Searching for the Inverted U-Shaped Relationship Between Time and Performance: Meta-Analyses of the Experience/Performance,Tenure/Performance,and Age/Performance Relationships

Abstract

Theoretical and empirical research suggests that job experience, organizational tenure, and age have non-linear relationships with performance. Considered simultaneously, there should exist an inverted U-shaped relationship between time and performance. Furthermore, the nature of this inverted U-shaped relationship should be affected by characteristics of the sample and measurement of performance. Using meta-analysis, this paper seeks to confirm the existence of the inverted U-shaped relationship between time and performance, and to demonstrate the moderating effects of performance measurement (objective versus subjective measures of performance) and job complexity. The results have implications for theory, research on dynamic performance, and human resource management practice.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ackerman, P. L. 1987. Individual differences in skill learning: An integration of psychometrics and information processing perspectives. Psychological Bulletin, 102: 3–27.

Ackerman, P. L. 1988. Determinants of individual differences during skill acquisition: Cognitive abilities and information processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 177: 288–318.

Ackerman, P. L. 1992. Predicting individual differences in complex skill acquisition: Dynamics of ability determinants. Journal of Applied Psychology, 77: 598–614.

Ahlburg, D. A. , & Kimmel, L. 1986. Human resources management implications of the changing age structure of the U.S. labor force. In K. M. Rowland & G. R. Ferris (Eds.), Research in personnel and human resources management: Vol. 4, 339–374. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.

Avolio, B. J. , Waldman, D. A. , & McDaniel, M. A. 1990. Age and work performance in nonmanagerial jobs: The effects of experience and occupational type. Academy of Management Journal, 33: 407–422.

Bommer, W. H. , Johnson, J. L. , Rich, G. A. , Podsakoff, P. M. , & MacKenzie, S. B. 1995. On the interchange ability of objective and subjective measures of employee performance: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 48: 587–605.

Borman, W. C. , & Motowidlo, S. J. 1993. Expanding the criterion domain to include elements of contextual performance. In N. Schmidt & W. Borman (Eds.), Personnel selection in organizations: 71–98.

Bryk, A. S. , & Raudenbush, S. W. 1992. Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Campbell, J. P. 1990. Modeling the performance prediction problem in industrial and organizational psychology. In M. D. Dunnette & L. M. Hough (Eds.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology: Vol. 1, 687–732. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.

10.

Chatman, J. A. 1991. Matching people and organizations: Selection and socialization in public accounting firms. Administrative Science Quarterly, 36: 459–484.

11.

Cleveland, J. N. , & Landy, F. J. 1983. The effects of person and job stereotypes on two personnel decisions. Journal of Applied Psychology, 68: 609–619.

12.

Cleveland, J. N. , & Landy, F. J. 1987. Age perceptions of jobs: Convergence of two questionnaires. Psychological Reports, 60: 1075–1081.

13.

Conway, J. M. 1999. Distinguishing contextual performance from task performance for managerial jobs. Journal of Applied Psychology, 84: 3–13.

14.

Deadrick, D. L. , Bennett, N. , & Russell, C. J. 1997. Using hierarchical linear modeling to examine dynamic performance criteria over time. Journal of Management, 23: 745–757.

15.

Deadrick, D. L. , & Madigan, R. M. 1990. Dynamic criteria revisited: A longitudinal study of performance stability and predictive validity. Personnel Psychology, 43: 717–744.

16.

Ehrenberg, R. G. , & Smith, R. S. 2000. Modern labor economics: Theory and public policy. Reading, MA: Addison Wesley.

17.

Erez, A. , Bloom, M. , & Wells, M. 1996. Using random rather than fixed effects models in meta-analysis: Implications for situational specificity and validity. Personnel Psychology, 49: 275–306.

18.

Farrell, J. N. , & McDaniel, M. A. 2001. The stability of validity coefficients over time: Ackerman’s (1988) model and the general aptitude battery. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86: 60–79.

19.

Feldman, D. C. 1976. A contingency theory of socialization. Administrative Science Quarterly, 21: 433–452.

20.

Feldman, J. M. 1981. Beyond attribution theory: Cognitive processes in performance appraisal. Journal of Applied Psychology, 66: 127–148.

21.

Fisher, R. A. 1932. Statistical methods for research workers. London: Oliver & Boyd.

22.

Forteza, J. A. , & Prieto, J. M. 1994. Aging and work behavior. In M. D. Dunnette & L. M. Hough (Eds.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology: Vol. 4, 447–483. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.

23.

Gandy, J. A. (1986, June). Job complexity, aggregated samples, and aptitude test validity: Meta-analysis of the General Aptitude Test Battery data base. Paper presented to the International Personnel Management Association, San Francisco, CA.

24.

Gatewood, R. D. , & Feild, H. S. 2001. Human resource selection. New York: Harcourt College Publishers.

25.

