Organizational ethics is an emerging field concerned with the study and practice of the ethical behaviour of organizations. For effective application to healthcare settings, we argue that organizational ethics requires attention to organizations' special characteristics combined with tools borrowed from the fields of business ethics and bioethics. We identify and discuss several implications of this burgeoning field to healthcare organizations, showing how organizational ethics can facilitate policy making, accountability, self-evaluation, and patient and business perspectives. In our conclusion, we suggest an action plan for healthcare organizations to help them respond appropriately to their ethical responsibilities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
SpencerEMMillsAERortyMVWerhanePH. Organization ethics in healthcare. New York: OUP; 2000.
2.
PhillipsRAMargolisJD. Toward an ethics of organizations. Business Ethics Quarterly1999; 9(4): 619–638.
3.
FrenchPA. The corporation as a moral person. In: PoffDCWaluchowWJ, editors. Business ethics in Canada. 3rd ed.Scarborough (ON): Prentice—Hall; 1999.
4.
WerhanePH. Formal organizations, economic freedom, and moral agency. In: PoffDCWaluchowWJ, editors. Business ethics in Canada. 3rd ed.Scarborough (ON): Prentice—Hall; 1999.
5.
Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations.1998 standards. Oakbrook Terrace (IL): The Commission; 1998.
6.
PotterRL. On our way to integrated bioethics: Clinical/organizational/communal. Journal of Clinical Ethics1999; 10(3): 171–174.
7.
The vocabulary of rights has not been the traditional vocabulary of the public provision of healthcare in Canada. Yet, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees certain rights and freedoms within reasonable limits prescribed by law. It will be curious to observe whether the presence of the Charter, together with the influence of rights vocabulary from the United States will result in greater identification of healthcare as a right in Canada.
8.
According to Statistics Canada, roughly one in 10 Canadians is employed in the healthcare sector.
9.
DarrK. Conflict of interest and fiduciary duty. In: DarrK. Ethics in health services management. 3rd ed. Baltimore: Health Professions Press; 1997: p. 99–114.
10.
DavidhizarRErdelSDowdS. Sexual harassment: Where to draw the line. Nursing Management1998 Feb;29(2): 40–43.
11.
DobosRT. Exposure to bloodborne pathogens in the hospital. Professional Safety2000 Feb;29–31.
12.
RoseJR. Contract negotiations: Hospital staffers seek help from a union for attendings. Medical Economics1997 Jun;29–30.
13.
De GeorgeRT. Ethical responsibilities of engineers in large organizations: The Pinto case. Business and Professional Ethics Journal1981 Sept;1(1): 1–14.
14.
Case 4.24: Exxon and Alaska. In: JenningsMM. Business Ethics: Case Studies and Selected Readings. 3rd ed.West Educational Publishing Company; 1999: p. 183–186.
15.
Case 3.24: Cheap Labor: Children, Sweat Shop and the 50-Hour Work Week. In: JenningsMM. Business Ethics: Case Studies and Selected Readings. 3rd ed.West Educational Publishing Company; 1999: p. 133–138.
16.
GoodpasterKE. Business ethics and stakeholder analysis. Business Ethics Quarterly1991; 1(1): 53–72.
17.
SowerVDuffyJKilbourneWKohersGJonesP. The dimensions of service quality for hospitals: Development and use of the KQCAH scale. Health Care Management Review2001; 26(2): 47–58.
18.
PinkGHMcKillopISchraaEGPreyraCMontgomeryCBakerGR. Creating a balanced scorecard for a hospital system. Journal of Health Care Finance2001; 27(3): 1–20.
19.
DonaldsonTPrestonL. The stakeholder theory of the corporation: Concepts, evidence, implications. Academy of Management Review1995; 20(1): 65–91.
20.
MetzgerMDaltonDRHillJW. The organization of ethics and the ethics of organizations: The case for expanded organizational ethics audits. Business Ethics Quarterly1993; 3(1): 27–43.
21.
HillWYFraserICottonP. Patients' voices, rights and responsibilities: On implementing social audit in primary healthcare. Journal of Business Ethics1998; 17(13): 1481–1497.
22.
KennyNPDownieJEllsCMacDonaldC. Organizational ethics Canadian style. HEC Forum2000 Jun;12(2): 141–148.
