Voice quality after narrow-margin laser cordectomy compared with laryngeal irradiation

Abstract

Voice quality remains the issue often used to support preference for radiotherapy in treatment of early glottic cancer. We therefore conducted a perceptual voice study in 2 groups, one treated with radiotherapy for malignant disease and the other with narrow-margin laser cordectomy for either malignant or extensive benign lesions. Sequential patients, 12 treated with radiotherapy and 30 with CO₂ laser excision, were included. Voice samples were recorded before and at intervals after surgery. Ratings of validated judges were used for statistical analysis of various voice characteristics at each time point. Voice deteriorated temporarily after surgery as compared with the radiated group; however, at 6 and 24 months no significant differences were found between the groups. Preferential use of narrow-margin laser cordectomy for appropriate early glottic tumors can be supported not only for oncologic reasons but also on the basis of voice results, cost, and efficiency considerations. (Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1999;121:528–33.)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Kanonier

Rainer

Fritsch

Radiotherapy in early glottic carcinoma. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1996; 105:759–63.

Pellitteri

Kennedy

Vrabec

Radiotherapy. The mainstay in the treatment of early glottic carcinoma. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1991; 117:297–301.

Cragle

Brandenburg

JH.

Laser cordectomy or radiotherapy: cure rates, communication, and cost. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1993; 108:648–54.

Davis

Kelly

Parkin

Selective management of early glottic cancer. Laryngoscope 1990; 100:1306–9.

Hirano

Structure of the vocal fold in normal and disease states: anatomical and physical studies. In: Proceedings of the Conference on the Assessment of Vocal Pathology. Rockville (MD): American Speech-Language-Hearing Association; 1981. ASHA Reports 11.

Kahane

JC.

Histologic structure and properties of the human vocal folds. Ear Nose Throat J 1988; 67:322–30.

Hirano

Kurita

Nakashima

The structure of the vocal folds. In: Stevens

Hirano

editors. Vocal fold physiology. Tokyo: University of Tokyo; 1981. p. 33.

Hirano

Hirade

Kawasaki

Vocal function following carbon dioxide laser surgery for glottic carcinoma. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1985; 94:232–5.

Ossoff

Sisson

Shapshay

SM.

Endoscopic management of selected early vocal cord carcinoma. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1985; 94:560–4.

10.

McGuirt

Blalock

Koufman

Voice analysis of patients with endoscopically treated early laryngeal carcinoma. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1992; 101:142–6.

11.

Blakeslee

Vaughan

Shapshay

Excisional biopsy in the selective management of T1 glottic cancer: a three year follow-up study. Laryngoscope 1984; 94:488–94.

12.

Perry

[Letter]. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1994; 103:85.

13.

Epstein

Lee

DJ.

[Letter]. Cancer 1990; 40:366–7.

14.

Marks

Clark

Wetmore

SJ.

T1 squamous cell carcinoma of the true vocal cord [controversies]. Head Neck Surg 1988;(Suppl 1):S69–71.

15.

Kleinsasser

Tumors of the larynx and hypopharynx. New York: Thieme Medical Publishers; 1988. p. 159.

16.

Cinberg

Silver

CE.

Treatment of larynx tumors with the CO2 laser. In: Silver

. Surgery for cancer of the larynx and related structures. New York: Churchill Livingstone; 1981. p. 154.

17.

Fitch

JL.

Consistency of fundamental frequency and perturbation in repeated phonations of sustained vowels, reading, and connected speech. J Speech Hear Disord 1990; 55:360–3.

18.

Cohen

Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 2nd ed. Hillsdale (NJ): Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1988.

19.

Altman

DG.

Practical statistics for medical research. London: Chapman & Hall; 1991. p. 403–9.

20.

Kaufman

JA.

The endoscopic management of early squamous carcinoma of the vocal cord with carbon dioxide surgical laser: clinical experience and a proposed classification. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1986; 95:531–7.

21.

Stoicheff

Ciampi

Passi

The irradiated larynx and voice: a perceptual study. J Speech Hearing Res 1983; 26:482–5.

22.

Benninger

Gillen

Thieme

Factors associated with recurrence and voice quality following radiation therapy for T1 and T2 glottic carcinomas. Laryngoscope 1994; 104:294–8.

23.

Strong

MS.

Laser excision of carcinoma of the larynx. Laryngoscope 1975; 85:1286–9.

24.

Meyers

Wagner

Johnson

JT.

Microlaryngoscopic surgery for T1 glottic lesions: a cost-effective option. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1994; 103:28–30.