This paper critically assesses the empirical evidence on the relationship between immigration and African American employment. Studies using various methodologies and data are reviewed: natural experiments, time series, and cross-sectional studies of local labor markets and intertemporal changes in the national labor market. We find that for African Americans as a whole, immigration may have little effect on mean wages and probability of employment. However, there is some evidence that immigration may have had an adverse impact on the labor market outcomes of African Americans belonging to low education-experience groups. However, even this modest conclusion must be qualified: the literature has many unresolved econometric issues that might easily undermine the received wisdom.
AddyS.A cost-benefit analysis of the new Alabama immigration law.Tuscaloosa: Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Alabama; 2012.
2.
AltonjiJ.G., CardD.The effects of immigration on labor market outcomes of less-skilled natives. In: AbowdJ.M., FreemanR.B., editors. Immigration, trade and the labor market.Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1991. p. 201–34.
3.
AydemirA., BorjasG.Attenuation bias in measuring the wage impact of immigration.J Labor Econ.2011; 29: 69–112.
4.
BorjasG.J.The analytic of the wage effect of immigration. In: National Bureau of Economic Research, Working paper 14796. 2009. www.nber.org/papers/w14796.
5.
BorjasG.J.The labor demand curve is downward sloping: reexamining the impact of immigration on the labor market.Q J Econ.2003; 118: 1335–74.
6.
BorjasG.J., GroggerJ., HansonG.H.Immigration and the economic status of African-American men.Economica.2010; 77(306): 255–82.
7.
ButcherK.F.Black immigrants to United States: a comparison with native blacks and other immigrants.Ind Labor Relat Rev.1994; 47: 265–84.
8.
CardD.Immigration and inequality.Am Econ Rev.2009; 99: 1–21.
9.
CardD.Immigration inflows, native outflows, and the local labor market immigrants of higher immigration.J Labor Econ.2001; 19(1): 22–64.
10.
CardD.The impact of the Mariel boatlift on the Miami labor market.Ind Labor Relat Rev.1990; 43(2): 245–57.
11.
DustmannC., PrestonI.Comment: estimating the effect of immigration on wages.J Eur Econ Assoc.2012; 10(1): 216–23.
12.
DustmannC., FrattiniT., PrestonI.The effect of immigration along the distribution of wages.Rev Econ Stud.2013; 80(1): 145–73.
13.
FriedbergR.M., HuntJ.The impact of immigrants on host country wages, employment and growth.J Econ Perspect.1995; 9: 23–44.
14.
GastonN., NelsonD.The employment and wage effects of immigration: an overview of theory, method and results.Globalisation and Development Centre.2007. Available at: http://works.bepress.com/noel_gaston/5.
15.
GrossmanJ.B.The substitutability of natives and immigrants in production.Rev Econ Stat.1982; 64: 596–603.
16.
KerrS.P., KerrW.R.Economic impacts of immigration: a survey.Boston: Harvard Business School; 2011.
17.
LaLondeR.J., TopelR.H.Labor market adjustments to increased immigration. In: AbowdJ.M., FreemanR.B., editors. Immigration, trade and the labor market.Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1991. p. 167–99.
18.
LonghiS., NijkampP., PootP.The economic impact of immigration on the labor market of host countries – meta-analytic evidence.2011. Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, TI 2011–103/3.
19.
LonghiS., NijkampP., PootP.The fallacy of “job robbing”: a meta-analysis of estimates of the effect of immigration on employment.2009. Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper.
MasonP.Race, competition and differential wages.Camb J Econ.1995; 19(4): 545–68.
22.
ModelS.West Indian immigrants: a black success story?New York: Russell Sage; 2008.
23.
OttavianoG., PeriG.Rethinking the effects of immigration on wages.J Eur Econ Assoc.2012; 10(1): 152–97.
24.
ReedD., DanzigerS.The effects of immigration on racial/ethnic labor market differentials.Am Econ Rev.2007; 97: 373–7.
25.
StevansL.K.The relationship among African American male earnings, employment, incarceration and immigration: a time series approach.Rev Black Polit Econ.2009; 36(3): 151–60.
26.
StevansL.K.Assessing the effect of the occupational crowding of immigrants on the real wages of African American workers.Rev Black Polit Econ.1998; 26(2): 37–46.
27.
StewartJ.B., HyclakT.J.The effects of immigrants, women, and teenagers on the relative earnings of black males.Rev Black Polit Econ.1986; 15(1): 93–101.
