The purpose of this review was to assess the current evidence supporting operative fixation versus casting for acute scaphoid fractures through a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature. Results Our search yielded 59 articles that met our inclusion criteria with five studies achieving high, 22 moderate, and 32 low Structured Effectiveness Quality Evaluation Scale scores. Pooled results of the four Sackett level 1 evidence studies showed no significant difference between the operative (114/115, 99%) versus non-operative group (106/112, 95%) (p=0.07) when the definition of nonunion was based on more definitive criterion versus plain radiographs that may be insufficient to assess bony union. Similar results were found for the Sackett level 2 and 4 articles.
Conclusions
This systematic review reveals that significant weaknesses exist in the literature with respect to the level of evidence and quality of published studies on this topic. Currently, there is insufficient evidence to support the most effective treatment for acute scaphoid fractures.
AdolfssonLLindauTArnerM. Acutrak screw fixation versus cast immobilization for undisplaced scaphoid waist fractures. J Hand Surg [Br].2001;26B(3):192–5.
2.
AroraRGschwentnerMKrappingerDLutzMBlauthMGablM. Fixation of nondisplaced scaphoid fractures: making treatment cost effective: prospective controlled trial. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg.2007;127:39–46.
3.
BediAJebsonPJLHaydenRJJacobsonJAMartusJE. Internal fixation of acute, non-displaced scaphoid waist fracture via a limited dorsal approach: an assessment of radiographic and functional outcomes. J Hand Surg.2007;32A:326–33.
4.
BondCDShinAYMcBrideMTDaoKD. Percutaneous screw fixation or cast immobilization for nondisplaced scaphoid fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Am.2001;83A(4):483–8.
5.
BrutusJPBaetenYChahidiNKinnenLMoermansJPLedouxP. Percutaneous Herbert screw fixation for fractures of the scaphoid: review of 30 cases. Chir Main.2002;21:350–4.
6.
BushnellBDMcWilliamsADMesserTM. Complications in dorsal percutaneous cannulated screw fixaton of nondisplaced scaphoid waist fractures. J Hand Surg.2007;32A(6):827–33.
7.
CaloiaMFGallinoRNCaloiaHRivarolaH. Incidence of ligamentous and other injuries associated with scaphoid fractures during arthroscopically assisted reduction and percutaneous fixation. Arthroscopy.2008;24(7):754–9.
8.
ChenACYChaoEKHungSSLeeMSSUengSWN. Percutaneous screw fixation for unstable scaphoid fractures. J Trauma.2005;59(1):184–7.
9.
ChristodoulouLChamberlainST. Internal fixation of scaphoid fractures with an AO mini-fragment lag screw, using temporary interoperative AO mini external fixation. J Hand Surg Br.1999;24B(6):676–8.
10.
ChungKC. A simplified approach for unstable scaphoid fracture fixation using the Acutrak screw. Plast Reconstr Surg.2002;110 (7):1697–703.
11.
ClayNRDiasJJCostiganPSGreggPJBartonNJ. Need the thumb be immobilized in scaphoid fractures? J Bone Joint Surg Br.1991;73B:828–32.
12.
De VosJVandenbergheD. Acute percutaneous scaphoid fixation using a non-cannulated Herbert screw. Chir Main.2003;22:78–83.
13.
DiasJJWildinCJBhowalBThompsonJR. Should acute scaphoid fractures be fixed? J Bone Joint Surg Am.2005;87A (10):2160–8.
14.
DiasJJDhukaramVAbhinavABhowalBWildinCJ. Clinical and radiological outcome of cast immobilisation versus surgical treatment of acute scaphoid fractures at a mean follow-up of 93 months. J Bone Joint Surg Br.2008;90(7):899–905.
15.
Dos ReisFBKoeberleGLeiteNMKatchburianMV. Internal fixation of scaphoid injuries using the Herbert screw through a dorsal approach. J Hand Surg.1993;18A:792–7.
16.
DracPManakPLabonekI. Percutaneous osteosynthesis versus cast immobilization for the treatment of minimally and non-displaced scaphoid fractures: functional outcomes after a follow-up of at least 12 month. Biomed Papers.2005;149 (1):149–51.
17.
DuppeHJohnellOLudborgGKarlssonMRedlund-JohnellI. Long-term results of fracture of the scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1994;76A(2):249–52.
