Americans who self-identify as spiritual but not religious (SBNR) have increased in recent years. Existing studies of American religion often assume the SBNR as a homogeneous group. Recently some scholars suggest they are not all the same. Instead, SBNR people may differ in the pattern of religious practice, attitude, and affection. This study examines the heterogeneity of the SBNR using a person-centered approach of latent class analysis. We first identified four distinct types of SBNR adolescents in the Wave 2 data of the National Survey of Youth and Religion. Then, we explored how subgroups changed their religious identity over time by tracking them in Wave 3 data.
ArnettJeffrey JensenJensenLene ArnettA congregation of one: Individualized religious beliefs among emerging adultsJournal of Adolescent Research2002175451–46710.1177/0743558402175002
2.
AmmermanNancy TSacred stories, spiritual tribes: Finding religion in everyday life2013New YorkOxford University Press10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199896448.001.0001
3.
AmmermanNancy TSpiritual but not religious? Beyond binary choices in the study of religionJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2013522258–27810.1111/jssr.12024
4.
BartonAlison LBlake SniderJVazsonyiAlexander TCoxJaclyn LayneAdolescent religiosity as a mediator of the relationship between parental religiosity and adolescent health outcomesJournal of Religion and Health201453186–9410.1007/s10943-012-9596-7
5.
BeaudoinTMVirtual faith: The irreverent spiritual quest of Generation X1998San FranciscoJossey-Bass
6.
BellahRobertMadsenRichardSullivanWilliam MSwidlerAHabits of the heart: Individualism and commitment in American life1985BerkeleyUniversity of California Press
7.
Bender, Courtney. 2007. Religion and spirituality: History, discourse, measurement. Social Science Research Council Forum: The Religious Engagements of American Undergraduates. http://religion.ssrc.org/reforum/. Accessed 5 Dec 2017.
8.
BergerPeter LDavieGraceFokasEffieReligious America, secular Europe? A theme and variation2008AldershotAshgate Publishing Ltd
9.
BerghuijsJoantineBakkerCokPieperJosNew spirituality and social engagementJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2013524775–79210.1111/jssr.12062
10.
BruceSteveSecularization and the impotence of individualized religionHedgehog Review200681/235–45
11.
CadgeWendyReflections on ‘habits’, buddhism in America, and religious individualismSociology of Religion2007682201–20510.1093/socrel/68.2.201
12.
CaseyPatricia RCookCI'm spiritual but not religious: Implications for research and practiceSpirituality, theology and mental health: Interdisciplinary perspectives2013LondonSCM Press20–39
13.
ChanMelissaTsaiKim MFuligniAndrew JChanges in religiosity across the transition to young adulthoodJournal of Youth and Adolescence20154481555–156610.1007/s10964-014-0157-0
14.
CollinsLinda MLanzaStephanie TLatent class and latent transition analysis: With applications in the social, behavioral, and health sciences2010HobokenWiley
15.
DavieGraceBergerPeter LEurope: The exception that proves the rule?The desecularization of the world: Resurgent religion and world politics1999Grand RapidsWm. B. Eerdmans Publishing65–83
16.
DillonMicheleWinkPaulFayKristenIs spirituality detrimental to generativity?Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion2003423427–44210.1111/1468-5906.00192
17.
EcklundElaine HowardLeeKristen SchultzAtheists and agnostics negotiate religion and familyJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2011504728–74310.1111/j.1468-5906.2011.01604.x
18.
FlereSergejKirbišAndrejNew age is not inimical to religion and traditionalismJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2009481179–18410.1111/j.1468-5906.2009.01435_3.x
19.
GeorgeLinda KEllisonChristopher GLarsonDavid BExplaining the relationships between religious involvement and healthPsychological Inquiry2002133201–23810.1207/S15327965PLI1303_04
20.
GiordanGiuseppeJuppPCFlanaganKSpirituality: From a religious concept to a sociological theoryA sociology of spirituality: Theology and religion in interdisciplinary perspective2007AldershotAshgate Publishing Ltd.161–180
21.
