While many studies have examined the relationship between social ties and joining social movements and religious groups, few studies have investigated the relationship between social ties and the likelihood of exiting such groups. Additionally, research has not considered how geography affects the membership dynamics of geographically-based congregations, specifically whether factors associated with residential mobility may also affect congregational exit in geographically-based congregations.
Purpose
The purpose of this study is to examine how familial ties and place of employment affect congregational exit in geographically-based congregations. Drawing on social network and residential mobility research, this study hypothesizes that having parents and/or adult children in the same congregation and having minor children decreases the likelihood of congregational exit and working farther away from the congregation increases it.
Methods
This study draws on longitudinal archival data from one Amish congregation in the Holmes County Ohio Settlement. It tests the hypotheses using logistic regression models.
Results
The results show that having one's parents/adult children in the congregation and working close to the congregation are associated with a reduced likelihood of congregational exit. Having minor children in one's household is not associated with congregational exit.
Conclusions and Implications
This is one of the first studies to consider how geographical requirements for congregational membership has implications for congregational exit. Given the results, congregations may be able to increase member retention by creating multigenerational ministries that support extended families and by advertising in local places of employment. As occupations increasingly shift to being primarily outside the home, Amish congregations in particular may experience more member turnover and membership instability.
Abel, Michael K. 2005. Retention Strategies and Religious Success: A Regional Comparison of American Jews. Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion 1.
2.
BahrHoward MAlbrechtStan LStrangers Once More: Patterns of Disaffiliation from MormonismJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1989282180–200
3.
BainbridgeWilliam SimsThe Sociology of Religious Movements1997New YorkRoutledge
4.
BibbyReginald WOn Boundaries, Gates, and Circulating Saints: A Longitudinal Look at Loyalty and LossReview of Religious Research1999412149–164
5.
BoeriMiriam WilliamsWomen after the Utopia: The Gendered Lives of Former Cult MembersJournal of Contemporary Ethnography2002313323–360
6.
BrinkerhoffMerlin BMackieMarlene MCasting off the Bonds of Organized Religion: A Religious-Careers Approach to the Study of ApostasyReview of Religious Research1993343235–258
7.
BromleyDavid GLinking Social Structure and the Exit Process in Religious Organizations: Defectors, Whistle-Blowers, and ApostatesJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1998371145–160
8.
BromleyDavid GBromleyDGThe Social Construction of Contested Exit Roles: Defectors, Whistleblowers, and ApostatesThe Politics of Religious Apostasy: The Role of Apostates in the Transformation of Religious Movements1998ConnecticutPaeger Publisher19–48
ColyerCoreyAndersonCorySteinRachelDonnermeyerJoseph FWasaoSamsonReviving the Demographic Study of the AmishJournal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies20175196–119
11.
Corcoran, Katie E. 2019. Religious Capital Specificity: Predicting Member Retention. Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion 15.
12.
DavidmanLynnBecoming Un-Orthodox: Stories of Ex-Hasidic Jews2015New YorkOxford University Press
13.
DavidmanLynnGreilArthur LCharacters in Search of a Script: The Exit Narratives of Formerly Ultra-Orthodox JewsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2007462201–216
14.
DawkinsCasey JAre Social Networks the Ties that Bind Families to Neighborhoods?Housing Studies2006216867–881
15.
DiamondEtanAnd I Will Dwell in Their Midst: Orthodox Jews in Suburbia2000Chapel HillUniversity of North Carolina Press
16.
DielemanFrans MModelling Residential Mobility; a Review of Recent Trends in ResearchJournal of Housing and the Built Environment200116249–265
17.
DonnermeyerJoseph FDoubling Time and Population Increase of the AmishJournal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies20153194–109
18.
DoughertyKevin DMulderMark TWorshipping Local? Congregation Proximity, Attendance, and Neighborhood CommitmentReview of Religious Research202062127–44
19.
EbaughHelen Rose FuchsBecoming an Ex: The Process of Role Exit1988ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
20.
