In recent years a number of studies have explored possible sources of nonrandom error and response bias in survey data on religion. Building on a longstanding body of work in the social sciences, we examine a neglected issue in this domain: the potential for race-of-interviewer effects, specifically in African Americans’ self-reports of various dimensions of religiousness. After outlining two competing perspectives on this issue—which we term racial deference and racial solidarity—we test relevant hypotheses using data from the African American oversample of a nationwide study of older adults. Results indicate that older blacks tend to report higher levels of non-organizational religious practices and subjective religiousness when interviewed by whites. A number of implications and promising directions for future research are discussed.
AikenLeona SWestStephen GMultiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions1991Newbury Park, CASage.
2.
AndersonBarbara ASilverBrian DMeasurement and mismeasurement of the validity of the self-reported voteAmerican Journal of Political Science198630771–785.
3.
AndersonBarbara ASilverBrian DAbramsonPaul RThe effects of race of the interviewer on measures of electoral participation by Blacks in SRC National Election StudiesPublic Opinion Quarterly19885253–83.
4.
AndersonBarbara ASilverBrian DAbramsonPaul RThe effects of the race of the interviewer on race-related attitudes of Black respondents in SRC/CPS National Election StudiesPublic Opinion Quarterly198852289–324.
5.
BiermanAlexDoes religion buffer the effects of discrimination on mental health? Differing effects by raceJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion200645551–565.
6.
BillingsleyAndrewMighty like a river: The Black church and social reform1999New YorkOxford University Press.
7.
BrennanKathleen MLondonAndrew SAre religious people nice people? Religiosity, race, interview dynamics, and perceived cooperativenessSociological Inquiry200171129–144.
8.
CarrLeslie GThe Srole items and acquiescenceAmerican Sociological Review197136287–293.
9.
CotterPatrick RCohenJeffreyCoulterPhilip BRace-of-interviewer effects in telephone interviewsPublic Opinion Quarterly198246278–284.
10.
CrownePDMarloweDA new scale of social desirability independent of psychopathologyJournal of Consulting Psychology196024349–354.
11.
DavisDarren WNonrandom measurement error and race of interviewer effects among African AmericansPublic Opinion Quarterly199761183–207.
12.
DavisDarren WThe direction of race of interviewer effects among African Americans donning the black maskAmerican Journal of Political Science199741309–322.
13.
Davis, James A., Tom W. Smith, and Peter V. Marsden. 2008. The General Social Survey: Cumulative codebook, 1972–2008. Chicago: National Opinion Research Center. Machine-readable data file [MRDF] distributed by Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR), Ann Arbor, MI.
14.
EhrlichJune SRiesmanDavidAge and authority in the interviewPublic Opinion Quarterly19612539–56.
15.
EllisonRalphInvisible man1947New YorkThe New American Library.
16.
EllisonChristopher GIdentification and separatism: Religious involvement and racial orientations among Black AmericansThe Sociological Quarterly199132477–494.
17.
EllisonChristopher GAre religious people nice people? Evidence from the National Survey of Black AmericansSocial Forces199271411–430.
18.
EllisonChristopher GMusickMarc AHendersonAndrea KBalm in Gilead: Racism, religious involvement, and psychological distress in a nationwide sample of African American adultsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion200847291–309.
19.
EllisonChristopher GSherkatDarren EThe ‘semi-involuntary institution’ revisited: Regional variations in church participation among Black AmericansSocial Forces1995731415–1437.
20.
FirebaughGlennDavisKenneth ETrends in anti-black prejudice, 1972–1984: Region and cohort effectsAmerican Journal of Sociology198894251–272.
21.
HadawayC KirkLong MarlerPennyChavesMarkWhat the polls don't show: The overreporting of church attendanceAmerican Sociological Review199358641–662.
22.
HarrisFredrick CSomething within: Religion in African American political activism1999New YorkOxford University Press.
23.
HatchettShirleySchumanHowardWhite respondents and race-of-interviewer effectsPublic Opinion Quarterly197539523–528.
24.
HoutMichaelGreeleyAndrewWhat church officials’ reports don't show: Another look at church attendance dataAmerican Sociological Review199863113–119.
25.
HuntMatthew OHuntLarry LRegional religions? Extending the semi involuntary thesis of African American religious participationSociological Forum200015569–594.
26.
HymanHerbert HCobbWilliam JFeldmanJacob JHartClyde WInterviewing in social research1954ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press.
27.
IannacconeLaurence REvertonSean FNever on sunny days: Lessons from weekly attendance countsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion200443191–207.
28.
IdlerEllen LMusickMarc AEllisonChristopher GGeorgeLinda KKrauseNealLevinJeffrey SOryMarciaPargamentKenneth IPowellLynda SWilliamsDavid RUnderwoodLynn GMeasuring multiple dimensions of religion and spirituality for health-related research: Conceptual background and findings from the 1998 General Social SurveyResearch on Aging200325327–365.