GoodMarieWilloughbyTeenaBusseriMichael AStability and change in adolescent spirituality/religiosity: A person-centered approachDevelopmental Psychology2011472538–55010.1037/a0021270
22.
GreerBruce ARoofWade Clark“Desperately seeking sheila”: Locating religious privatism in American societyJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion199231346–5210.2307/1387125
23.
HeelasPaulFlanaganKJuppPThe holistic milieu and spirituality: Reflections on Voas and BruceA sociology of spirituality2007AldershotAshgate Publishing Ltd.63–80
24.
HeelasPaulSpiritualities of life: New age romanticism and consumptive capitalism2009HobokenWiley
25.
HillPeter CConceptualizing religion and spirituality: Points of commonality, points of departureJournal for the Theory of Social Behaviour200030151–7710.1111/1468-5914.00119
26.
HodderJacquelineSpirituality and well-being: ‘New age’ and ‘evangelical’ spiritual expressions among young people and their implications for well-beingInternational Journal of Children's Spirituality2009143197–21210.1080/13644360903086463
27.
HoutMichaelFischerClaude SWhy more Americans have no religious preference: Politics and generationsAmerican Sociological Review2002672165–19010.2307/3088891
HoutmanDickMasciniPeterWhy do churches become empty, while new age grows? Secularization and religious change in the NetherlandsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2002413455–47310.1111/1468-5906.00130
30.
HoutmanDickAupersStefThe spiritual turn and the decline of tradition: The spread of post-christian spirituality in 14 western countries, 1981–2000Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion2007463305–32010.1111/j.1468-5906.2007.00360.x
31.
HuijtsTKraaykampGReligious involvement, religious context, and self-assessed health in EuropeJournal of Health and Social Behavior201152191–10610.1177/0022146510394950
32.
JangSung JoonFranzenAaron BIs being “spiritual” enough without being religious? A study of violent and property crimes among emerging adultsCriminology2013513595–62710.1111/1745-9125.12013
KingPamela EbstyneFurrowJames LReligion as a resource for positive youth development: Religion, social capital, and moral outcomesDevelopmental Psychology2004405703–71310.1037/0012-1649.40.5.703
35.
KoenigLaura BMcGueMattIaconoWilliam GStability and change in religiousness during emerging adulthoodDevelopmental Psychology2008442532–54310.1037/0012-1649.44.2.532
36.
LimChaeyoonMacGregorCarol AnnPutnamRobert DSecular and liminal: Discovering heterogeneity among religious nonesJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2010494596–61810.1111/j.1468-5906.2010.01533.x
LippyCharles HBeing religious, American style: A history of popular religiosity in the United States1994WestportPraeger Publishers
39.
LynchGordonThe new spirituality: An introduction to progressive belief in the twenty-first century2007LondonI.B.Tauris
40.
ManningChristel JUnaffiliated parents and the religious training of their childrenSociology of Religion: A Quarterly Review2013742149–17510.1093/socrel/srs072
41.
MarlerPenny LongKirk HadawayCToward a typology of protestant “marginal members”Review of Religious Research199335134–5410.2307/3511059
42.
MarlerPenny LongKirk HadawayC“Being religious” or “being spiritual” in America: A zero-sum proposition?Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion200223289–30010.1111/1468-5906.00117
43.
McClurePKSomething besides monotheism: Sociotheological boundary work among the spiritual, but not religiousPoetics20176253–6510.1016/j.poetic.2017.01.001
44.
McGuireMeredith BLived religion: Faith and practice in everyday life2008New YorkOxford University Press10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195172621.001.0001
45.
MercadanteLinda ABelief without borders: Inside the minds of the spiritual but not religious2014New YorkOxford University Press10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199931002.001.0001
46.
