Based on a review of empirical studies, this paper compares the effectiveness of perimeter and outdoor advertising in terms of recall. In a first step, variables influencing the memorisation of perimeter and outdoor advertisers are summarised and categorised. Four groups of variables related to exposure conditions, product, message, and respondent characteristics can be distinguished and are integrated into an information-processing framework in order to explain how perimeter and outdoor advertising work. Conclusions for improving the effectiveness of perimeter advertising are drawn.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AnneF.La mesure de l'efficacité du sponsoringRevue Française du Marketing1381992123–136
2.
AnneF.ChéronE.J.Mesure de l'efficacité du sponsoring: une analyse des effets intermédiaires sur 1’audience directe de l’événementProceedings of the 6th Congress of the French Marketing Association (AFM) 10–11 May, Association Française de Marketing, La Baule, France, 121–1481991
3.
AzhariA.G.KamenJ.M.Study Shows Billboards are More Effective than Recall, Attitude-Change Scores IndicateMarketing News231984November
4.
BhargavaM.DonthuN.CaronR.Improving the Effectiveness of Outdoor Advertising: Lessons from a Study of 282 CampaignsJournal of Advertising Research342199446–55
5.
BucciR.P.Erroneous Recall of MediaJournal of Advertising Research134197323–27
6.
ChandlerB.Media: Outdoor-Effectiveness Research – The Key to Understanding1993Madison AvenueApril
7.
ColeyM. L. (1992), ‘Ad-time – its uses and benefits’, in ESOMAR Sponsorship Europe ‘92 Conference Guide, 2–4 December, Monaco, European Society for Market Research, 77–82.
8.
DeimelK.Erinnerungswirkung der SportwerbungMarketing – Zeitschrift für Forschung und Praxis15119935–14
9.
DonthuN.CherianJ.BhargavaM.Factors Influencing Recall of Outdoor AdvertisingJournal of Advertising Research333199364–72
10.
DreesN.Werbung an Rennstrecken: Präsenz und Erinnerungswirkung ausgewählter Werbeträger bei FernsehübertragungenWerbeforschung & Praxis32119879–12
11.
DuffyE.Activation and Behaviour1962John WileyLondon
12.
EastonS. and MackieP. (1997), ‘When Football Came Home: Sponsorship Activity at EURO 96’, in European Society for Market Research (ed.), New Ways for Optimising Integrated Communications, 16–18 April, Paris, 1–14.
13.
International Marketing Data and Statistics (1996), Euromonitor Publications, London.
14.
GiannelloniJ.-L. (1990), Contribution à l étude du mode d'influence de la communication par l’événement, unpublished doctoral dissertation, University de Lille, Lille, France.
15.
GiannelloniJ.-L.L'influence de la communication par l’événement sur la structure de l'image d'entrepriseRecherche et Applications en Marketing8119935–29
16.
HackforthJ.Zwischen Bandenwerbung und Bandenwirkung – Erste Ergebnisse einer Studie zur EURO 88HermannsA.Sport – und Kultursponsoring1989Vahlen, MunichGermany100–111
17.
HermannsA.DreesN.WangenE.Zur Wahrnehmung von Werbebotschaften auf Rennfahrzeugen: Ein Beitrag zur Wirkungsforschung in der SportwerbungMarketing – Zeitschrift für Forschung und Praxis821986123–129
18.
HewettW.C.What One Little Showing Can DoJournal of Advertising Research125197229–30
KingK.W.TinkhamS.F.The Learning and Retention of Outdoor AdvertisingJournal of Advertising Research296198947–51
21.
LardinoitT. (1996), Etude de l'efficacité du parrainage sportif: Effet modérateur des implications durable et situationnelle, unpublished doctoral dissertation, Université Catholique de Louvain, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium.
22.
McGuireW.J.Some Internal Psychological Factors Influencing Consumer ChoiceJournal of Consumer Research21976302–319(March)
23.
MeenaghanT.Ambush Marketing: Immoral or Imaginative Practice?Journal of Advertising Research344199477–88
24.
MüllerF.Banden – und Sportwerbung: Eine Untersuchung zur Wirkung von Bandenwerbung und zur Einstellung gegenüber Werbung im SportInterview und Analyse104/51983152–156
25.
OtkerT.HayesP.Evaluation de l'efficacité du sponsoring: Expériences de la Coupe du Monde de Football 1986Revue Française du Marketing118198813–40
26.
PavelchakM.A.AntilJ.H.MunchJ.M.The Super Bowl: An Investigation into the Relationship among Program Context, Emotional Experience, and Ad RecallJournal of Consumer Research151989360–367(December)
27.
PhamM.T.Effects of Involvement, Arousal, and Pleasure on the Recognition of Sponsorship StimuliSherryJ.F.SternthalB.Advances in Consumer Research1992Association of Consumer ResearchProvo, UT85–93
28.
SandlerD.M.ShaniD.Olympic Sponsorship vs. “Ambush” Marketing: Who Gets the Gold?Journal of Advertising Research29419899–14
29.
SchumannF.Und am Rand steigt der Bekanntheitsgrad: Die Wirkung der Bandenwerbung bei zwei ausgesuchten Spielen der Fußball Europameisterschaft 1984HackforthJ.Sportmedien und Mediensport: Wirkungen – Nutzung – Inhalte der Sportberichterstattung1987VistasBerlin57–79
30.
Sponsorship Research International. (1994), Annual Estimates of Sponsorship Expenditure, Sponsorship Research International, London.
31.
StippH.SchiavoneN.P.Modelling the Impact of Olympic Sponsorship on Corporate ImageJournal of Advertising Research212199659–65
32.
TinkhamS.Billboard Advertising Effects in a Field Setting: Brand and Advertising Recall’Proceedings of the 1983 Conference of the American Academy of AdvertisingAmerican Academy of Advertising, Lawrence, USA1983
33.
TischlerS.Sportfans gegen Bandenwerber 6:4Absatzwirtschaft202197734–36
34.
TrollK.F.Wirkung von Bandenwerbung – Bericht über ein PilotprojektJahrbuch der Absatz – und Verbraucherforschung291983201–220
35.
WalliserB. (1994), L'efficacité du parrainage sportif au sein de la communication de l'entreprise, unpublished doctoral dissertation, Université de Grenoble II: Ecole Supérieure des Affaires, Grenoble, France.
36.
WalliserB.Sponsoring: Bedeutung, Wirkung und Kontrollmöglichkeiten1995Gabler, WiesbadenGermany
37.
WalliserB.Le rô1e de l'intensité des émotions éprouvées par le téléspectateur dans la mémorisation du parrainageRecherche et Applications en Marketing11119965–21
38.
WalliserB.über den Zusammenhang zwischen Markenbekanntheit und Wiedererkennung bei der BandenwerbungMarketing – Zeitschrift für Forschung und Praxis191199743–52
39.
WoodsideA.G.Outdoor Advertising as ExperimentsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science1831990341–352
40.
YoungE.Visibility Achieved by Outdoor AdvertisingJournal of Advertising Research244198419–21