29.
JohnsonCharles SGrowing up in the black belt1941ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press.
30.
KaneEmily WMacaulayLaura JInterviewer gender and gender attitudesPublic Opinion Quarterly1993571–28.
31.
KluegelJames RTrends in Whites’ explanations of the Black-White gap in socioeconomic status, 1977–1989American Sociological Review199055512–525.
32.
KrauseNealA comprehensive strategy for developing closed-ended survey items for use in studies of older adultsJournal of Gerontology: Social Sciences200257BS263–S274.
33.
KrauseNealCommon facets of religion, unique facets of religion, and life satisfaction among older African AmericansJournal of Gerontology: Social Sciences200459BS109–S117.
34.
KrauseNealAging in the church: How social relationships affect health2008West Conshohocken, PAJohn Templeton Foundation Press.
35.
KrysanMariaCouperMick PRace in the live and virtual interview: Racial deference, social desirability, and activation effects in attitude surveysSocial Psychology Quarterly200366364–383.
36.
LandisJudsonSullivanDarylSheleyJosephFeminist attitudes related to sex of interviewerPacific Sociological Review197316305–314.
37.
LevinJeffrey STaylorRobert JChattersLinda MA multidimensional model of religiosity among Black AmericansThe Sociological Quarterly199536157–173.
38.
LewisHylanBlackways of Kent1955Chapel HillUniversity of North Carolina Press.
39.
LincolnC EricMamiyaLawrence HThe Black church in the African American experience1990Durham, NCDuke University Press.
40.
LueptowLloyd BMoserSusan LPendletonBrian FGender and response effects in telephone interviews about gender characteristicsSex Roles19902229–42.
41.
McDanielEric LPolitics in the Pews: The political mobilization of Black churches2008Ann Arbor, MIUniversity of Michigan Press.
42.
MorganS PhilipA research note on religion and morality: Are religious people nice people?Social Forces198361683–692.
43.
MorrisAldonSmithChristianThe Black church in the civil rights movement: The SCLC as the decentralized radical arm of the Black churchDisruptive religion: The force of faith in social movement activism1996New YorkRoutledge29–46.
44.
NelsenHart MYokleyRaytha LNelsenAnne KBlack church in the sixties1971Lexington, KYUniversity Press of Kentucky.
45.
PaulhusDelroy LRobinsonJohn PShaverPhillip RWrightsmanLawrence SMeasurement and control of response biasMeasures of personality and social psychological attitudes1991San DiegoAcademic Press17–59.
46.
PresserStanleyStinsonLindaData collection mode and social desirability bias in self-reported religious attendanceAmerican Sociological Review199863137–145.
47.
RegnerusMark DSmithChristianSelection effects in studies of religious influenceReview of Religious Research20054723–50.
48.
RegnerusMark DUeckerJeremyReligious influences on sensitive behaviors: The product of social desirability, deceit, or embarrassment?Sociology of Religion200768145–163.
SchaefferNora CEvaluating race-of-interviewer effects in a national surveySociological Methods and Research19808400–419.
51.
SchumanHowardConverseJeanThe effects of Black and White interviewers on Black responses in 1968Public Opinion Quarterly19713544–68.
52.
SherkatDarren EReligion and survey non-response: Toward explaining the moral voter gap between surveys and votingSociology of Religion20076883–95.
53.
SherkatDarren ECunninghamShannon AExtending the semi-involuntary institution: Regional variations and social constraints on private religious consumption among African AmericansJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion199837383–396.
54.
SilverBrian DAbramsonPaul RAndersonBarbara AThe presence of others and over-reporting of voting in American national electionsPublic Opinion Quarterly198650228–239.
55.
SingerEleanorFrankelMartin RGlassmanMarc BThe effect of interviewer characteristics and expectations on responsePublic Opinion Quarterly19834768–83.
56.
SmithA WadeEducation as a determinant of social class among Black AmericansJournal of Negro Education198958416–429.
57.
SnidermanPaul MPiazzaThomasThe scar of race1993Cambridge, MAHarvard University Press.
58.
StarkRodneyGlockCharles YAmerican piety1968BerkeleyUniversity of California Press.
59.
SudmanSeymourBradburnNormanSchwarzNorbertThinking about answers: The application of cognitive processes to survey methodology1996San FranciscoJossey-Brass.
60.
TaylorRobert JChattersLinda MLevinJeffrey SReligion in the lives of African Americans2004Thousand Oaks, CASage.
61.
TuckerClydeInterviewer effects in telephone surveysPublic Opinion Quarterly19834784–95.
62.
UeckerJeremyReligious and spiritual responses to 9/11: Evidence from the Add Health StudySociological Spectrum200828477–509.
63.
WoodberryRobert DWhen surveys lie and people tell the truth: How surveys oversample church attendersAmerican Sociological Review199863119–122.