Giblin, E. J. 1986. The challenge facing human resources. In H. Heneman & D. Schwab (Eds.), Perspectives on personnel/human resource management (3rd ed.): 11–16. Homewood, IL: Irwin.

26.

Giniger, S. , Dispenzieri, A. , & Eisenberg, J. 1983. Age, experience, and performance on speed and skill jobs in an applied setting. Journal of Applied Psychology, 68: 469–475.

27.

Gutenberg, R. L. , Arvey, R. D. , Osburn, H. G. , & Jeanneret, P. R. 1983. Moderating effects of decision-making/information-processing job dimensions on test validities. Journal of Applied Psychology, 68: 602–608.

28.

Hackman, J. R. , & Oldham, G. R. 1975. Development of the job diagnostic survey. Journal of Applied Psychology, 60: 159–170.

29.

Hall, D. T., & Associates . 1996. The career is dead-long live the career. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

30.

Hall, D. T. , & Mirvis, P. H. 1995. Careers as lifelong learning. In A. Howard (Ed.), The changing nature of work: 323–361. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

31.

Hedges, L. V. , & Olkin, I. 1985. Statistical, methods for meta-analysis. New York: Academic Press.

32.

Heneman, R. L. 1986. The relationship between supervisory and results-oriented measures of performance: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 39: 811–826.

33.

Heneman, H. G. , Heneman, R. L. , & Judge, T. A. 1997. Staffing organizations (2nd ed.). Chicago: Irwin.

34.

Henry, R. A. , & Hulin, C. L. 1987. Stability of skilled performance across time: Some generalizations and limitations on utilities. Journal of Applied Psychology, 72: 457–462.

35.

Hofmann, D. A. , Jacobs, R. , & Baratta, J. E. 1993. Dynamic criteria and the measurement of change. Journal of Applied Psychology, 78: 194–204.

36.

Hofmann, D. A. , Jacobs, R. , & Gerras, S. J. 1992. Mapping individual performance over time. Journal of Applied Psychology, 77: 185–195.

37.

Hotelling, H. 1953. New light on the correlation coefficient and its transformation. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B, 15: 193–225.

38.

Hulin, C. L. , Henry, R. A. , & Noon, S. L. 1990. Adding a dimension: Time as a factor in the generalizability of predictive relationships. Psychological Bulletin, 107: 328–340.

39.

Hunter, J. E. 1983a. A causal analysis of cognitive ability, job knowledge, job performance and supervisory ratings. In F. Landy , S. Zedeck , & J. Cleveland (Eds.), Performance measurement and theory: 257–266. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

40.

Hunter, J. E. 1983b. Test validation for 12,000 jobs: An application of job classification and validity generalization analysis for the General Aptitude Test Battery (U.S. Employment Service Test Research Report No. 45). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor.

41.

Hunter, J. E. , & Hunter, R. F. 1984. Validity and utility of alternative predictors of job performance. Psychological Bulletin, 96: 72–98.

42.

Hunter, J. E. , & Schmidt, F. L. 1990. Methods of meta-analysis. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

43.

Hunter, J. E. , & Schmidt, F. L. 2000. Fixed effects vs. random effects meta-analysis models: Implications for cumulative research knowledge. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 8: 275–292.

44.

Judge, T. A. , & Hulin, C. L. 1993. Job satisfaction as a reflection of disposition: A multiple source causal analysis. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 56: 388–421.

45.

Judge, T. A. , & Locke, E. A. 1993. Effect of dysfunctional thought processes on subjective well-being and job satisfaction. Journal of Applied Psychology, 78: 475–490.

46.

Kahn, S. C. , Brown, B. B. , Zepke, B. E. , & Lanzarone, M. L. 1994. Legal guide to human resources. New York: Warren, Gorham & Lamont.

47.

Kliegl, R. , & Mayr, U. 1992. Shifting levels of analysis in the investigation of cognitive aging: Commentary. Human Development, 35: 343–349.

48.

Kuhlen, R. G. 1977. Developmental changes in motivation during the adult years. In B. L. Neugarten (Ed.), Middle age and aging: 115–136. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

49.

Lance, C. E. , Teachout, M. S. , & Donnelly, T. M. 1992. Specification of the criterion construct space: An application of hierarchical confirmatory factor analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 77: 437–452.

50.

Lawrence, B. S. 1988. New wrinkles in the theory of age: Demography, norms, and performance ratings. Academy of Management Journal, 31: 309–337.

51.

Lawrence, B. S. 1996. Interest and indifference: The role of age in the organizational sciences. Research in Personnel and Human Resource Management, 15: 1–59.

52.

Lindenberger, U. , & Baltes, P. B. 1994. Sensory functioning and intelligence in old age: A strong connection. Psychology and Aging, 9: 339–355.

53.

McDaniel, M. A. , Schmidt, F. L. , & Hunter, J. E. 1988. Job experience correlates of job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73: 327–330.