EbaughHelen Rose FuchsBromleyDGLeaving Catholic Convents: Toward a Theory of DisengagementFalling from the Faith: Causes and Consequences of Religious Apostasy. Vol. 20201988Beverly Hills, CASage Publications1–33
21.
EricksenEugene PEricksenJulia AHostetlerJohn AThe Cultivation of the Soil as a Moral Directive: Population Growth, Family Ties, and the Maintenance of Community among the Old Order AmishRural Sociology198045149
22.
EricksenJuliaKleinGaryWomen's Roles and Family Production among the Old Order AmishRural Sociology1981462282
23.
FaulknerCarolineGendered Motivations for Religious Exit among the Former AmishInterdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion2018143–27
24.
FaulknerCaroline LIdentity Change among Ethno-Religious Border Crossers: The Case of the Former AmishReview of Religious Research2017594447–470
25.
FaulknerCaroline LDingerRachel ChristenResearch Note: Understanding Defection among the Former AmishMennonite Quarterly Review2014881107–127
26.
FazzinoLori LLeaving the Church behind: Applying a Deconversion Perspective to Evangelical Exit NarrativesJournal of Contemporary Religion2014292249–266
27.
FinkeRogerIannacconeLaurence RSupply-Side Explanations for Religious ChangeThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science199352727–39
28.
FinkeRogerStarkRodneyThe Churching of America, 1776–2005: Winners and Losers in Our Religious Economy20052New Brunswick, NJRutgers University Press
29.
FischerPeter AMalmbergGunnarSettled People Don't Move: On Life Course and (Im-)Mobility in SwedenInternational Journal of Population Geography200175357–371
30.
Gallagher, Sally K. 2020. Continuity and Community: An Analysis of Membership Turnover, Growth and Decline in Three Congregations. Review of Religious Research.
31.
GlennNorval DInterreligious Marriage in the United States: Patterns and Recent TrendsJournal of Marriage and the Family1982443555–566
32.
GouldRoger VDianiMMcAdamDWhy Do Networks Matter? Rationalist and Structuralist InterpretationsSocial Movements and Networks: Relational Approaches to Collective Action2003New YorkOxford University Press233–257
33.
GreeleyAndrew MMusical Chairs: Patterns of Denominational ChangeSociology and Social Research19887275–86
34.
GreksaLawrence PKorbinJill EKey Decisions in the Lives of the Old Order Amish: Joining the Church and Migrating to Another SettlementMennonite Quarterly Review2002764373–399
35.
HadawayC. KirkMarlerPenny LongAll in the Family: Religious Mobility in AmericaReview of Religious Research199335297–116
36.
HinderakerAmoretteO'ConnorAmyThe Long Road out: Exit Stories from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day SaintsCommunication Studies2015665509–527
37.
HostetlerJohn AAmish Society19934Baltimore, MDJohns Hopkins University Press
38.
HurstCharles EMcConnellDavid LAn Amish Paradox: Diversity and Change in the World's Largest Amish Community2010Baltimore, MDJohns Hopkins University Press
39.
IannacconeLaurence RA Formal Model of Church and SectAmerican Journal of Sociology198894SupplementS241–S268
40.
IannacconeLaurence RReligious Practice: A Human Capital ApproachJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1990293297–314
41.
IannacconeLaurence RWhy Strict Churches are StrongAmerican Journal of Sociology19949951180–1211
42.
JacobsJanetThe Economy of Love in Religious Commitment: The Deconversion of Women from Nontraditional Religious MovementsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1984232155–171
43.
JacobsJanetDeconversion from Religious Movements: An Analysis of Charismatic Bonding and Spiritual CommitmentJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1987263294–308
44.
JohnsonDaniel CarsonBromleyDGApostates Who Never Were: The Social Construction of Absque Facto Apostate NarrativesThe Politics of Religious Apostasy: The Role of Apostates in the Transformation of Religious Movements1998ConnecticutPaeger Publisher115–138
45.