18.
FilanSLHerbertTJ. Herbert screw fixation of scaphoid fractures. J Bone Joint Surg.1996;78B(4):519–29.
19.
FusettiCGaravagliaGPapaloizosMYWasserfallenJBBuchlerUNagyL. Direct and indirect costs in the conservative management of undisplaced scaphoid fractures. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol.2003;13:241–4.
20.
GellmanHCaputoRJCarterVAboulafiaAMcKayM. Comparison of short arm and long thumb-spica casts for non-displaced fractures of the carpal scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1989;71A(3):354–7.
21.
GunalIOztunaVSeberS. Trapezio-lunate external fixation for scaphoid fractures: an experimental and clinical study. J Hand Surg Br.1994;19B:759–62.
22.
GunalYOztunaVOzcelikAKoseNTurgutAGokturkEMedium-term results of trapezio-lunate external fixation for scaphoid fractures. J Hand Surg Br.2002;27B(5):410–2.
23.
HaddadFSGoddardNJ. Acute percutaneous scaphoid fixation using a cannulated screw. Ann Chir Main.1998;17(2):119–26.
24.
HaddadFSGoddardNJ. Acute percutaneous scaphoid fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Br.1998;80B(1):95–9.
25.
HambidgeJEDesaiVVSchranzPJCompsonJPDavisTRCBartonNJ. Acute fractures of the scaphoid: treatment by cast immobilization with the wrist in flexion or extension. J Bone Joint Surg Br.1999;81B(1):91–2.
26.
HarnimanECaretteSKennedyCBeatonD. Extracorporeal shock wave therapy for calcific and noncalcific tendonitis of the rotator cuff: a systematic review. J Hand Ther.2004;17:132–51.
27.
HoveLM. Epidemiology of scaphoid fractures in Bergen, Norway. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg Hand Surg.1999;33:423–6.
28.
InoueGShionoyaK. Herbert screw fixation by limited access for acute factures of the scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Br.1997;79B:418–21.
29.
JeonIHOhCWParkBCIhnJCKimPT. Minimal invasive percutaneous Herbert screw fixation in acute unstable scaphoid fracture. Hand Surg.2003;8(2):213–8.
30.
KhanFAAl HarbyS. Fresh scaphoid fractures (analysis of 45 cases). Afr J Med Med Sci.1995;24:201–6.
31.
KorkalaOLKuokkanenHOEerolaMS. Compression-staple fixation for fractures, nonunions, and delayed unions of the carpal scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1992;74:423–6.
32.
KujalaSRaatikainenTKaarelaOAshammakhiNRyhanenJ. Successful treatment of scaphoid fractures and nonunions using bioabsorbable screws: report of six cases. J Hand Surg.2004;29A:68–73.
33.
LindstromGNystromA. Incidence of post-traumatic arthrosis after primary healing of scaphoid fractures: a clinical and radiological study. J Hand Surg Br.1990;15B:11–3.
34.
McQueenMMGelbkeMKWakefieldAWillEMGaeblerC. Percutaneous screw fixation versus conservative treatment for fractures of the waist of the scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Br.2008;90B(1):66–71.
35.
MeermansGVerstrekenF. Percutaneous transtrapezial fixation of acute scaphoid fractures. J Hand Surg Eur.2008;33(6):791–6.
36.
MoranRCurtinJ. Scaphoid fractures treated by Herbert screw fixation. J Hand Surg.1988;13B(4):453–5.
37.
MullerMTsuiDSchnurrRBiddulph-DeisrothLHardJMacDermidJC. Effectiveness of hand therapy interventions in primary management of carpal tunnel syndrome: a systematic review. J Hand Ther.2004;17:210–28.
38.
MüllerMGermannGSauerbierM. Minimal invasive screw fixation and early mobilization of acute scaphoid fractures in the middle third: operative technique and early functional outcome. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg.2008;12(2):107–13.
39.
PapaloizosMYFusettiCChristenTNagyLWaserfallenJB. Minimally invasive fixation versus conservative treatment of undisplaced scaphoid fractures: a cost-effectiveness study. J Hand Surg Br.2004;29B(2):116–9.
40.
RaudasojaLRawlinsMKallioPVaseniusJ. Conservative treatment of scaphoid fractures: a follow-up study. Ann Chir Gynaecol.1999;88:289–93.
