This study explores the impact megachurches have on local and extra-local congregations. Arguing that the two commonly held theories concerning the effect of megachurches on local congregations—that they are either harmful because they undercut local competition, or are beneficial because they increase local competition—are under-specified, we add the concept of religious niches to an organizational ecology model to predict how megachurches will differentially impact local congregations of various affiliation. Following new methodological directions charted by Blanchard et al. (Soc Forces 86(4):1591–1620, 2008), we test how the presence of megachurches differentially impacts congregational change rates among Catholics, Mainline Protestants, Conservative Protestants and three disaggregated Conservative Protestant sub-groups—Evangelical, Pentecostal and Fundamentalists, using county-level data from the 1990 and 2000 Churches and Church Membership datasets and megachurch data from the Database of Megachurches in the US. We find support for the variable impact of megachurches on local congregations in differing niches. For local congregations in dissimilar niches the presence of megachurches seems to be beneficial, whereas for local congregations inhabiting similar niches the presence of megachurches seems to be harmful. In addition to the local impact of megachurches, we find that they also have an impact upon the vitality of congregations in neighboring counties.
BeyerleinKraigSpecifying the impact of Conservative Protestantism on educational attainmentJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2004344505–518
4.
BlanchardTroyIrwinMichaelTolbertCharlesLysonThomasNucciAlfredSuburban sprawl, regional diffusion, and the fate of small retailers in a large retail environment, 1977–1996Sociological Focus2003364313–331
5.
BlanchardTroyBartkowskiJohn PMatthewsTodd LKerleyKent RFaith, morality and mortality: The ecological impact of religion on population healthSocial Forces20088641591–1620
6.
BorgonoviFrancescaDivided we stand, united we fall: Religious pluralism, giving and volunteeringAmerican Sociological Review200873105–128
7.
Brown, Patricia Leigh. 2002. Megachurches as minitowns. The New York Times, May 9.
8.
BruceSteveGod is dead: Secularization in the west2002OxfordBlackwell
9.
CarrollGlenn RConcentration and specialization: Dynamics of niche width in populations of organizationsAmerican Journal of Sociology19859061262–1283
10.
ChavesMark2005 H. Paul Douglass lecture: All creatures great and small: Megachurches in contextReview of Religious Research2006474329–346
11.
ChavesMarkGorskiPhillipReligious pluralism and religious participationAnnual Review of Sociology200127261–281
12.
ConellCarolVossKimFormal organization and the fate of social movements; craft association and class alliance in the Knights of LaborAmerican Sociological Review199055255–269
13.
DeanAndrea MSobelRussell SHas WalMart buried mom and pop?Regulation200831138–45
DeWeese-BoydMargaretCommunity versus development? Land Use and development policy in Vermont as a tool toward community viabilityCommunity Development Journal2006413334–351
16.
EieslandNancy LA particular place2000New BrunswickRutgers University Press
17.
EllingsonStephenThe megachurch and the mainline2007ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
HannanMichaelFreemanJohnOrganizational ecology1989CambridgeHarvard University Press
20.
HannanMichaelCarrollGlenn RDynamics of organizational populations1992New YorkOxford University Press
21.
GillAnthonyRendering unto Caesar: The Catholic Church and the state in Latin America1998ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
22.
KarnesKimberlyMcIntochWayneMorrisIrwinPearson-MerkowitzShannaMighty fortresses: Explaining the spatial distribution of American megachurchesJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2007462261–268
23.
McGeeJefferyRubachMichael JResponding to increased environmental hostility: A study of the competitive behavior of small retailersJournal of Applied Business Research199713183–94
24.
McPhersonJ MillerA dynamic model of voluntary affiliationSocial Forces198159705–728
25.
McPhersonJ MillerSmith-LovinLynnHomophily in voluntary organization: Status distance and the composition of face to face groupsAmerican Sociological Review198757153–170
26.
MinkoffDebra CThe organization of survival: Women's and racial-ethnic voluntarist and activist organizations, 1955–1985Social Forces199371887–908
27.
MinkoffDebra CFrom service provision to institutional advocacy: The shifting legitimacy of organizational formsSocial Forces1994724943–969
28.
NuemarkDavidZhangJunfuCiccarellaStevenThe effects of WalMart on local labor marketsJournal of Urban Economics2008632405–430
29.
OlzakSusanWestElizabethEthnic conflict and the rise and fall of ethnic newspapersAmerican Sociological Review199156458–474
30.
PopielarzPamela AMcPhersonJ MillerOn the edge or in between: Niche position, niche overlap, and the duration of voluntary association membershipsAmerican Journal of Sociology1995101698–720
31.
ScheitleChristopher PDoughertyKevin PDensity and growth in a congregational population: Reformed churches in New York, 1628–2000Review of Religious Research2008493233–250
32.
SitesWilliamBeyond grassroots? Reflections on urban mobilization, fragmentation, and the anti-WalMart campaign in ChicagoEnvironment and Planning200739112632–2651
33.
SmithChristianChristian America? What Evangelicals really want2000BerkeleyUniversity of California Press
34.
Smith, Christian, with Michael Emerson, Sally Gallagher, Paul Kennedy, and David Sikkink. 1998. American Evangelicalism: Embattled and thriving. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
35.
StarkRodneyFinkeRogerActs of faith2000BerkeleyUniversity of California Press
36.
StarkRodneyFinkeRogerReligions in context: The response of non-Mormon faiths in UtahReview of Religious Research2004453293–298
37.
SteenslandBrianParkJerry ZRegenerusMark DRobinsonLynn DBradford WilcoxWWoodberryRobert DThe measurement of American religion: Toward improving the state of the artSocial Forces2000791291–318
ThummaScottPetersenJimCiminoRichardGoliaths in our Midst: Megachurches in the ELCALutherans today: American Lutheran identity in the twenty-first century2003Grand RapidsEerdmans102–124
42.
ThummaScottTravisDaveBeyond megachurch myths: What we can learn from America's largest churches2007San FranciscoJossey Bass
43.
Tucker-Worgs, Tamelyn N. 2011. The black megachurch: Theology, gender, and the politics of public engagement. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press.
44.
VoasDavidOlsonDaniel VACrockettAlasdairReligious pluralism and participation: Why previous research is wrongAmerican Sociological Review200267212–230
45.
VolpeRichard JIIILavoieNathalieThe effect of WalMart super centers on grocery prices in New EnglandReview of Agricultural Economics20083014–26
46.
WarrenDorian TWalMart surrounded: Community alliances and labor politics in ChicagoNew Labor Forum200514317–23
47.
WellmanJames KEvangelical vs. liberal: The clash of Christian cultures in the Pacific Northwest2008New YorkOxford University Press
48.
WoodberryRobert DSmithChristian SFundamentalism et al.: Conservative Protestants in AmericaAnnual Review of Sociology199824125–56