KittsJamesMobilizing in Black Boxes: Social Networks and Participation in Social Movement OrganizationsMobilization: An International Quarterly200052241–257
46.
KittsJames ANot in Our Backyard: Solidarity, Social Networks, and the Ecology of Environmental MobilizationSociological Inquiry1999694551–574
47.
KosminBarry AlexanderKeysarArielaReligion in a Free Market: Religious and Non-Religious Americans: Who, What, Why, Where2006Ithaca, NYParamount Market Publishing
48.
KraybillDonald BThe Riddle of Amish Culture2001Baltimore, MDJohns Hopkins University Press
49.
KraybillDonald BJohnson-WeinerKaren MNoltSteven MThe Amish2013Baltimore, MDJohns Hopkins University Press
LongLarry HThe Influence of Mumber and Ages of Children on Residential MobilityDemography197293371–382
52.
LongScot EMooreRichardAmish Church District Fissioning and Watershed Boundaries among Holmes County, Ohio, AmishJournal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies201422186–202
53.
LovelandMatthew TReligious Switching: Preference Development, Maintenance, and ChangeJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2003421147–157
54.
LowerySeanNobleAllen GThe Changing Occupational Structure of the Amish of the Holmes County, Ohio, SettlementThe Great Lakes Geographer20007126–37
55.
MainesDavid RMcCallionMichael JResearch Note: Evidence of and Speculations on Catholic de Facto CongregationalismReview of Religious Research200446192–101
56.
MaussArmand LBromleyDGApostasy and the Management of Spoiled IdentityThe Politics of Religious Apostasy: The Role of Apostates in the Transformation of Religious Movements1998Westport, CTPaeger Publisher51–74
57.
McAdamDougRecruitment to High-Risk Activism: The Case of Freedom SummerAmerican Journal of Sociology198692164–90
58.
McAdamDougDianiMMcAdamDBeyond Structural Analysis: Toward a More Dynamic Understanding of Social MovementsSocial Movements and Networks: Relational Approaches to Collective Action2003New YorkOxford University Press281–298
59.
McBrideMichaelClub Mormon: Free-Riders, Monitoring, and Exclusion in the LDS ChurchRationality and Society2007194395–424
60.
McConnellDavid LHurstCharles ENo ‘Rip Van Winkles’ Here: Amish Education Since Wisconsin v. YoderAnthropology & Education Quarterly2006373236–254
61.
MeadLoren BThe Once and Future Church: Reinventing the Congregation for a New Mission Frontier1991LanhamRowman & Littlefield
62.
MeyersThomas JPopulation Growth and Its Consequences in the Elkhart–LaGrange Old Order Amish SettlementMennonite Quarterly Review1991653308–321
63.
MeyersThomas JKraybillDBOlshanMALunch Pails and FactoriesThe Amish Struggle with Modernity1994Hanover, NHUniversity Press of New England165–181
64.
MeyersThomas JThe Old Order Amish: To Remain in the Faith or to LeaveMennonite Quarterly Review1994683378–395
65.
MichielinFrancescaMulderClara HFamily Events and the Residential Mobility of CouplesEnvironment and Planning A200840112770–2790
66.
MontgomeryJames DDynamics of the Religious Economy: Exit, Voice and Denominational SecularizationRationality and Society19968181–110
67.
MuellerSamuel ADimensions of Interdenominational Mobility in the United StatesJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion197110276–84
68.
MusickMarcWilsonJohnReligious Switching for Marriage ReasonsSociology of Religion1995563257–270
69.
NoltSteven MThe Amish: A Concise Introduction2016Baltimore, MDJohns Hopkins University Press
70.
PackardJoshFergusonTodd WBeing Done: Why People Leave the Church, but Not Their FaithSociological Perspectives2019624499–517
71.
PasseyFlorenceDianiMMcAdamDSocial Networks Matter. But How?Social Movements and Networks: Relational Approaches to Collective Action2003New YorkOxford University Press21–48
72.
