This article focuses on key health policy issues related to physician health resources. Using the 1991 Barer/Stoddart report, Toward Integrating Medical Resource Policies for Canada, as the starting point for discussion, the author examines such issues as the number and geographic distribution of physicians, reimbursement, licensing standards, specialty mix and scope of practice. The article concludes with recommendations for future directions in public policy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsO. Management of human resources in health care: The Canadian Experience. Health Economics1992; 1(2): 131–143.
2.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward Integrating Medical Resource Policies for Canada. Report prepared for the Federal/Provincial/Territorial conference of Deputy Ministers of Health, June 1991.
3.
HaconWS. The Health Manpower Situation in Canada. Presented at the Pan-American Conference on Health Manpower Planning, 10–14 Sept, Ottawa, World Health Organization.
4.
LalondeM. A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians. Ottawa, Supply and Services Canada, 1974.
5.
HallE. Canada's National Provincial Health Program for the 1980s: A Commitment for Renewal. Ottawa, Department of Supply and Services, 1980.
6.
Tracing the Origins of a National Health Care Agenda in Canada, 1987–1993. Canadian Medical Association, April 1993.
7.
Strategic Directions for Canadian Physician Resource Management. Provincial/Territorial Conference of Ministers of Health, 28 Jan 1992, Banff, Alberta.
8.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 7. Undergraduate Medical Training. Can Med Assoc J1992; 147(3): 305–312.
9.
ShahCP. Public Health and Preventive Medicine in Canada. Toronto, University of Toronto Press, 1994.
10.
MosbergWHJr. Medical manpower needs at home and abroad. Neurosurgery1992; 30(4): 639–649.
11.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 11. Improving effectiveness and efficiency. Can Med Assoc J1992; 147(11): 1653–1660.
12.
RytonE. The impact of enrollment cuts on Canadian faculties of medicine. ACMC Forum1993; 26(3): 10–16.
13.
National Coordinating Committee on Postgraduate Medical Training.Third Report (revised). To the Liaison Deputy Responsible for Physician Resource Management. January 1994.
14.
MaudsleyR. Canadian self-sufficiency in physician resources. Can Med Assoc J1994; 150(1): 21–22.
15.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 4. Graduates of foreign medical schools. Can Med Assoc J1992; 146(9): 1549–1554.
16.
National Specialty Physician Review.Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada in cooperation with the Canadian Medical Association and the National Specialty Societies. Office of Fellowship Affairs. November 1988.
17.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 1. Background, process and perceived problems. Can Med Assoc J1992; 146(3): 347–351.
18.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 5. The roles and funding of academic medical centres. Can Med Assoc J1992; 146(11): 1919–1924.
19.
HorneJM (ed). Searching for Shortage: A Population-based Analysis of Medical Care Utilization in Under-doctored Communities in Rural Manitoba. In: Proceedings of the Third Canadian Conference on Health Economics, 1986. Winnipeg, Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Manitoba, 1987: 173–198.
20.
Canadian Health Monitor.Survey 4. Toronto, Price Waterhouse, 1990.
21.
WaughD. Present approaches to MD manpower planning “pathway to disaster,” conference told. Can Med Assoc J1991; 145 (3): 255–256.
22.
WilliamsL Sears. Future looks bleak for new MDs as practice limitations become national issue. Can Med Assoc J1993; 148(12): 2175–2180.
23.
FuchsVRHahnJS. How does Canada do it?A comparison of expenditures for physicians' services in the United States and Canada. NE/M; 27 Sept 1990: 884–890.
24.
Physicians Income by Specialty Study, 1985. Ottawa, Health and Welfare Canada, 1988.
25.
American Medical Association.SMS Detailed Tables. Chicago, AMA Center for Health Policy Research, October 1987.
26.
GellmanDD. Growing medical income disparities threaten fee-for-service medicine. Can Med Assoc J1992; 147(11): 1682–1686.
27.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada; 6. Remuneration of physicians and global expenditure policy. Can Med Assoc J1992; 147(1): 3338.
28.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 10. Information creation and dissemination. Can Med Assoc J1992; 147(9): 1325–1329.
29.
MhatreSDeberR. From equal access to health care to equitable access to health: A review of Canadian provincial health commissions and reports. International Journal of Health Services; 22(4): 645–668.
30.
TrentW. Sweeping demographic changes may provide major challenges for Canada's doctors. Can Med Assoc J1993; 149 (5): 717–723.
31.
BarerMStoddartG. Toward integrated medical resource policies for Canada: 8. Geographic distribution of physicians. CMAJ1992; 147(5): 617–642.
32.
BirchSGoldsmithLMakelaM. Paying the Piper and Calling the Tune, Principles and Prospects for Reforming Physician Payment Methods in Canada. Hamilton, Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis, McMaster University, 1994.