NylundKaren LAsparoutiovTihomirMuthenBengt ODeciding on the number of classes in latent class analysis and growth mixture modeling: A Monte Carlo simulation studyStructural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal2007144535–56910.1080/10705510701575396
47.
OhSSarkisianNSpiritual individualism or engaged spirituality? Social implications of holistic spirituality among mind-body-spirit practitionersSociology of Religion2012733299–32210.1093/socrel/srr054
48.
PearceLisa DMichael FosterEHardieJessica HallidayA person-centered examination of adolescent religiosity using latent class analysisJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion201352157–7910.1111/jssr.12001
49.
PettitAndrewSpiritual but not religious: Understanding new forms of spirituality, community, and worship through the musical practice of kirtanInternational Journal of Religion & Spirituality in Society20143313–1810.18848/2154-8633/CGP/v03i03/51058
PowellLynda HShahabiLeilaThoresenCarl EReligion and spirituality: Linkages to physical healthThe American Psychologist200358136–5210.1037/0003-066X.58.1.36
54.
RoofWade ClarkModernity, the religious, and the spiritualAmerican Academy of Political and Social Science19985581211–22410.1177/0002716298558001016
55.
RoofWade ClarkMcKinneyWilliamAmerican mainline religion: Its changing shape and future1987New BrunswickRutgers University Press
56.
SaroglouVassilisReligious bricolage as a psychological reality: Limits, structures and dynamicsSocial Compass2006531109–11510.1177/0037768606061581
57.
SaucierGerardSkrzypińskaKatarzynaSpiritual but not religious? Evidence for two independent dispositionsJournal of Personality20067451257–129210.1111/j.1467-6494.2006.00409.x
58.
SeidlitzLarryDevelopment of the spiritual transcendence indexJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2002413439–45310.1111/1468-5906.00129
SmithChristianDentonMelinda LundquistSoul searching: The religious and spiritual lives of american teenagers2005New YorkOxford University Press10.1093/019518095X.001.0001
63.
SmithChristianSnellPatriciaSouls in transition: The religious and spiritual lives of emerging adults2009New YorkOxford University Press10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195371796.001.0001
64.
TeinJenn-YunCoxeStefanyChamHeiningStatistical power to detect the correct number of classes in latent profile analysisStructural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal2013204640–65710.1080/10705511.2013.824781
65.
VoasDavidChavesMarkIs the United States a counterexample to the secularization thesis?American Journal of Sociology201612151–4010.1086/684202
66.
WagenerLinda MansFurrowJames LKingPamela EbstyneLeffertNancyBensonPeterReligious involvement and developmental resources in youthReview of Religious Research2003443271–28410.2307/3512387
67.
WilcoxMelissa MWhen Sheila's a lesbian: Religious individualism lesbian, gay, bisexual, among and transgender ChristiansSociology of Religion2002634497–51310.2307/3712304
68.
WinkPaulDillonMicheleFayKristenSpiritual seeking, narcissism, and psychotherapy: How are they related?Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion2005442143–15810.1111/j.1468-5906.2005.00272.x
69.
WinkPaulDillonMichele MichellePrettymanAdrienneReligiousness, spiritual seeking, and authoritarianism: Findings from a longitudinal studyJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2007465321–33510.1111/j.1468-5906.2007.00361.x
70.
WoodheadLindaTrends in church life: The spiritual turnTheology of Scotland2005725–22
71.
WuthnowRobertAfter heaven: Spirituality in America since the 1950s1998BerkeleyUniversity of California Press10.1525/california/9780520213968.001.0001
72.
ZinnbauerBrian JPargamentKenneth IScottAllie BThe emerging meanings of religiousness and spirituality: Problems and prospectsJournal of Personality1999676889–91910.1111/1467-6494.00077
73.
ZinnbauerBrian JPargamentKenneth IColeBrendaRyeMark SButterEric MBelavichTimothy GHippKathleen MScottAllie BKadarJill LReligion and spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzyJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion1997364549–56410.2307/1387689
