In an effort to maintain fiscal viability, hospitals have been undergoing major restructuring. This article reports on a study that examined innovative downsizing strategies used by 20 acute care hospitals in Ontario. The study team reviewed hospital operating plans and analysed the results of interviews conducted with administrators and employees about the downsizing process. Results revealed no uniformity of approach to downsizing. Although many administrators expressed the need for a cooperative approach, downsizing was typically conducted in a top down fashion, and was perceived very differently by staff and administrators. The authors suggest ways to improve restructuring efforts and put forward questions to guide future research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
FreemanSJCameronKS. Organizational downsizing: A convergence and reorientation framework. Organization Science1993; 4(1): 10–29.
2.
NeufieldMMHoltAJDeberRB. The merger that wasn't: Lessons for senior administrators. Healthcare Management Forum1993; 6(4): 33–37.
3.
SchneierCEShawDGBeattyRW. Companies' attempt to improve performance while containing costs: Quick fix versus lasting change. Human Resource Planning1992; 15(3): 1–25.
4.
NeinstedtPR. Effectively downsizing management structures. Human Resources Planning1992; 12(2): 155–165.
5.
Right Associates.Lessons learned: When Canadian Organizations Downsize. Philadelphia, Right Associates, 1993.
6.
Wyatt Company.Best Practices in Corporate Restructuring. Chicago, USA, Wyatt Company, 1993.
7.
The Financial Times.Awaiting the crunch of the human time-bomb. Bangkok Post, 19 Nov 1992: 24.
MacLeanMB. Measuring hospital productivity and output: The omission of outpatient services. Health Reports1991; 3(3): 229–244.
10.
AdamsLM. Seven steps to staff reduction. Nursing Management1985; 16(2): 11–12.
11.
American Nurses Association.Safe and Quality of Care in Hospitals — Talking Points. Briefing Paper. Washington, American Nurses Association, August 1996.
12.
BaumgartAJ. Evolution of the Canadian health care system. In: BaumgartAJLarsenJ (eds). Canadian Nursing Faces the Future. Scarborough, Mosby-Year Book Inc., 1992: 23–44.
13.
HakimC. Core and periphery in employers' workforce strategies: Evidence from the ELUS survey. Work, Employment and Society1991; 4: 157–188.
14.
BallT. Hospitals Can Meet The Challenge. Speech delivered to the Hospital Boards in the Kitchener-Waterloo area. Kitchener-Waterloo, Health Concepts Consultants, 1991.
15.
Ontario Hospital Association.Report on Hospitals in Ontario. Don Mills, Ontario Hospital Association, 1995.
16.
BuickS. Personal Communication. Alberta Health, 1995.
17.
Job Registries 1995.Personal communication with Health Sector Training and Adjustment Board, Toronto, 11 Dec 1995.
18.
Canadian Nurses Association.Employment Cross Country Checkup. Ottawa, Canadian Nurses Association, June 1996.
19.
Canadian Healthcare Association.Guide to Canadian Healthcare Facilities. Ottawa, Canadian Healthcare Association, 1995.
20.
Canadian Nurses Association and Canadian Hospital Association.Nurses Retention and Quality of Worklife: A National Perspective. Ottawa, Canadian Nurses Association and Canadian Hospital Association, 1990.
21.
MeltzNM. Sorry No Care Available Due to Nursing Shortage. Toronto, Registered Nurses' Association of Ontario, 1988.
22.
MurrayMFrisinaA. Nurses Resigning Their Hospital Jobs in Toronto: Who are They? Why are They Resigning and What are They Going to Do?Toronto, University of Toronto, Health Care Research Unit, 1988.
23.
Ordre des infirmieres et infirmiers du Quebec.The facts — hyper-tension: An urgent need for action. Quebec, National Library of Canada, 1989.
24.
ArmstrongPArmstrongHChoiniereJFeldbergGWhiteJ. Take Care. Warning Signals for Canada's Health System. Toronto, Garamond Press, 1994.
25.
Armstrong-StassenM. The Impact of Work-Force Reduction on Retained Employees: How Well Do Job Survivors Survive? (doctoral dissertation). Columbus, Ohio State University, 1989.
26.
BrocknerJ. The effects of work layoffs on survivors: Research, theory, and practice. Research in Organizational Behavior1988; 10: 213–255.
27.
CameronSHorsburghMEArmstrong-StassenM. Job satisfaction, propensity to leave and burnout in RNs and RNAs: A multivariate perspective. The Canadian Journal of Nursing Administration1994; 7(3): 43–61.
28.
CollinsALNobleR. Hospital rightsizing: In line with long-term strategies and economic realities. Healthcare Management Forum1992; 5(1): 4–18.
29.
ArndtEMDucheminKF. More than “Bandaids”: Emotional support and education during the downsizing process. Healthcare Management Forum1993; 6(3): 5–10.
30.
LowryF. Toronto hospital a real-life experiment in dealing with health care's new fiscal realities. Canadian Medical Association Journal1994; 150(7): 1142–1144.
31.
CameronSHorsburghMArmstrong-StassenM. Effects of Downsizing on RNs and RNAs in Community Hospitals. Working paper. Quality of Nursing Worklife Research Unit, School of Nursing, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, 1994.
32.
VilleneuveMSemogasDPeereboomEIrvineDMcGillisLWalshSO'Brien-PallasLBaumannA. Worklife Concerns of Ontario Nurses. Working paper. Quality of Nursing Worklife Research Unit, School of Nursing, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, 1995.
33.
FaireyD. Patient-Focused Care: Hospital Re-Engineering and the Union Response. Vancouver, Trade Union Research Bureau, 1994.
34.
PinkGH. Funding methods in a restructuring environment. In: The Canadian Institute (eds). Hospital Restructuring. Section IV. Toronto, The Canadian Institute, 1993.
35.
Ontario Hospital Association.Hospital Restructuring in Ontario. Toronto, Ontario Hospital Association, Dec 1994.
36.
College of Nurses.Annual Report 1993. Toronto, College of Nurses, 1993.
37.
Conference of Deputy Ministers of Health (Canada).Federal/Provincial/Territorial Working Group on Health Services Utilization 1994. When Less is Better: Using Canada's Hospitals Efficiently. Ottawa, Queen's Printer, 1994.
38.
KaneJ. The executive's role in getting everyone aboard: Coping with individual response to collective change. Aspens Advisor for Nurse Executives1992; 7(7): 1,3,8.
39.
Porter-O'GradyT. The seven basic rules for successful redesign. JONA1996; 26(1): 46–53.
40.
Ontario Hospital Association.Survey of Operating Plan Costs and Benefits. Final Report. Don Mills, Ontario Hospital Association, Jan 1995.
41.
HammerL. Hospital diversification: Evaluating alternatives. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy1987; 44(5): 1051–1055.
42.
ShererJL. Managing Chaos. Hospitals and Health Networks1995; 69(4): 22–27.
43.
SovieM. Tailoring hospitals for managed care and integrated health systems. Nursing Economics1995; 13(2): 72–83.
