.
MoyerM.L.BanksJ.C.Industry Self-Regulation: Some Lessons from the Canadian Advertising IndustryThompsonD.Problems in Canadian Marketing1977AMAChicago185–202
40.
NeelankavilJ.P.StridsbergA.B.Advertising Self-Regulation: A Global Perspective1980Communications Arts BooksNY
41.
OfnerJ.Are Committees Worthwhile?Commerce Magazine56195964–652 March
42.
PincusJ.J.WithersG.A.Economics of RegulationGruenF.H.IIISurveys of Australian Economics1983Allen and UnwinSydney9–76
43.
ShimpT.A.Advertising Promotion: Supplemental Aspects of Integrated Marketing Communications5th edition2000The Dryden PressNew York
44.
SinclairJ., 1992. Globalisation and National Culture: Structure Regulation and Content in the Advertising Industry in Australia. Policy Research Paper No. 24 Centre for International Research on Communication and Information Technologies June, Melbourne, CIRCIT.
45.
SinclairL.AFA Takes Broad-Brush Approach to Ethics Code2001B&T WeeklyJanuary 25th
46.
StreeckW.PhilippeC.S.Private Interest Government: Beyond Market and State1985Beverly HillsSage
47.
StricklandK., 1996. Tasteless ads code to vanish. The Australian, 5, September 28-29, Sydney.
48.
SverdrupS.G.StoE.Regulation of Sex Discrimination in Advertising: An Empirical Inquiry Into the Norwegian CaseJournal of Consumer Policy141992371–391
49.
Trade Practices Commission, 1988. Industry Codes of Practice - A Brief Report, AGPS, Canberra.
50.
WiggsG., 1992. Self-Regulation - A Mix of Judicial and Marketing Principles. Unpublished essay, Advertising Standards Complaints Board, New Zealand.
51.
WooldrigeM., 1998. Code of Responsible Advertising for Liquor Industry. MW152/98, Media Release, 10th July.
52.
WotrubaT.R.Industry Self-Regulation: AReview and Extension to a Global SettingJournal of Public Policy and Marketing Spring16199738–541