RoofWade ClarkMultiple Religious Switching: A Research NoteJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion198928530–535
73.
ScheitleChristopher PDoughertyKevin DRace, Diversity, and Membership Duration in Religious CongregationsSociological Inquiry2010803405–423
74.
SchwadelPhilipPeriod and Cohort Effects on Religious Nonaffiliation and Religious Disaffiliation: A Research NoteJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2010492311–319
75.
SchwadelPhilipSocial Class and Finding a Congregation: How Attendees are Introduced to Their CongregationsReview of Religious Research2012544543–554
76.
SherkatDarren ELeaving the Faith: Testing Theories of Religious Switching Using Survival ModelsSocial Science Research1991202171–187
77.
SherkatDarren EYoungLAEmbedding Religious ChoicesRational Choice Theory and Religion: Summary and Assessment1997New YorkRoutledge65–87
78.
SherkatDarren EChanging Faith: The Dynamics and Consequences of Americans’ Shifting Religious Identities2014New YorkNYU Press
79.
SherkatDarren EWilsonJohnPreferences, Constraints, and Choices in Religious Markets: An Examination of Religious Switching and ApostasySocial Forces1995733993–1026
80.
SmithChristianSikkinkDavidSocial Predictors of Retention in and Switching from the Religious Faith of Family of Origin: Another Look Using Religious Tradition Self-IdentificationReview of Religious Research2003452188–206
81.
SnowDavid AMachalekRichardThe Sociology of ConversionAnnual Review of Sociology1984101167–190
82.
SnowDavid APhillipsCynthia LThe Lofland-Stark Conversion Model: A Critical ReassessmentSocial Problems1980274430–447
83.
SnowDavid AZurcherLouis AEkland-OlsonSheldonSocial Networks and Social Movements: A Microstructural Approach to Differential RecruitmentAmerican Sociological Review1980455787–801
84.
SpringAmyAckertElizabethCrowderKyleSouthScott JInfluence of Proximity to Kin on Residential Mobility and Destination Choice: Examining Local Movers in Metropolitan AreasDemography20175441277–1304
85.
StarkRodneyFinkeRogerActs of Faith: Explaining the Human Side of Religion2000BerkeleyUniversity of California Press
86.
StarkRodneyGlockCharles YAmerican Piety: The Nature of Religious Commitment1968BerkeleyUniversity of California Press
87.
SteinRachel ECorcoranKatie EKowalskiBrittany MColyerCorey JCongregational Cohesion, Retention, and the Consequences of Size Reduction: A Longitudinal Network Analysis of an Old Order Amish ChurchSociology of Religion2020812206–229
88.
StevickRichard AGrowing up Amish: The Rumspringa Years20142BaltimoreJohns Hopkins University Press
89.
SuhDanielRussellRaymondNon-Affiliation, Non-Denominationalism, Religious Switching, and Denominational Switching: Longitudinal Analysis of the Effects on ReligiosityReview of Religious Research201557125–41
90.
Van OmmerenJosCommuting and Relocation of Jobs and Residences2018New YorkRoutledge
91.
VargasNicholasRetrospective Accounts of Religious Disaffiliation in the United States: Stressors, Skepticism, and Political FactorsSociology of Religion2011732200–223
92.
WrightStuart APost-Involvement Attitudes of Voluntary Defectors from Controversial New Religious MovementsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1984232172–182
93.
WrightStuart ADyadic Intimacy and Social Control in Three Cult MovementsSociology of Religion1986472137–150
94.
WrightStuart AReconceptualizing Cult Coercion and Withdrawal: A Comparative Analysis of Divorce and ApostasySocial Forces1991701125–145
95.
WrightStuart APiperElizabeth SYouth Leaving or Remaining in Deviant Religious GroupsJournal of Marriage and the Family19864815–25
96.
WuthnowRobertThe Restructuring of American Religion: Society and Faith since World War II1988Princeton, NJPrinceton University Press
