Critical to health services management in today's economic climate is efficient utilization of our costly and sometimes limited supply of health care professionals. This two-part article gives an overview of current issues in health care work force planning in Canada. In Part I, the problems of estimating current supply are discussed. Needs-based and demand-based forecasting are contrasted. Comprehensive needs-based planning is recommended and changes needed in order to move toward this type of planning are discussed.
In Part II, the maldistribution of health care professionals and various corrective measures within the context of needs-based comprehensive planning are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Federal/Provincial/Territorial Advisory Committee on Health Manpower.1985. Physician Manpower in Canada 1980–2000. Ottawa: Health and Welfare Canada, Health Manpower Division.
2.
LomasJ.StoddartG.L., and BarerM.1985. Supply projections as planning: A critical review of forecasting net physicians requirements in Canada. Social Science and Medicine20(4): 4311–4424.
3.
Ontario Nurses' Association. 1988. An industry in crisis: Ontario nurses speak out on the nursing shortage. ONA media release, November 10. Toronto.
4.
MeltzN.M.1988. The Shortage of Registered Nurses: An Analysis in Labour Market Context. Toronto: The Registered Nurses' Association of Ontario.
5.
Board of Directors of Physiotherapy and Ontario Physiotherapy Association.1989. Ontario Physiotherapy Manpower Task Force Report. Toronto: Ontario Physiotherapy Association.
6.
MirkopoulosC. and QuinnB.1989. Occupational therapy manpower: Ontario's critical shortage. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy56(2): 73–79.
7.
MacKinnonJ.R.1985. Current supply and future requirements for occupational therapy manpower in British Columbia. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy52(5): 251–257.
8.
FülöpT.1983. Action for the future: Implications for the future for health manpower research. In BankowskiZ. and BryantJ.H., eds., Health For All — A Challenge to Research in Health Manpower Development, XVIth CIOMS Round Table Conference. Geneva: Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences.
9.
Health and Welfare Canada.1988. Health Personnel in Canada 1987. Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services Canada.
10.
Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada.1989. National Speciality Physician Review. Ottawa.
11.
Ontario Council of Health.1983. Medical Manpower for Ontario. Toronto.
12.
Professional Corporation of Physicians of Quebec.1981. Les Effectifs Médicaux au Quebec. Quebec.
13.
LomasJ.1987. Health manpower in Ontario: Distribution, planning and policies. Unpublished document prepared for the Ontario Health Review Panel.
14.
BarerM.L.StarkA.J., and KinnisC.1984. Manpower planning, fiscal restraint, and the “demand” for health care personnel. Inquiry21: 254–265.
15.
Alberta Hospital Association.1980. Nursing Manpower: A Study of Factors in Nursing Supply and Demand in Alberta Hospitals and Nursing Homes. Edmonton.
16.
KazanjianA. and WongG.W.1982. Registered Nurses in British Columbia: A Report on the Supply Situation. Report S:11. Vancouver: Division of Health Services Research and Development, University of British Columbia.
17.
KazanjianA.BrothersK., and WongG.1986. Modelling the supply of nurse labour: Life-cycle activity patterns of registered nurses in one Canadian delivery system. Medical Care24(12): 1067–1083.
18.
MacKinnonJ.R. and StarkA.J.1984. An approach to estimating future manpower requirements in physical and occupational therapy. Physiotherapy Canada36(6): 321–325.
19.
HallT.L.1978. Demand. In HallT.L. and MejiaA., eds., Health Manpower Planning: Principles, Methods, Issues. Geneva: World Health Organization.
20.
FülöpT. and RoemerM.I.1982. International Development of Health Manpower Policy. World Health Organization Offset Publ. No. 61. Geneva: World Health Organization.
21.
BarerM.L. and StoddartG.L.1991. Toward Integrated Medical Resource Policies for Canada: Background Document. Winnipeg: Federal/Provincial/Territorial Conference of Deputy Ministers of Health.
22.
MejiaA.1987. Health manpower out of balance. In BankowskiZ. and MediaA., eds., Health Manpower Out of Balance: Conflicts and Prospects, XX CIOMS Conference, 7–12 September, 1986, Acapulco, Mexico. Geneva: World Health Organization.
23.
HallT.L. and MejiaA., eds. 1978. Health Manpower Planning: Principles, Methods, Issues. Geneva: World Health Organization.
24.
RoemerM.I. and RoemerR.J.1981. Health Care Systems and Comparative Manpower Policies. New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc.
25.
LongA.F. and MercerG., eds. 1981. Manpower Planning in the National Health Service. Guildford, Surrey: Biddles Ltd.
26.
BankowskiZ. and BryantJ.H., eds. 1983. Health For All — A Challenge to Research in Health Manpower Development, XVIth CIOMS Round Table Conference. Geneva: Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences.
27.
RotemA. ed. 1988. Health Workforce Planning, Proceedings of the Intercountry Workshop Sponsored by the World Health Organization, 7–19 February 1988, Kensington: University of New South Wales.
28.
FülöpT. and RoemerM.I.1987. Reviewing Health Manpower Development: A Method of Improving National Health Systems. Public Health Paper No. 83. Geneva: World Health Organization.
29.
World Health Organization.1989. Management of Human Resources for Health: Report of a WHO Expert Committee. Technical Report Series 783. Geneva.
30.
Grava-GubinsI.1986. Manpower study, 1986. Canadian Family Physician32: 2313, 2323.
31.
MooreC.A.1982. Family physician manpower: Poor planning with inaccurate data. Canadian Medical Association Journal127: 1180–1182.
32.
Statistics Canada.1987. Nursing in Canada. Ottawa: Health Division, Minister of Supply and Services.
33.
GinzburgE.1990. What physicians should know about the nursing shortage. Annals of Internal Medicine112(5): 319–320.
34.
FeinD.J.1984. Findings from the 1983 ASHA omnibus survey. ASHA26(4): 45–48.
35.
MorrisL.V.1989. Occupational therapy: A study of supply and demand in Georgia. American Journal of Occupational Therapy43(4): 234–239.
36.
AikenL.H. and MullinexC.F.The nurse shortage: Myth or reality. New England Journal of Medicine317(10): 641–646.
37.
IglehartJ.K.1987. Problems facing the nursing profession. Ibid: 646–651.
38.
BrownM.C.1988. Are health care costs too high because there are too many doctors? In WatanabeM., ed., Physician Manpower in Canada: Proceedings of the First and Second Annual ACMC Physician Manpower Conference. Calgary: University of Calgary.
39.
LomasJ.BarerM.L., and StoddartG.L.1985. Physician Manpower Planning: Lessons from the Macdonald Report. Toronto: Ontario Economic Council.
40.
StevensonC.1988. Projecting health workforce supply requirements. In RotemA., ed. Health Workforce Planning, Proceedings of the Intercountry Workshop Sponsored by the World Health Organization, 7–19 February 1988. Kensington University of New South Wales.
41.
Premier's Council on Health Strategy.1991. Achieving the Vision: Health Human Resources. Toronto.