54.

McEvoy, G. M. , & Cascio, W. F. 1989. Cumulative evidence of the relationship between employee age and job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 74: 11–17.

55.

Motowidlo, S. J. , & Van Scotter, J. R. 1994. Evidence that task performance should be distinguished from contextual performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 79: 475–480.

56.

Murphy, K. R. 1989. Is the relationship between cognitive ability and job performance stable over time? Human Performance, 2: 183–200.

57.

Nonaka, I. 1994. A dynamic theory of organizational knowledge creation. Organizational Science, 5: 14–37.

58.

Overton, R. C. 1998. A comparison of fixed effects and mixed (random-effects) models for meta-analysis tests of moderator variable effects. Psychological Methods, 3: 354–379.

59.

Ployhart, R. E. , & Hakel, M. D. 1998. The substantive nature of performance variability: Predicting interindividual differences in intraindividual performance. Personnel Psychology, 51: 859–901.

60.

Quiñones, M. A. , Ford, J. K. , & Teachout, M. S. 1995. The relationship between work experience and job performance: A conceptual and meta-analytic review. Personnel Psychology, 48: 887–910.

61.

Rhodes, S. R. 1983. Age-related differences in work attitudes and behavior: A review and conceptual analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 93: 328–367.

62.

Roth, P. R. , & Switzer, F. S. 1995. A Monte Carlo analysis of missing data techniques in a HRM setting. Journal of Management, 21: 1003–1023.

63.

Rotundo, M. , & Sackett, P. R. 2002. The relative importance of task, citizenship, and counter productive performance to global ratings of job performance: A policy-capturing approach. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87: 66–80.

64.

Sackett, P. R. , & Yang, H. 2000. Correction for range restriction: An expanded typology. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85: 112–118.

65.

Salthouse, T. 1979. Adult age and speed accuracy trade-off. Ergonomics, 22: 811–821.

66.

Salthouse, T. 1991. Theoretical perspectives of cognitive aging. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

67.

Schmidt, F. L. , Hunter, J. E. , & Outerbridge, A. N. 1986. The impact of job experience and ability on job knowledge work sample performance, and supervisory rating of performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 71: 432–439.

68.

Schmidt, F. L. , & Kaplan, L. B. 1971. Composite vs. multiple criteria: A review and resolution of the controversy. Personnel Psychology, 24: 419–434.

69.

Scullen, S. E. , Goff, M. , & Mount, M. K. 2000. Understanding the latent structure of job performance ratings. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85: 956–970.

70.

Siegel, J. P. , & Ghiselli, E. E. 1971. Managerial talent, pay, and age. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 1: 129–135.

71.

Sturman, M. C. , & Trevor, C. O. 2001. The implications of linking the dynamic performance and employee turnover literatures. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86: 684–696.

72.

Tesluk, P. E. , & Jacobs, R. R. 1998. Toward an integrated model of work experience. Personnel Psychology, 51: 321–355.

73.

United States Department of Labor . 1991. Dictionary of occupational titles (4th ed.). Washington, DC: U.S. Government.

74.

Van Maanen, J. , & Schein, E. H. 1979. Toward a theory of organizational socialization. In B. M. Staw (Ed.), Research in organizational behavior: Vol. 1, 209–264. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.

75.

Van Scotter, J. R. , Motowidlo, S. J. , & Cross, T. C. 2000. Effects of task performance and contextual performance on systematic rewards. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85: 526–535.

76.

Vance, R. J. , MacCallum, R. C. , Coovert, M. D. , & Hedge, J. W. 1988. Construct validity of multiple job performance measures using confirmatory factor analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73: 74–80.

77.

Verhaeghen, P. , & Salthouse, T. A. 1997. Meta-analyses of age-cognitive relations in adulthood: Estimates of linear and nonlinear age effects and structural models. Psychological Bulletin, 122: 231–249.

78.

Waldman, D. A. , & Avolio, B. J. 1986. A meta-analysis of age differences in job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 71: 33–38.

79.

Waldman, D. A. , & Avolio, B. J. 1993. Aging and work performance in perspective: Contextual and developmental considerations. In K. M. Rowland & G. R. Ferris (Eds.), Research in personnel and human resources management: Vol. 11, 133–162. Greenwich, Hun CT: JAI Press.

80.

Warr, P. 1994. Age and employment. In H. C. Triandis , M. D. Dunnette , & L. M. Hough (Eds.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology: Vol. 4, 485–550. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.

81.

Weiss, H. M. 1990. Learning theory and industrial and organizational psychology. In M. D. Dunnette & L. M. Hough (Eds.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology (2nd ed.): Vol. 1, 171–221. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.

82.

Wright, J. D. , & Hamilton, R. F. 1978. Work satisfaction and age: Some evidence for the job change hypothesis. Social Forces, 56: 1140–1158.