41.
RettigACWeidenbenerEJGloyeskeR. Alternative management of midthird scaphoid fractures in the athlete. Am J Sports Med.1994;22(5):711–4.
42.
RettigACKolliasSC. Internal fixation of acute stable scaphoid fractures in the athlete. Am J Sports Med.1996;24 (2):182–6.
43.
RettigMERaskinKB. Retrograde compression screw fixation of acute proximal pole scaphoid fractures. J Hand Surg.1999;24A:1206–10.
44.
RettigMEKozinSHCooneyWP. Open reduction and internal fixation of acute displaced scaphoid waist fractures. J Hand Surg.2001;26A:271–6.
45.
RoolkerWMaasMBroekhuizenAH. Diagnosis and treatment of scaphoid fractures, can nonunion be prevented? Arch Orthop Trauma Surg.1999;119:428–31.
46.
SaedenBTornkvistHPonzerSHoglundM. Fracture of the carpal scaphoid: a prospective, randomized 12-year follow-up comparing operative and conservative treatment. J Bone Joint Surg Br.2001;83B(2):230–4.
47.
ShihJTLeeHMHouYTTanCM. Results of arthroscopic reduction and percutaneous fixation for acute displaced scaphoid fractures. Arthroscopy.2005;21(5):620–6.
48.
SinghHPForwardDDavisTRCDawsonJSOniJADowningND. Partial union of acute scaphoid fractures. J Hand Surg Br.2005;30B(5):440–5.
49.
SladeJFIIIGutowAPGeisslerWB. Percutaneous internal fixation of scaphoid fractures via an arthroscopically assisted dorsal approach. J Bone Joint Surg.2002;84:21–36.
50.
SladeJFIIIGillonT. Retrospective review of 234 scaphoid fractures and nonunions treated with arthroscopy for union and complications. Scand J Surg.2008;97(4):280–9.
51.
SladeJFLozano-CalderónSMerrellGRingD. Arthroscopic-assisted percutaneous reduction and screw fixation of displaced scaphoid fractures. J Hand Surg Eur.2008;33(3):350–4.
52.
SmithJTKeeveJPBertinKCMannRJ. Simultaneous fractures of the distal radius and scaphoid. J Trauma.1988;28(5):676–9.
53.
SmithKHelmRTonkinMA. The Herbert screw for the treatment of scaphoid fractures. Ann Chir Main Memb Supér.1991;10(6):556–63.
54.
TerkelsenCJJepsenJM. Treatment of scaphoid fractures with a removable cast. Acta Ortho Scand.1988;59(4):452–3.
55.
TrumbleTEBenirschkeSKVedderNB. Ipsilateral fractures of the scaphoid and radius. J Hand Surg.1993;18A:8–14.
56.
TrumbleTEGilbertMMurrayLWSmithJMcCallisterWV. Displaced scaphoid fractures treated with open reduction and internal fixation with a cannulated screw. J Bone Joint Surg.2000;82:633–41.
57.
TuYKChenACChouYCUengSWMaCHYenCY. Treatment for scaphoid fracture and nonunion—the application of 3.0 mm cannulated screws and pedicle vascularised bone grafts. Injury.2008;39 Suppl 4:96–106.
58.
VinnarsBAf EkenstamFGerdinB. Comparison of direct and indirect costs of internal fixation and cast treatment in acute scaphoid fractures: a randomized trial involving 52 patients. Acta Orthop.2007;78(5):672–9.
59.
VinnarsBPietreanuMBodestedtAEkenstamFGerdinB. Nonoperative compared with operative treatment of acute scaphoid fractures. A randomized clinical trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am.2008;90(6):1176–85.
60.
VukovVRisticKStevanovicMBumbasirevicM. Simultaneous fractures of the distal end of the radius and the scaphoid bone. J Orthop Trauma.1988;2(2):120–3.
61.
WozasekGEMoserKD. Percutaneous screw fixation for fractures of the scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg.1991;73B (1):138–42.
62.
YinZGZhangJBKanSLWangP. Treatment of scaphoid fractures: systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res.2007;460:142–51.
63.
YipHSFWuWCChangRYPSoTYC. Percutaneous cannulated screw fixation of acute scaphoid waist fracture. J Hand Surg Br.2002;27B(1):42–6.
